If it wasn't for Hero's read I would be suspect of Gnips as well but he seems clean right now

seems the only way to clear myself is to get a result on heros sanity, and as you'd guess I'm not in the business of self voting

if it clears me to the rest of you then i'll vote LP, if we think that's the best way to sort out the sanity issues? and given LP didn't go on the bertie train out of them all, i find confusing..

##vote LP

48 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

@Herowannabe :

@GhostofNobodyInParticular :

@EbonHawk : Podracer, Herowannabe, Clontroper5 (L-2)

@Lord Preyer : Ebonhawk (L-4)

@Caldias :

 @Madaghmire :

@PodRacer :

 @clontroper5 : Lord Preyer (L-4)

5 to hammer.

@GhostofNobodyInParticular @Caldias @Madaghmire you three are the only ones without a vote at the moment. Care to cast a vote and/or weigh in on the discussion?

2 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

Im not shading Cal with that, just explaining why im confused.

Guys am behind but wanted to weigh in here. My intention was to communicate this but infer I couldn't self protect tonight to bait scum. There is a restriction but it wasn't active last night.

7 minutes ago, Herowannabe said:

@GhostofNobodyInParticular @Caldias @Madaghmire you three are the only ones without a vote at the moment. Care to cast a vote and/or weigh in on the discussion?

At work and busy so can't really wade through it all ATM, but will try to pick out things people have asked. I'm right now still ok with voting Ebon, and I think my vote is still on him.

13 hours ago, Caldias said:

More like DeadbonHawk

##vote EbonHawk

No unvote after that. Ebon should still be at L1

3 minutes ago, Caldias said:

At work and busy so can't really wade through it all ATM, but will try to pick out things people have asked. I'm right now still ok with voting Ebon, and I think my vote is still on him.

Hmm... looks like you are right. @The Jabbawookie , here's where Caldias voted, and he has not unvoted, only indicated that he could if needed.

13 hours ago, Caldias said:

More like DeadbonHawk

##vote EbonHawk

Oops, ninja'd by the man himself.

Just now, Caldias said:

No unvote after that. Ebon should still be at L1

mad

5 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

##unvote

Top of page 49

11 minutes ago, Caldias said:

At work and busy so can't really wade through it all ATM, but will try to pick out things people have asked. I'm right now still ok with voting Ebon, and I think my vote is still on him.

Most of what has been happening has been Ebon and I debating back and forth about whether or not he's scum, whether or not I'm a sane cop, and what the best methods are to prove/disprove both. In my (completely unbiased, I'm sure) opinion, the most useful posts over the past several hours are @clontroper5 's recaps on pages 51 and 52:

1 hour ago, clontroper5 said:

Everybody that's left in the game:

@PodRacer : claims doc/BG, I think everyone is pretty much agreed that he is town.

@Caldias : claims doc, survived a night attack, 95% sure he is town. He did take part in the CV lynch though

@Madaghmire : claims cop, probably paranoid, I think we agree he is town.

@Herowannabe :claims cop, I think we all agree he is town.

@GhostofNobodyInParticular : no claim I think, not a lot of information but seems good to me. (Although was involved in the CV lynch)

@EbonHawk : hasn't claimed I think? read by Hero as Scum. Took part in the CV lynch.

@Lord Preyer : I can't remember a claim, read as scum by Hero, also took part in the CV lynch

So that review narrows it down a lot in my view, already we have Gnips, ebon, and Lord preyer, as really the only possible suspects (with the ever present possibility that people are lying and everything we know is wrong) and we have a cop that has a scum read of 2 of these players. I think that makes it clear.

44 minutes ago, clontroper5 said:

first (attempted) lynch @LTD : Ebo  nhawk, Lord Preyer  , Caldias, Madaghmire   , Podracer,  Bertie Woo  ster, ghostofnobodyinparticular.

2nd lynch (scum): @  Bertie Wooster : EbonHawk, CV, Podracer,  Mada  ghmire, Caldias, Herowannabe

3rd lynch (town)

@Constantine Valdor : GNiPs         , Lord Preyer, C  aldias   , EbonHawk , podracer.

38 minutes ago, clontroper5 said:

@EbonHawk , @Caldias , and @PodRacer , were on all 3 hammer trains.

LP and Gnips were on both town hammer trains.

Mad was on the first 2 trains but not the third.

Hero was on the Scum train.

And I wasn't on any of the trains...

7 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

Top of page 49

Just as a general FYI to you, @The Jabbawookie , and anyone else, there's a little gray arrow in the top right corner of every quote box. Clicking that arrow takes you to the original post being quoted.

Just now, Herowannabe said:

Just as a general FYI to you, @The Jabbawookie , and anyone else, there's a little gray arrow in the top right corner of every quote box. Clicking that arrow takes you to the original post being quoted.

my man! I never knew this, that is helpful!

Just now, EbonHawk said:

my man! I never knew this, that is helpful!

Amazingly neither did I...

I have this gut feeling like im paranoid and hero is sane, in which case we should hang clon. Plus, I was starting to lean scum on him anyway. But Ebons spat with pod set off a lot of bells that without the cop stuff would make me want to focus there, and LP seems like the best information kill. So im mulling it over

Insane, not sane*

Plus if im paranoid and hero is sane, then ebon/lp should hang

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

I have this gut feeling like im paranoid and hero is sane, in which case we should hang clon. Plus, I was starting to lean scum on him anyway. But Ebons spat with pod set off a lot of bells that without the cop stuff would make me want to focus there, and LP seems like the best information kill. So im mulling it over

So my grip with this line, is who am I working with?

Bertie and someone else

Just now, Madaghmire said:

Plus if im paranoid and hero is sane, then ebon/lp should hang

Also I want to reaffirm that both ebon, and LP were involved in Both town lynches

They were, but its easy for town to get caught in that. Ebons been in on all three

Just now, Madaghmire said:

Bertie and someone else

So I just want too point out your case against me is based Solely on a gut feeling that Hero is insane.

1 minute ago, clontroper5 said:

Also I want to reaffirm that both ebon, and LP were involved in Both town lynches

LTD isn't much, he was silent and by his own admission even he thought it was better to let that build and get the kill based on his role, and CV becuase he looked scummy, was lurky and his posts made me fear a cult or scum

Just now, clontroper5 said:

So I just want too point out your case against me is based Solely on a gut feeling that Hero is insane.

so was mine last game on jabba/broba and this game on bertie.. although CV was a gut read so it can be wrong I hand tou that

we assume there is still 3 scum at gaem start even if I was wrong about the cult I could be right about jabba only putting in two scum

If jabba only put in two scum then i hope bertie is ripping him a new one in observers