Alright sorry been with the wife red dead for last couple hours lol

Give me 25 mins I'm gonna due some good old digging and try to dig myself to freedom lol

1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:

Alright sorry been with the wife red dead for last couple hours lol

Give me 25 mins I'm gonna due some good old digging and try to dig myself to freedom lol

this could actually be good

Matt spends all afternoon with Red Dead, now seeks Redemption.

6 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Matt spends all afternoon with Red Dead, now seeks Redemption.

Ugh why can't we just lynch Mad for this haha

1. @LTD EbonHawk Matt3412
2. @The Jabbawookie
3. @GhostofNobodyInParticular LTD
4. @Madaghmire LTD, Constantine Valdor, Matt3412
5. @BrobaFett EbonHawk, The Jabbawookie , LTD , Lord Preyer Matt3412
6. @Matt3412 Brobafett, GNiP
7. @Lord Preyer
8. @Constantine Valdor
9. @EbonHawk

Pretty sure this is current, but if I missed something let me know!

can we get a current vote count comparing notes currently dont want to make a mistake

Just now, Caldias said:

1. @LTD EbonHawk Matt3412
2. @The Jabbawookie
3. @GhostofNobodyInParticular LTD
4. @Madaghmire LTD, Constantine Valdor, Matt3412
5. @BrobaFett EbonHawk, The Jabbawookie, LTD , Lord Preyer Matt3412
6. @Matt3412 Brobafett, GNiP
7. @Lord Preyer
8. @Constantine Valdor
9. @EbonHawk

Pretty sure this is current, but if I missed something let me know!

I unvoted Broba when Matt voted him.

when was lTD's vote on GNIPS???

3 hours ago, LTD said:

I do not have anything much to add here - just woke up - caught up - posting before heading out.

I seem to feature quite highly in people's suspicious lists - this makes sense as I don't say a lot and am not great at the reading between the lines stuff. I mostly do vote analysis, which isn't very helpful when we've only had one vote.

The main argument against BrobaFett was that he did not post very much - and now he has posted quite a bit.

1. @LTD - me - town
2. @The Jabbawookie - ?
3. @GhostofNobodyInParticular - ?
4. @Madaghmire - claims third party
5. @BrobaFett - makes no claims beyond busy and town
6. @Matt3412 - claims he did not vote when BrobaFett was a L-1
7. @Lord Preyer - unvoted when BrobaFett was at L-1
8. @Constantine Valdor - indicates some kind of scanner
9. @EbonHawk - claims hated town

Of those who remain, Jabbawookie and GNIPs appear most suspicious to me at this time.

## unvote

## vote GhostofNobodyInParticular because why not I guess?

5 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

I unvoted Broba when Matt voted him.

Updated!

still looking at some stuff but i have noticed a few things.

5 remaining unconfirmed town (im just gonna call myself confirmed cuz i have to for my sanity right now come with me lol)

1) only JAbba has remained unvoted on at any point not necessarily a bad thing)

2) GNIPS tells us to slow down at the lynch then immediately follows Broba onto me

3) LP + Broba have both claimed IRL events (some merit obviously)

4) If you believe me and broba as innocent JABBA has only voted on town people before we knew they were town

5) GNIPS has only ever voted for me even with 5 options. and 2 very viable trains one on the third party okay he woundnt know but one on his buddy Broba.

6) LTD and Jabba have both voted for Broda.

After all this im seeing a picture of Mad self claimed third party right??

and the 2 scum as GNIPS + Broda

No other combination makes sense but if i had to pick a sub it might be LP>>>> i really dont know

Well im gonna go ********************************************* dint want to spoil anything lol

excuse my grammer/spelling

3 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

Well im gonna go ********************************************* dint want to spoil anything lol

what's this mean?

red dead lol

This is one weird game.

Mads is likely third party - and we’re letting him live.

CV and Ebon are both likely Town (given interactions).

Broba was a possie scummarine/policy vote and opinion is now split on his truthfulness.

I have aroused Ebon’s suspicions. However, I myself find Ebon to be playing a quite Townish game (with the one exception of his cast-back to my Wine In Front of Me comment).

