2UXXs or UXE?

By Glyph, in X-Wing Squad Lists

Hey guys!

I'm trying to decide on a list for a tournament I have on Sunday (Brian, if you're reading this...quit cheating and wait till Sunday to see what I'm bringing :P)

I've narrowed it down to two lists, but could use some help picking one, or even refining them into a winning list!

UXX v1
Wedge (X-Wing)
S-foils, R3 Astromech, Proton Torpedoes, Marksmanship

Luke (X-Wing)
S-foils, R3 Astromech, Proton Torpedoes, Heightened Perception

Magva Yarro (U-Wing)
Pivot Wing, Leia Organa
[200pts]

UXE
Wedge (X-Wing)
S-foils, R3 Astromech, Proton Torpedoes, Marksmanship

Corran Horn (E-Wing)
R2-D2, Proton Torpedoes, Fire-Control Systems, Marksmanship

Blue Squadron Scout (U-Wing)
Pivot Wing, Leia Organa
[200pts]

UXX v2
Wedge (X-Wing)
S-foils, R3 Astromech, Marksmanship, Shield Upgrade optional

Luke (X-Wing)
S-foils, R3 Astromech, Heightened Perception, Shield Upgrade optional

Benthic Two Tubes (U-Wing)
Pivot Wing, Leia Organa, Perceptive Copilot, Shield Upgrade
[188-200pts]

Personally I would fly the E wing list. Nobody is expecting an E wing. Especially not one as survivable as Corran with R2.

I dig Benthic with Leia and PerCo

I dig Corran - but with Predator, FCS, R3 (with Benthic's help, double rerolls and focus on both his attacks)

I dig Luke

That leaves 8 points for bid/flexible upgrades