What are you expecting for Clone Wars commanders?

GAR:

Anakin Skywalker

Obiwan Kenibi

Admiral Yularen

Ahsoka Tano

??

CIS

General Grievous

Admiral Trench

Count Dooku?

EDIT: Darth Sidious because FFG thinks he acted openly... ever.

??

Dooku, Kalani, Ventress, Tarkin, Yoda, Admiral Coburn.

I don’t see Ashoka getting a commander card; she primarily seems to direct starfighter and ground combat, and is outranked by everyone else on that list.

Nute Gunray and Mace Windu are also possible commanders.

Admiral Killian

Plo Koon

Maar Tukk (commander or officer, he led sep forces at Ryloth)

Lushros Dofine (definitely should be an officer, captained Invisible Hand at Coruscant)

Core Set:

General Grievous and Admiral Yularen as the commanders.

Anakin and Assaj Ventress as the hero and villain squadrons.

I would like to see a couple, "Clone Naval Officer" and "Tactical Droid" commanders. I think it would be interesting. Maybe let their ability be the ability to use one of the Fleet Commands?

Commander Tarkin?

Also, a friendly reminder that as he is not faction locked, Hondo is a friend to all!

Ugh, Ashoka. It was bad enough making every random Jedi a commander in an army, but kids! Jeez. So stupid.

6 minutes ago, mazz0 said:

Ugh, Ashoka. It was bad enough making every random Jedi a commander in an army, but kids! Jeez. So stupid.

She did mature quite well over the course of the series, but remember: Palpatine's plan wasn't about finding competent commanders and winning. It was about involving the Jedi in the war, to kill them.

GRN:

Yoda

Koon

Skywalker

Kenobi

Tano

Yularen

Kilian

Coburn

Tarkin

CISN:

Grievous

Trench

Dooku

Dofine

Kalani

Tukk

(Cad) Bane?

2 hours ago, The Jabbawookie said:

I don’t see Ashoka getting a commander card; she primarily seems to direct starfighter and ground combat, and is outranked by everyone else on that list.

Maybe as a Mon Mothma-style commander?

Mace Windu!!

1 hour ago, Battlefleet 01 Studios said:

Plo Koon

"Large ship only."

"When it is your turn to activate, you may exhaust this card to pass your turn (your opponent activates a ship instead)."

Just now, Muelmuel said:

"Large ship only."

"When it is your turn to activate, you may exhaust this card to pass your turn (your opponent activates a ship instead)."

*Dies inside*

2 hours ago, The Jabbawookie said:

Dooku, Kalani, Ventress, Tarkin, Yoda, Admiral Coburn.

I don’t see Ashoka getting a commander card; she primarily seems to direct starfighter and ground combat, and is outranked by everyone else on that list.

There was a whole EPISODE on her being a Commander, and the Marg-Sable lives in through it.

Probably get both commander and officer (maybe even boarding party at some point?) of the following:

Anakin

Obi Wan

Yularen

Ahsoka

Mace Windu

Grievous

Dooku

Ventress

7 minutes ago, Drasnighta said:

There was a whole EPISODE on her being a Commander, and the Marg-Sable lives in through it.

It was a single episode centered around her character development, though. Neither the lesson nor the naval role stuck.

Ahsoka: *ignores big picture and advice from people who better understand the situation*

Clones: *die*

Ahsoka: Guess I learned my lesson.

Ahsoka on Felucia: *ignores big picture and advice from people who better understand the situation*

Clones: *die*

2 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

It was a single episode centered around her character development, though. Neither the lesson nor the naval role stuck.

Ahsoka: *ignores big picture and advice from people who better understand the situation*

Clones: *die*

Ahsoka: Guess I learned my lesson.

Ahsoka on Felucia: *ignores big picture and advice from people who better understand the situation*

Clones: *die*

But the tactic did!

Just now, Drasnighta said:

But the tactic did!

Sure. It just doesn't mean Ahsoka should be commanding a fleet when she's almost exclusively seen in other roles (heck, she only got the job over Ryloth after getting Yularen injured and when Anakin was busy.) Officer? Sure. Ace? Absolutely. Boarding team? I'll buy it. Admiral... not sold.

32 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

Sure. It just doesn't mean Ahsoka should be commanding a fleet when she's almost exclusively seen in other roles (heck, she only got the job over Ryloth after getting Yularen injured and when Anakin was busy.) Officer? Sure. Ace? Absolutely. Boarding team? I'll buy it. Admiral... not sold.

And yet... Mon Mothma .

I'll be honest... I want one Jedi commander who makes it so boarding teams arnt discarded upon use.

11 minutes ago, Drasnighta said:

And yet... Mon Mothma .

Is political leadership. So while she might not be coordinating broadsides, I could absolutely see her dictating an overall battle strategy. Which Ahsoka wouldn't and doesn't do unless the upper levels of leadership are unavailable.

Ultimately, I'm content with agreeing to disagree on Ahsoka being a commander. What's basically guaranteed is that she gets one or more roles in the CW era, and that's great.

10 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

Is political leadership. So while she might not be coordinating broadsides, I could absolutely see her dictating an overall battle strategy. Which Ahsoka wouldn't and doesn't do unless the upper levels of leadership are unavailable.

Ultimately, I'm content with agreeing to disagree on Ahsoka being a commander. What's basically guaranteed is that she gets one or more roles in the CW era, and that's great.

I'm just... I guess I'm having a hard time seeing what the criteria is for qualification, that's all...

I mean, sure. Mothma is a Political leader, but in her own words, deliberately leaves off the grand strategy and tactical works to Admirals and Generals... The times we see her, it is only ever as a Political leader - even in Rebels, she leaves Tactical decisions to Hera at the time... Her greatest command is, basically, "you do it.

So when we get to Ahsoka, we have record of her at least attempting to do so, and we're shown - from that point onward - that she is indeed, a direct commander and leader... So I just figure, she'd qualify...

Now, is she a priority qualification given the rest? **** no. Personally, I'd be fine if we left the Jedi for the Squadrons and Upgrades, and kept it at Admirals, Captains and Commanders (Clones or Not) for Fleet Commanders... But we know that's not going to happen