Just now, EbonHawk said:I think what he's trying to say by killing broba, if he's scum and CV rolls town on you it will implicate Jabba
no because that fits with Jabba's claim that i'm scum
all that's going to do is have the good cop say town and the bad cop say scum on the same player
Plus my roles a self reveal at a certain point anyway, and as shown mad leaves once he's won, so what these two cops looking for?
Just now, Matt3412 said:no because that fits with Jabba's claim that i'm scum
all that's going to do is have the good cop say town and the bad cop say scum on the same player
not if CV scans broba and gets scum as you say, you shouldn't have anything to worry about
Just now, Matt3412 said:no because that fits with Jabba's claim that i'm scum
all that's going to do is have the good cop say town and the bad cop say scum on the same player
the only reason now to push this would be to get both scum another night ala you and Jab
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:not if CV scans broba and gets scum as you say, you shouldn't have anything to worry about
your confused Broba's not apart of any of this next day or night in my logic
HES DONE TOADY??!?!
also if jabba is a cop it clears me and you and indicates lp and broba meaning a quick win after
Just now, Matt3412 said:your confused Broba's not apart of any of this next day or night in my logic
HES DONE TOADY??!?!
no I'm not confused just using my own logic.. and putting a different view forward.
Just now, EbonHawk said:no I'm not confused just using my own logic.. and putting a different view forward.
hence I say the cop should scan him and we kill jabba, if you're so sure of broba being scum the cop will find out.. I don't get why you're worried unless you're actually scum
2 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:You're confused Broba's not apart of any of this next day or night in my logic
HES DONE TOADY??!?!
In memory of the fallen LTD who saw that but couldn't post
F for respect
7 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:Look if broba dies today we will know one scum or one town.
we will know what LP is Scum or Town.
After that its pretty simple to get us to who the last person left is
Ok Matt! I’m going to take a deep breath and try to examine your logic anew and really listen to what you’re trying to tell me. Sorry if I’m being obtuse. Can you help me out by filling this out below please?
You are saying:
1) kill ?
2) NK (likely GNIP)
2) scan ?
3) scan ?
3) ask Jabba to state scan first
4) ask CV to state scan second
And that will unlock everything even if I’m Town and Jabba is Scum and he lies? This is the bit I’m stuck on!
Thanks!
33 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:The logic stands that if we kill broba today
Both cops scan LP tonight
Jabba revels first. Cv gets to check if hes lying.
And then either kill lp found guilty 2nd scum or kill jabba for lying.
And if LP is town AND Jabba isn't lying? It is possible, after all.
1 minute ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:And if LP is town AND Jabba isn't lying? It is possible, after all.
that's my point, better to take jabba and get CV on Broba and settle this
5 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:And if LP is town AND Jabba isn't lying? It is possible, after all.
alright fine its possible in a world where i'm scum that's what i'm missing.
then have Jabba Scan LP and Have CV scan Jabba...
and that should fix everything as long as we vote Broba.
+ Protect CV, GNIPS PLEASE
3 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:alright fine its possible in a world where i'm scum that's what i'm missing.
then have Jabba Scan LP and Have CV scan Jabba...
and that should fix everything as long as we vote Broba.
I'm still more confident on killing Jabba, cv on broba more so since they've been my gut since N1 reread
3 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:alright fine its possible in a world where i'm scum that's what i'm missing.
then have Jabba Scan LP and Have CV scan Jabba...
and that should fix everything as long as we vote Broba.
But how does it fix everything if Broba and me are Town and you and Jabba are scum?
you would have another night of killing.
We will Know if JABBA is scum and if me and ebon should be trusted based off of CV's look
Just now, Matt3412 said:We will Know if JABBA is scum and if me and ebon should be trusted based off of CV's look
but then better to take jabba now as he's the most likely scum target
and if cv goes on broba 99% hes scum if not then we relook at imo yours and lps game as I know my role and if we don't reach consensus on eitehr it'll be me who has to hang anyway
look i want Jabba to be town honestly or else we have a big problem because now ebon could have been scum the whole time playing us
Since i know you don't believe it but i'm town
Matt - if you don’t mind. Could you fill in my question sheet from above please? (Incorrectly numbered though it is!)
Just now, Matt3412 said:look i want Jabba to be town honestly or else we have a big problem because now ebon could have been scum the whole time playing us
Since i know you don't believe it but i'm town
I do, and I think jabba broba are scum hence killing Jab and scanning broba and I'm confident on that hence not worried about tomorrow because i know im town
22 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:Ok Matt! I’m going to take a deep breath and try to examine your logic anew and really listen to what you’re trying to tell me. Sorry if I’m being obtuse. Can you help me out by filling this out below please?
You are saying:
1) kill ? Broba
2) NK (likely GNIP)
2) scan ? Jabba [with CV]
3) scan ? LP [with jabba]
3) ask Jabba to state scan first
4) ask CV to state scan second
And that will unlock everything even if I’m Town and Jabba is Scum and he lies? This is the bit I’m stuck on!
Thanks!
Just now, EbonHawk said:I do, and I think jabba broba are scum hence killing Jab and scanning broba and I'm confident on that hence not worried about tomorrow because i know im town
I do as in I do believe you're town and I'm saying in my plan you shouldn't be worried because if you're as sure on broba as me and you're actually town you know what cv will find on broba and we hang him tomorrow
but I'm happy to hang either broba or jabba just preference to jabba