4 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

I can’t be scummy because I’ve never challenged this line of thought and also scummy because in the first circumstance I could find to post I happened to be scum. Its logically inconsistent.

So basically, I call you scum for saying it, so you quote a previous game, just to say I can't call you scum now.. Just means you've brought it up before in a game I wasn't in/can't remember.. fail to see the point....

Providing proof you've done it previously doesn't make my point mute just alters it

4 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

Aw thanks.

I mean, you and Mads banging on about it means we don't have total RNG. Which is nice.

That was my point, we would never have to RNG and I would never have to vote on my history thing with good talking a point he skipped rgiht over to go straight into 'i've been targeted for my history mode' and voting me

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

So basically, I call you scum for saying it, so you quote a previous game, just to say I can't call you scum now.. Just means you've brought it up before in a game I wasn't in/can't remember.. fail to see the point....

Providing proof you've done it previously doesn't make my point mute just alters it

How the **** do you not see the point? For your point to matter it has to be behavior that is out of character for me . It has to be something that I haven’t challenged. It doesn’t matter if I never challenged you. It matters that it establishes a pattern of behavior of mine.

4 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Fwiw, I no longer think Ebon is scum. I just want him dead.

How does this benefit town?

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

That was my point, we would never have to RNG and I would never have to vote on my history thing with good talking a point he skipped rgiht over to go straight into 'i've been targeted for my history mode' and voting me

To be fair, you did target him for his history. And this is still a very good talking point. ?

Just now, Madaghmire said:

How the **** do you not see the point? For your point to matter it has to be behavior that is out of character for me . It has to be something that I haven’t challenged. It doesn’t matter if I never challenged you. It matters that it establishes a pattern of behavior of mine.

Yep that's fine, but you're getting bogged down in that point. Doesn't change the fact you voted me for it, regardless of your history, and it doesn't change the fact despite explaining it too you multiple times, you've still taken it personally and assumed a wagon being built.. focusing on smaller points rather than the big one, regardless of your post history I think your reaction to my post and reactions since explaining are scummy...

Just now, The Jabbawookie said:

To be fair, you did target him for his history. And this is still a very good talking point. ?

TBF NO I DIDNT, I voted him because of his vote and over reaction on me..

Please read the game Jab. I have not targeted him for history and stressed the point many times..

Funnily enough I'm now thinking of the past few times you've been scum and nearly all of them involve you getting caught defending a scum friend?

I'm more curious on what everyone else has been up too I feel like we got some people flying under the radar right now...

Just now, EbonHawk said:

Yep that's fine, but you're getting bogged down in that point. Doesn't change the fact you voted me for it, regardless of your history, and it doesn't change the fact despite explaining it too you multiple times, you've still taken it personally and assumed a wagon being built.. focusing on smaller points rather than the big one, regardless of your post history I think your reaction to my post and reactions since explaining are scummy...

Because **** town. Last game showed me that I’m a town liability late game, because if you morons dont know who it is you’ll just vote me anyway. So I have one day to nail a scum. At first, I legit thought it was you, but now I just want you to lose.

Just now, Matt3412 said:

I'm more curious on what everyone else has been up too I feel like we got some people flying under the radar right now...

Indeed, lotta of lurkers around..

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

TBF NO I DIDNT, I voted him because of his vote and over reaction on me..

Please read the game Jab. I have not targeted him for history and stressed the point many times..

Funnily enough I'm now thinking of the past few times you've been scum and nearly all of them involve you getting caught defending a scum friend?

Yes you did. Saying you didnt do a thing doesnt mean you didnt do a thing. This isnt politics.

Just now, Madaghmire said:

Because **** town. Last game showed me that I’m a town liability late game, because if you morons dont know who it is you’ll just vote me anyway. So I have one day to nail a scum. At first, I legit thought it was you, but now I just want you to lose.

See and you wonder why I vote you.

