As to lurkers, my opinions run along with Ninja’s, dont kove focusing down lurkers, because it seems they are often confused or lazy town.

However, in a game with scum daychat, delays may also be scum discussion.

On 12/20/2018 at 1:06 PM, LTD said:

I’ve read through, and don’t like the argument against Clon.

this is still very shady

On 12/20/2018 at 10:36 AM, EbonHawk said:

Top 4 for me RN: LTD/Jabba for quietness and not much else in way of solve of help, then Mad/Biggs.. mad hasn't played his usual game so far but it's day 1, and biggs seemed to swoop in on me, but i haven't played much with him as others have so wouldn't know if that is out of sorts for him.

I'm watching LP for possible cult, but agree it would be foolish to out as he did if he was such, atm I'm happy to stick to LTD

This kinda flies in the face of what I posted earlier about Biggs. Could Ebon just be separating himself from a scumbuddy? yes.

After another re-read, Ebon doesn't look at Clon at all really. I could see a Ebon, Clon, LTD mafia with the LTD slip above (subbing Clon in for Ebon).

Just theories at this point.

The reason for my silence is that, as per usual, what I would say has already been said in a better manner to how I would have said it, and it wasn't much in quantity.

I have found LTD to be the scummiest of you all by far, and thus intend to vote him, though I shall not do so with so much time still.

I am inclined to trust ovi. LP seems normal to me.

I get the impression that Mad was the TT and that clon got his role, which makes me inclined to trust clon.

1 minute ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

The reason for my silence is that, as per usual, what I would say has already been said in a better manner to how I would have said it, and it wasn't much in quantity.

I have found LTD to be the scummiest of you all by far, and thus intend to vote him, though I shall not do so with so much time still.

I am inclined to trust ovi. LP seems normal to me.

I get the impression that Mad was the TT and that clon got his role, which makes me inclined to trust clon.

Inclined to trust Ovi? Thats big of you, considering he’s confirmed town. But be careful, don’t wanna go too far out on a limb there.

I’d like to hear from LTD, there’s been a lot of fire directed his way so far.

I would also like to hear from Ovi,

2 minutes ago, clontroper5 said:

I would also like to hear from Ovi,

Sorry. I mentioned to say LTD, I think Ovi has said alot right now haha

3 hours ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

this is still very shady

Yeah, I said Clon instead of Ebon. That happens when you are posting at 6am.

I am not scum, I am town. Look elsewhere.

I am willing to follow Ovi’s lead... and will post more later today once out of the boondocks. Be aware though that midnight gmt Christmas Eve is my 10am Christmas Day - so you ain’t getting much out of me for those last 12 hours or so.

My tendency is towards a shady Biggs at this point.

## vote @BiggsIRL in case I can’t post again for a long while.

7 hours ago, Lord Preyer said:

As for Ser Jabba’s “I don’t mind flavour... but content” I have also provided content. Most notably in drawing attention to his odd early game (and possible scummarining). He may not have liked the content I provided but that does not mean it was not there

- Furthermore, I take his votesword on me as a retaliatory move which I find... uncouth. 

Some content to be sure, but not proportional to the post count and thicker than even your standard. The vote is not vengeful, but you initiated a push on town over a decent case on someone who flipped scum. That doesn’t prove your guilt by any stretch of the imagination, but I don’t mind hanging my vote on you for a bit to get conversation going. Think of me as a border collie nipping at slow heels.

Right now, I see myself, Ovi and Jabba as most convinvingly town.

Ovi, for obvious reasons.

Myself, I think also for obvious reasons (beyond my own knowledge of my affiliation).

Jabba, because I am inclined to believe Restless Spirit was assigned town, and given how Ebon pushed him it makes most sense to me that hes town.

I am also inclined to believe LTD. He reads to me as busy more than scummarining.

I like what Ninja’s doing, but none of it is something I wouldn’t expect him to do as scum. Indeed, a call for movement, a rallying of town, is excellent scumplay precisely because of its townliness. That said, I’m also not interested in voting someone on that, plus I liked his D1 as town.

So thats five players I simply refuse to vote on. Who does that leave?

LP, Biggs, Gnips and Clon.

I’ll be looking over each.

11 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Right now, I see myself, Ovi and Jabba as most convinvingly town.

Ovi, for obvious reasons.

