So guys we either kill Jabba thereby confirming him or not, or kill Broba for the same

but the sucm team is either broba/lp or jabba/matt

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

no but as LP said if jabba is scum he will just lie say LP is town and CV won't be able to call him on it....

If CV scans jabba and he's lying it means you and he are scum which diddles town rotten

if jabba is true in his words than it's LP and Broba

I think we’ve got it Ebon!

And I wonder if you’re a wee bit nervous Matt my old friend!?

Could also be Jabba/Broba

and Jabba as scum and thereby knowing all the town anyway just claimed cop and picked two random towns me and matt to confirm knowing we would say yes

Actually very likely now I think about it

Becuase lets be honest Jabbas cleared both me and matt and we both want to kill him, that says something

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

So guys we either kill Jabba thereby confirming him or not, or kill Broba for the same

but the sucm team is either broba/lp or jabba/matt

I think there are more possibilities whereby Jabba is the scum then other possibilities.

Just now, Lord Preyer said:

I think there are more possibilities whereby Jabba is the scum then other possibilities.

yep

##vote @The Jabbawookie

your role would clear a lot of the game

Just now, EbonHawk said:

Becuase lets be honest Jabbas cleared both me and matt and we both want to kill him, that says something

It says that at least one of you is genuine in your desire for his death!

2 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

Could also be Jabba/Broba

and Jabba as scum and thereby knowing all the town anyway just claimed cop and picked two random towns me and matt to confirm knowing we would say yes

Actually very likely now I think about it

especially as I've already claimed not a hard one to pick

I am not ruling out the Broba thing - it just doesn’t feel like Broba to me and never really has this game except for scummarining and I don’t think he’s lying to us about real life pressures.

Just now, Lord Preyer said:

It says that at least one of you is genuine in your desire for his death!

Dead or Alive, but no disintegrations

Here let me lay this out as clear as possible to prove this option gets us everything we need

of the remaining all confirmed

GNIPS - medic

Con Val - cop

Ebon - hated

4 remain questionable

If we kill Broba today eliminates number 1 that we are most confident about

Both scan (Jabba + Con Val) LP Confirms number 2 [Doc must protect CV]

We let Jabba Reveal first. Either confirms Jabba as Scum or town number 3

then there will only be me if there is 2 Scum found out i'm clearly town if not i'm clearly scum Number 4

We know Everybody in the whole game at that point

Just now, Lord Preyer said:

I am not ruling out the Broba thing - it just doesn’t feel like Broba to me and never really has this game except for scummarining and I don’t think he’s lying to us about real life pressures.

No one thinks he's lying, but just despite that you could still be scummarining.. and i think better that we kill Jabba and have CV investigate Broba

@Constantine Valdor

Just now, Matt3412 said:

Here let me lay this out as clear as possible to prove this option gets us everything we need

of the remaining all confirmed

GNIPS - medic

Con Val - cop

Ebon - hated

4 remain questionable

If we kill Broba today eliminates number 1 that we are most confident about

Both scan (Jabba + Con Val) LP Confirms number 2 [Doc must protect CV]

We let Jabba Reveal first. Either confirms Jabba as Scum or town number 3

then there will only be me if there is 2 Scum found out i'm clearly town if not i'm clearly scum Number 4

We know Everybody in the whole game at that point

If Jabba is scum he can lie, then CV can't confirm anything

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

If Jabba is scum he can lie, then CV can't confirm anything

YES thats the point!!! CV WILL KNOW HES LYING AND TELL US!!!

Just now, Matt3412 said:

YES thats the point!!! CV WILL KNOW HES LYING AND TELL US!!!

No he won't he says LP is town and LP is town, then what does CV do, say jab is telling the tryth?

Scum now all the town, its given with the role...

So if Jabba is scum knowing the plan ahead a day early he isn't going to say LP is scum and blow himself, he will give the result CV gets which implicates Broba...

so better to hang Jabba and confirm both of us or not, and then get CV on Broba

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

No he won't he says LP is town and LP is town, then what does CV do, say jab is telling the tryth?

Scum now all the town, its given with the role...

Your missing it let me try again.

its irrelevant what Jabba says...

CV is going to know that LP is scum or not.

1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:

Your missing it let me try again.

its irrelevant what Jabba says...

CV is going to know that LP is scum or not.

YES... and we will still be in the dark over Broba...

and if LP is town then it means someone of me, you, jabba is lying

not missing anything

Look if broba dies today we will know one scum or one town.

we will know what LP is Scum or Town.

After that its pretty simple to get us to who the last person left is

Broba is going to be dead caldias will tell us????

2 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

Your missing it let me try again.

its irrelevant what Jabba says...

CV is going to know that LP is scum or not.

But as I keep saying, if Jabba is Scum and I am not then he knows CV will say I am not and so he will say cleared on me and then we’re stuck again!

no we are not because we believe CV correct????

1 minute ago, Lord Preyer said:

But as I keep saying, if Jabba is Scum and I am not then he knows CV will say I am not and so he will say cleared on me and then we’re stuck again!

I think what he's trying to say by killing broba, if he's scum and CV rolls town on you it will implicate Jabba

Just now, Matt3412 said:

no we are not because we believe CV correct????

correct, although I think it better to hang jabba and just get CV to investigate LP/Broba and confirm the other one as scum

I don't buy TWO cops in a game with only 2 scum I mean c'mon