43 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

@GhostofNobodyInParticular - anything to add since you role confirm?

Not really, no. Otherwise I would have.

I don't like Matt's suggestion for lynching those who roll scum frequently purely for that fact, and he has already acknowledged that he knows that. I can understand your approach to his suggestion, but I still dislike it. It feels too much like what drove JJ off these games.

I am inclined to vote for either you or Matt (with a preference for Matt) due to the stated reasons, however I am not strongly given over to that action. I find Mad's early vote hasty and perhaps too extreme of a first reaction, but then again, as I said, I can sympathize with him. I may end up joining him, after all.

I think LP's post was fine. I can't see a dissonance between the two ideas. Perhaps the phrasing is what threw you off?

So that is where I am, so far. Pod is being his usual self, though perhaps with a slight difference, I am not sure. The others haven't posted enough for me to get any sort of read of them.

16 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

So that is where I am, so far. Pod is being his usual self, though perhaps with a slight difference, I am not sure. The others haven't posted enough for me to get any sort of read of them. 

I thought the same about Pod, but didn't want to hound him D1 again, I've got my eye on him though for sure

17 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

I don't like Matt's suggestion for lynching those who roll scum frequently purely for that fact, and he has already acknowledged that he knows that. I can understand your approach to his suggestion, but I still dislike it. It feels too much like what drove JJ off these games.

I am inclined to vote for either you or Matt (with a preference for Matt) due to the stated reasons, however I am not strongly given over to that action. I find Mad's early vote hasty and perhaps too extreme of a first reaction, but then again, as I said, I can sympathize with him. I may end up joining him, after all. 

Matt suggested just a random lynch, it was me who mentioned people who roll scum alot, but in the context of having no other information to go on only.

My top 3 of shady suspects so far is Mad, Pod, and Jab but I wouldn't call any of them scum, just pinging the early warning systems.. I get matt and he's been odd too, but I wonder if he's just putting some alien flavour in?

16 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

Matt suggested just a random lynch, it was me who mentioned people who roll scum alot, but in the context of having no other information to go on only.

You are correct. Still, he went along with it and considered it a valid strategy, so he remains on my suspect list.

1 minute ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

You are correct. Still, he went along with it and considered it a valid strategy, so he remains on my suspect list.

Fair enough, I can see your point on that

@EbonHawk thanks for clarifying that point for everyone i appreciate it.

Also i have an observation.

Last game when this played out GNIPS heavily defended he wasn't scum the same way Mag is doing this game. GNIPS was scum last time. based on Mag's reaction he seems to be overacting... Gnips seems very level headed good good haha

##unvote

##vote @Madaghmire

1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:

@EbonHawk thanks for clarifying that point for everyone i appreciate it.

Also i have an observation.

Last game when this played out GNIPS heavily defended he wasn't scum the same way Mag is doing this game. GNIPS was scum last time. based on Mag's reaction he seems to be overacting... Gnips seems very level headed good good haha

##unvote

##vote @Madaghmire

Yep that's my point on mad, I agree.. A simple observation from me and it did get taken rather to heart..

Could be because Mad used to be a policy vote and doesn't want that back, could be because he got pegged early by chance

25 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

Many words..

Ebon/gnip

Town lean

3 minutes ago, PodRacer said:

Ebon/gnip

Town lean

This is a first isn't it, town leaning on me? and where did you even find that quote ahahhha

oh you changed it to many words...

funny man ahha

13 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

This is a first isn't it, town leaning on me? and where did you even find that quote ahahhha

IKR... U must be scummy!

1 hour ago, PodRacer said:

IKR... U must be scummy!

maybe we're turning a new leaf together

4 hours ago, EbonHawk said:

LP you had me till that last point, the bit underlined is so far from my point it hurts coming from you.

Never did I say lets hang vets with experience, because after we hang Mad/Gnips/Jabba I'm next so that's stupid for a start!

My point is shown above again, and on page 1.

Hopefully in a day 1 you guys actually get yakking for more than 1 or 2 posts and we can pick up on someone acting odd, that's where my vote goes. IF IF it ever came down to a RNG number vote on Day yes I would hang Mad or Cal with my vote no shame bc not only do they roll scum a lot, THEY ARE HARD TO PIN DOWN because they're so good.

Don't change my point to bring shade, and the fact you did plus the little Mad Like makes me wonder are you to in cahoots?

Mad takes my simple point to Matt very to heart even though I've made the point before, then LP comes in and changes that point to say Im saying 'lets hang a vet' over my actual explained point as it's put..

