Scum possibilities:
Jabba/Matt: Jabba ‘cleared’ Matt (eg coverered for him)
Jabba/Ebon: Jabba ‘cleared’ Ebon (eg covered for him)
Broba/LP: scummarining and however you so choose to characterise my game
Broba/Matt: (not sure that’s even possible because of scans)
Broba/Ebon: (not sure that’s even possible because of scans)
Anything missing/wrong here?
2 minutes ago, BrobaFett said:while gnips distrust ebon because he had a solid claim that took a lot of heat off of him offered early with no prompting and he hasn't been scanned or really considered much since then.
With 11 players of which 2 scum, 1 3rd party, and 8 town
with the 3rd party targeting a town, and my role it evens the game for scum who other wise would be at a disadvantage
2 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:Scum possibilities:
Jabba/Matt: Jabba ‘cleared’ Matt (eg coverered for him)
Jabba/Ebon: Jabba ‘cleared’ Ebon (eg covered for him)
Broba/LP: scummarining and however you so choose to characterise my game
Broba/Matt: (not sure that’s even possible because of scans)
Broba/Ebon: (not sure that’s even possible because of scans)
Anything missing/wrong here?
nope
2 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:Scum possibilities:
Jabba/Matt: Jabba ‘cleared’ Matt (eg coverered for him)
Jabba/Ebon: Jabba ‘cleared’ Ebon (eg covered for him)
Broba/LP: scummarining and however you so choose to characterise my game
Broba/Matt: (not sure that’s even possible because of scans)
Broba/Ebon: (not sure that’s even possible because of scans)
Anything missing/wrong here?
oh yes Broba/Jabba
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:With 11 players of which 2 scum, 1 3rd party, and 8 town
with the 3rd party targeting a town, and my role it evens the game for scum who other wise would be at a disadvantage
I buy this as quite likely.
Am more worried by the Matt/Jabba possibility.
My order of fear is:
1) Jabba/Matt
2) Jabba/Broba
3) Jabba/Ebon
Um jabba is my number 2 suspect but I think logically we should use his claim to our power to eliminate the possibility's I mean look at my posts against jabba today. jesus I'm not working with him at all lol
Just now, EbonHawk said:oh yes Broba/Jabba
because while Jabs claim is believable it was so darn late, and would have liked cv to go and scan him
Just now, Matt3412 said:Um jabba is my number 2 suspect but I think logically we should use his claim to our power to eliminate the possibility's I mean look at my posts against jabba today. jesus I'm not working with him at all lol
that is exactly what scum working together would say to play devils advocate
He literally tried to get me killed?!?! And I'm trying to get him killed there is no way for mafia to win with those results if we were the pair
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:because while Jabs claim is believable it was so darn late, and would have liked cv to go and scan him
also i don't get why he gets a pre game scan and CV didn't but as gnips said it doesn't have to mirror
1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:Um jabba is my number 2 suspect but I think logically we should use his claim to our power to eliminate the possibility's I mean look at my posts against jabba today. jesus I'm not working with him at all lol
There are ways he could game his response the next day and he is a seasoned enough player to likely know them even better than some of us!
Also, whilst you do read as Town for your scumhunting to me I don’t automatically buy a willingness to attack/pursue a target as proof that you are not actually allied with that player. Have seen that movie too often now! 
1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:He literally tried to get me killed?!?! And I'm trying to get him killed there is no way for mafia to win with those results if we were the pair
The logic stands that if we kill broba today
Both cops scan LP tonight
Jabba revels first. Cv gets to check if hes lying.
And then either kill lp found guilty 2nd scum or kill jabba for lying.
1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:He literally tried to get me killed?!?! And I'm trying to get him killed there is no way for mafia to win with those results if we were the pair
We've been through this before. Scum have slit each others throats for credit in the past.
And as long as the medic protects cv we are fine cuz if jabba dies we know hes town and I'm confirmed as well
1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:The logic stands that if we kill broba today
Both cops scan LP tonight
Jabba revels first. Cv gets to check if hes lying.
And then either kill lp found guilty 2nd scum or kill jabba for lying.
But if Jabba were scum wouldn’t he just lie!?
Just now, Matt3412 said:The logic stands that if we kill broba today
Both cops scan LP tonight
Jabba revels first. Cv gets to check if hes lying.
And then either kill lp found guilty 2nd scum or kill jabba for lying.
I like this tbf
Meaning LP would be bad and cv w po uld know that
Just now, Lord Preyer said:But if Jabba were scum wouldn’t he just lie!?
doesn't matter, because CV would know the truth.. so he would get caught
wait I see he would jsut say you're town anyway
Its literally right in front of us how to proceed
it would be better for CV to scan jabba thereby confirming Jabba or not, which would then confirm or accuse Matt/LP
Its process of elimination we find out everyone this does not benefit me at all you will know what I am for sure
2 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:Meaning LP would be bad and cv w po uld know that
But it falls apart if Jabba is bad and I am good! And I know the latter to be true which is why I’m worried about this!
Just now, Matt3412 said:Its process of elimination we find out everyone this does not benefit me at all you will know what I am for sure
no but as LP said if jabba is scum he will just lie say LP is town and CV won't be able to call him on it....
If CV scans jabba and he's lying it means you and he are scum which diddles town rotten
if jabba is true in his words than it's LP and Broba