So I've played about 15-20 games of the base game of Star Wars Rebellion now, and after the most recent game my friend and I packed the game away and swore we would never play it again. It's a game we both we really want to like (and we're generally big fans of FFG games), but we have a couple of big problems with the base game. Then I remembered that the game has an expansion, and I was wondering if it might fix those problems?
The biggest problem we have with the base game is that the Rebels ALWAYS win. The games generally feel quite tense and well-balanced for the first six turns, but in the late game the Rebels always win comfortably. Our experience has been that a skilled Rebel player has too many options available for the Empire to shut them down, so they are able to knock off Objectives at a reasonable rate and usually can end the game by about turn 8 - and that's assuming the Rebels don't pull a card like One in a Million, which means five rebel fighters are virtually guaranteed to be able to destroy the Death Star and shorten the game by two turns no matter how well defended it might be. Discussing things after the game, we rarely seem to be able to identify anything the Empire player should have done differently that would have given them a better chance of winning.
In particular, the movement rules where you can't move a fleet if you've placed a leader in to defend in a combat or oppose an enemy mission seems rather punitive to the Imperials given the Rebels always get to act first. Because of the setup rules it's hard to stop the Rebel player getting at least one Mon Calamari cruiser and three or four Airspeeders throughout the game, meaning you need a pretty beefy fleet to be able to survive the Rebels attacking OUT of the base at the start of their turn (when you can't afford to put a leader in) given if they win either the space or the ground combat then you can't take their base and you lose the game. Maybe we're playing the Empire wrong but they just don't seem to have enough time to do what they need to do, even when the dice rolls seem to be going their way.
It does seem like there's been a few specific changes that do make things more balanced, like those shield bunkers that make that specific Death Star Plans / One in a Million combo less viable, and new setup rules that mean the Rebels can't easily take and hold Mon Calamari / Utapau for several turns just because the Empire didn't start with a nearby planet ... but I've not had a chance to look at the new cards and units etc as a whole. Is the general feeling that the new rules buff the Empire or the Rebels? The upgraded combat looks much better but if the Rebels are still going to win every game I'm not sure we'll get much use out of an expansion!
Edited by chris421