Considering I made the point and MAKE EVERY GAME the need for talking in a talking game to avoid people like you getting hung for nothing... getting killed late game does not make you a liability though and you're not such! You're a great player, getting killed like that is part of the game sometimes.

As said I'm voting you because you choosing not to see the difference in what I said, where I explain how I want to avoid voting RNG or on player history by getting conversation going, sometime you should be for not against..

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

Yes you did. Saying you didnt do a thing doesnt mean you didnt do a thing. This isnt politics.

Shut the F up bud....

Putting words into my mouth doesn't mean i bloody said them.. IF I TELL YOU IM NOT VOTING YOU FOR YOUR HISTORY IT MEANS IM NOT VOTING YOU FOR YOUR HISTORY... no one is in charge of my opinions but me! And as said MULTIPLE times I'm voting oyu BC of your reaction to my early post, not because you roll scum a lot... but please peddle that all you want..

I'm going for a smoke because it grinds my gears when people warp others words to make a point themselves,, make a real point not make one up

2 hours ago, EbonHawk said:

That's cool, but the response you quote there compared to the response you gave me

Seems rather more urgent for you in my case, and as said I don't think they matter at all, but in a situation where there is nothing I'd vote someone with a past over a random player or newbie..

Think we could've caught one by chance and you haven't really swung me onto you being town

##vote Mad

Where do i mention mads history being the reason for my vote? The bit in bold is not a reason before someone warps it, it's reaffirming an ongoing point that IMO player history over RNG is more important to me, that does not equate into why I'm voting him, taken out of the context of around post.

I say I reckon we've caught one my chance in regards to how mad replied to my post as underlined. I think mad got a little spooked and hasn't nudged me from thinking that since, my vote is about this current game.

Mine too!

I havent responded to your or Matts votes on me because I dont give a **** about the vote. I care about this ******* nonsense where we bring up how often so and so rolls scum. I never said you voted me for my history. Neither did Jabba. He said you targetted me for it. And you ******* did.

Also as 4 pages established, explaining logic is overrated!

Vive le Pod!

Pod who are you even voting for?

Lets face it, If we always went on history I would be the easiest TR in the world..

I is voting for LTD

I think he could use at least a couple ore talking points..

Oblige him..

Ebons right about that smoke tho, Ima step out and cool off as well.

##unvote

sooo post smoke cooling off while i think we and mad are going to have to agree to disagree, I don't think he's as scum as I did and think we it was a case of immovable object meets unstoppable force..

Im going to take some time to not only review mads posts again but also everyone else, I know we have more lurkers than is normal this D1

Off the bat after Mad

Matt seemed a little eager to follow me, pods something different than normal but i can't put a finger on it

That smoke was very much needed I think to avoid going back and forth between me and mad, and come away and think it over

24 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

TBF NO I DIDNT, I voted him because of his vote and over reaction on me..

Please read the game Jab. I have not targeted him for history and stressed the point many times..

Funnily enough I'm now thinking of the past few times you've been scum and nearly all of them involve you getting caught defending a scum friend?

What was he reacting to? Your suggestion that *all else being equal,* he was on your short list of D1 kills because of his history. I get that's not why you're voting him, but you did say that. As for me, I only defend scum when I'm town, remember? Using logic a lot like yours, no less. ?

7 minutes ago, PodRacer said:

I think he could use at least a couple ore talking points..

Oblige him..

So could you, voting people for them to talk isn't talking yourself..

9 hours ago, Caldias said:

Vote count:

1. @LTD Podracer
2. @The Jabbawookie
3. @PodRacer LTD
4. @GhostofNobodyInParticular
5. @Madaghmire
6. @BrobaFett
7. @Matt3412
8. @Lord Preyer Matt3412
9. @Constantine Valdor
10. @EbonHawk Madaghmire
11. @Vipcard3

6 to hammer

Countdown To Night

23ish hours to go

1, 8, 9, 11

what are you thoughts?