Myself, I think also for obvious reasons (beyond my own knowledge of my affiliation).

Jabba, because I am inclined to believe Restless Spirit was assigned town, and given how Ebon pushed him it makes most sense to me that hes town.

I am also inclined to believe LTD. He reads to me as busy more than scummarining.

I like what Ninja’s doing, but none of it is something I wouldn’t expect him to do as scum. Indeed, a call for movement, a rallying of town, is excellent scumplay precisely because of its townliness. That said, I’m also not interested in voting someone on that, plus I liked his D1 as town.

So thats five players I simply refuse to vote on. Who does that leave?

LP, Biggs, Gnips and Clon.

I’ll be looking over each.

We're you the Time Traveler as Biggs has guessed?

15 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Right now, I see myself, Ovi and Jabba as most convinvingly town.

Ovi, for obvious reasons.

Myself, I think also for obvious reasons (beyond my own knowledge of my affiliation).

Jabba, because I am inclined to believe Restless Spirit was assigned town, and given how Ebon pushed him it makes most sense to me that hes town.

I am also inclined to believe LTD. He reads to me as busy more than scummarining.

I like what Ninja’s doing, but none of it is something I wouldn’t expect him to do as scum. Indeed, a call for movement, a rallying of town, is excellent scumplay precisely because of its townliness. That said, I’m also not interested in voting someone on that, plus I liked his D1 as town.

So thats five players I simply refuse to vote on. Who does that leave?

LP, Biggs, Gnips and Clon.

I’ll be looking over each.

Wou you consider your new role...

Scummy?

39 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Wou you consider your new role...

Scummy?

Actually, I would consider the new role scummy. But it didnt shift my alignment

4 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

Inclined to trust Ovi? Thats big of you, considering he’s confirmed town. But be careful, don’t wanna go too far out on a limb there.

He himself said he wasn't town, or at least implied it. Thus, he is either 3rd party or scum. Given his death, I am inclined to think him 3rd party. That doesn't make him necessarily on our side, so yes, there are grounds for doubt.

48 minutes ago, clontroper5 said:

We're you the Time Traveler as Biggs has guessed?

Yes, I thought that was clear.

6 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Pod said town's beloved princess.

I AM NOT TOWN

I am royalty!

Here is the post I refer to.

Just now, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

He himself said he wasn't town, or at least implied it. Thus, he is either 3rd party or scum. Given his death, I am inclined to think him 3rd party. That doesn't make him necessarily on our side, so yes, there are grounds for doubt.

That was clearly a play on the princess role. He said he wasnt town, he was royalty.

Just now, Madaghmire said:

That was clearly a play on the princess role. He said he wasnt town, he was royalty.

One cannot be sure.

Trying to push doubt on a confirmed Beloved Princess is either remarkably misguided townplay or incredibly brazen scum.

16 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Yes, I thought that was clear.

Just checking, I don't fully understand the role so I wasn't sure haha

17 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Trying to push doubt on a confirmed Beloved Princess is either remarkably misguided townplay or incredibly brazen scum.

I am not pushing doubt, I am being cautious. I believe him to be on our side, but am acknowledging the possibility of his having other motives.

19 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

Here is the post I refer to.

17 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

One cannot be sure.

@clontroper5, @Lord Preyer you both also said your roles were stolen. LP actually said it was changed. Do you consider there is valuable information to share?

11 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

@clontroper5, @Lord Preyer you both also said your roles were stolen. LP actually said it was changed. Do you consider there is valuable information to share?

If information was truly valuable I would have shared it already!

1 hour ago, The Jabbawookie said:

Some content to be sure, but not proportional to the post count and thicker than even your standard. The vote is not vengeful, but you initiated a push on town over a decent case on someone who flipped scum. That doesn’t prove your guilt by any stretch of the imagination, but I don’t mind hanging my vote on you for a bit to get conversation going. Think of me as a border collie nipping at slow heels.

Ah! You play The Hound Ser! Well I fear no fire!

As for my words and deeds, the former I pray you’d find very much in keeping with my usual form. The latter, as constructive as might be given the case in question is D1.. On which note, thine own contribution to that day was Scummarinish enough to illicit mineself and two others to draw attention to thy words and deeds that day.

I continue to be on my guard. And I note your blade remains drawn at me...

5 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

If information was truly valuable I would have shared it already!

A townie role maybe?