A post in another thread had me wondering if my opinions match the masses. I'm curious what scenarios from each cycle you love, and which ones you dread. I'll go first
Night if the Zealot
Best: Midnight Masks
It's still fun. Chasing down the cultists, the unique way to dispose of them all. Even better in return when you have even less clue where or who you need to get to.
Worst: The Gathering
Just boring. The other two are just better. But it's the intro scenario, so I get why.
The Dunwich Legacy
Best: Essex County Express
Love this one. Running through the train, cars disappearing. So great
Honourable Mention: Blood on the Alter
Worst: Undimentioned and Unseen
I know some people like this, but it never grew on my. I never have fun on this one.
Dishonourable Mention: Where Doom Awaits
The Path to Carcosa
Best: The Palid Mask
Love exploring the catacomb. Love that the map is never the same twice.
Honourable Mention: The Last King
Worst: The Unspeakable Oath
Don't really have a reason. Always feels rushed. Also don't like the permadeath if you fail.
Dishonourable Mention: Black Stars Rise
The Forgotten Age
Best: Threads of Fate
Just so excellently designed. Love the multiple Acts. Love the variety of options. So good.
Honourable Mention: The Depths of Yoth
Worst: The Boundary Beyond
I hate this one. Least favourite of the whole game. Everything is needlessly punishing.
Dishonourable Mention: Heart of the Elders
The Circle Undone
Best: The Witching Hour
I think it's cool. Being forced away from your friends. Really tests your deck. First time I played, died horrible as an underprepared Carolyn. Won't make that mistake again.
Honourable Mention: For the Greater Good
Worst: The Secret Name
Tedious. Way too long for it's own good.
Dishonourable Mention: Disappearance at the Twilight Estate (is picking the prologue cheating? Don't care. It deserves it)
Dream Eaters:
Haven't played yet. So no opinion yet.
Stand Alones
Best: Murder at the Excelsior Hotel
They did well here. The new one is so much fun. Again, I like that it's always different with each play.
Honourable Mention: Carnivale of Horrors
Worst: The Labyrinths of Lunacy
Feels less like Arkham and more like a Saw movie.
Dishonourable Mention: The Night's Userper
Edited by Magnito