4 hours ago, Jo Jo said:Does anybody actually like ROS? Where they rank it at least in their top 3 Star Wars movies, or even top 5?
Define "liked."
As a sit down and turn off my brain type movie, I could enjoy it for the dumb action. It was deeply flawed, but I could mostly just go 'meh.' Hated it as a "closure to the saga" story, there was so much potential leading into, even after the other two movies, that just seemed phoned in to try to cash in on nostalgia rather than depend on story at all.
It doesn't rank top 3 Star Wars movies for me, obviously. Top 5... in the Skywalker saga only... maybe. The competition is really trying hard to fight for the bottom. It might make 5th, because I heavily disliked the execution of the prequel movies, I'm biased by nostalgia and prefer the original trilogy as top three, and well... TFA or ROS for 5th? I think ROS managed more tension than TFA, but still totally flopped the dialogue during those moments and the story too over-the-top to suspend belief enough to forget the reality of it. I preferred TLJ, honestly, though that Canto Bight stuff was painful as all heck.
Revenge of the Sith may actually sit in 5th, though one must remember to turn the movie off or walk out before the ending...
Solo and Rogue One were much more enjoyable films... (still cringe-worthy at times, but better overall)