Could be simple mis-reading granted, could be palling up a scum team member...

Sorry ebon! No offence intended! I was probably over reacting to the last games too and fired up a bit too much by mads’ post. Apologies sir.

1 minute ago, Lord Preyer said:

Sorry ebon! No offence intended! I was probably over reacting to the last games too and fired up a bit too much by mads’ post. Apologies sir.

All good, I thought as much.. Still waiting on ol' @Madaghmire to reply

Hey everyone! As I said before game I'm gonna be super duper unavailable today. I'll try and catch up tonight around 11pm pacific if that's not post day. I'll be the first to admit D1 for me is always a crap shoot.

Only interesting thing I've noticed so far is that GNIPS and Ebon started down a road that pointed some suspicion at Matt and he immediately turns around and doesn't address them and places a vote on Madagmire. That could be something worth taking note of, as I think those kind of things D1 - though flimsy - could be enough to risk voting over.

Idk who to vote on D1, and at hammertime I would be busy painting minis for a tournament this weekend ?

11 minutes ago, BrobaFett said:

Hey everyone! As I said before game I'm gonna be super duper unavailable today. I'll try and catch up tonight around 11pm pacific if that's not post day. I'll be the first to admit D1 for me is always a crap shoot.

Only interesting thing I've noticed so far is that GNIPS and Ebon started down a road that pointed some suspicion at Matt and he immediately turns around and doesn't address them and places a vote on Madagmire. That could be something worth taking note of, as I think those kind of things D1 - though flimsy - could be enough to risk voting over.

interesting points broba

9 minutes ago, Constantine Valdor said:

Idk who to vote on D1, and at hammertime I would be busy painting minis for a tournament this weekend ?

12 hours ish till night

Guys, just a heads up: I’ll be flying tonight 2200 CET long haul back to London Sector so will need to place my VoteZap by then.

5 hours ago, EbonHawk said:

OOOOOOO you're touchy this morning darling...

Never said that was my tact, but if we came down to just picking a number out of the hat, yes I'd hang you or Cal (if he were alive and jokes about in his own post) first... ya know why, not because as you say I don't understand probability, but because of the infinite improbability you and cal, and to a lesser extent jab/gnips drop scum (I hope you like that hitchhikers reference). This is something I've said in MANY MANY MANY games previous....

Yet this game you take exception, maybe you don't want it to gain any thought because you have different motives?

The early vote seems to make this look so

I always attack posts that suggest previous games roles matter.

On 8/2/2018 at 11:31 PM, Madaghmire said:

Being good or bad wouldn’t factor in, and you previous results would have no influence on the RNG. Setup says 2 scum, your chances of being scum this game are 2/7, same as everyone else.

This is from July.

Er, August. That game started in July.

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

I always attack posts that suggest previous games roles matter.

This is from July.

That's cool, but the response you quote there compared to the response you gave me

17 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

Well. Not a lot going on.

But the ole “hey lets vote people who have drawn scum at a higher rate in the past because I don’t understand how probability works” argument is enough to draw a vote from me, given that its D1 and I don’t really have anywhere better to put it, and it feels like he’s testing the water to see if the idea has legs.

##vote Ebonhawk

Seems rather more urgent for you in my case, and as said I don't think they matter at all, but in a situation where there is nothing I'd vote someone with a past over a random player or newbie..

Think we could've caught one by chance and you haven't really swung me onto you being town

##vote Mad

55 minutes ago, BrobaFett said:

Only interesting thing I've noticed so far is that GNIPS and Ebon started down a road that pointed some suspicion at Matt and he immediately turns around and doesn't address them and places a vote on Madagmire. That could be something worth taking note of, as I think those kind of things D1 - though flimsy - could be enough to risk voting over.

i think i've played enough games to establish some consistency on this point.

i rarely go out of my way to defend every little point about me unless its a serious accusation. yes i do die from this being interpreted wrong and yes i'm always town when that happens... hahahahaha probability arguments anyone?

why would you go back 3 months to find a post seems like your really reaching on that one.

4 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

That's cool, but the response you quote there compared to the response you gave me

Seems rather more urgent for you in my case, and as said I don't think they matter at all, but in a situation where there is nothing I'd vote someone with a past over a random player or newbie..

Think we could've caught one by chance and you haven't really swung me onto you being town

##vote Mad

Well yeah, in that game I was scum and didnt want to draw attention to myself.