I also have a habit in this game of suspecting-dismissing-returning to Matt (based I freely admit less on evidence than feeling, hence me flagging suspicion rather than prosecuting a case).

Jabba, LTD and GNIPs are each playing very in keeping with their playstyle.

Of these three, I’m actually more nervous about GNIPs because we know from previous games how indistinguishable he is as Town/Scum - proving to be the voice of calm reason throughout. Oh GNIPs - why can’t you screw up more like the rest of us?!

Given Mads potential/probable(?) 3rd party role I’m guessing there are 2 Scum.

I therefore believe them to be drawn from this pool (in descending likelihood):

- Matt

- Broba

- GNIPs

- Jabba

As of now, I am leaning to a vote on either Matt or Broba.

@Lord Preyer i think your seeing the same things as me just i'm also in the middle of it lol...

i think if multiple people keep coming up with Broba + GNIPS high on there respective lists then there is something there.

Thanks Matt - that was a helpful post and a good piece of work re: Jabba. Second time you’ve contributed valuable theory with good logic. Thank you.

Mph and if you are scum, you are truly fulfilling the Mads/Cal Rule No.1 of Scuminess: always be scumhunting!

5 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

GNIPS tells us to slow down at the lynch then immediately follows Broba onto me

This is a good point

1 minute ago, Lord Preyer said:

Broba was a possie scummarine/policy vote and opinion is now split on his truthfulness.

I don't doubt he was telling the truth to us, but it doesn't mean he wasn't scumarining.. just that we were told what he was doing in that time...

2 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

I therefore believe them to be drawn from this pool (in descending likelihood):

- Matt

- Broba

- GNIPs

- Jabba

As of now, I am leaning to a vote on either Matt or Broba.

As said before Matt is the east vote this day, and if he doesn't die in the night and hoping we have another CV scan things will be clearer... But imo I don't think we should go for the easy option... as if matt is scum, after we get CV giving us another town and based on who dies at night it wouldn't be hard to figure out... right now my gut says Matt is town at least enough to see how he plays tomorrow

We have to hope for a doc protecting CV regardless!

5 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

If you believe me and broba as innocent

Does anyone? Serious question. The points are all definitely interesting. But none of it is a defense.

1 minute ago, Lord Preyer said:

Given Mads potential/probable(?) 3rd party role I’m guessing there are 2 Scum. 

Don't forget Ebon's hated role too.

Ok, if I deprioritise Matt, I have Broba, GNIP and Jabba.

Ebon - say is is Broba and it isn’t Matt. Who do you think the other scum is?

9 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

2) GNIPS tells us to slow down at the lynch  then immediately follows Broba onto me

5) GNIPS has only ever voted for me even with 5 options. and 2 very viable trains one on the third party okay he woundnt know but one on his buddy Broba.

I told you to slow down when we nearly lynched a guy less than 10 hours into the day, and I warned LP about putting somebody at L-1 before he defended himself. I voted you when you only had 1 vote on you less than 10 hours till the end of the day. How is that a contradiction?

And as for only voting you, yes there may have been more options, but the one I most want to vote is Mad, and everybody seems to have agreed that he should be spared. Jabba is only my third choice, so why would I vote him over you? Ltd and Broba are tied for 4th at the moment, so they are way down on the list.

Just now, The Jabbawookie said:

Does anyone? Serious question. The points are all definitely interesting. But none of it is a defense.

Don't forget Ebon's hated role too.

I do believe Matt for what its worth

3 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

Mph and if you are scum, you are truly fulfilling the Mads/Cal Rule No.1 of Scuminess: always be scumhunting!

^^^He's doing well scum hunting as town imo and if scum would be more than telling tomorrow

Just now, The Jabbawookie said:

Does anyone? Serious question. The points are all definitely interesting. But none of it is a defense.

Don't forget Ebon's hated role too.

hold up now jab that contradicts itself we are literally trying to get each other killed we both cant be scum

1 minute ago, The Jabbawookie said:

Does anyone? Serious question. The points are all definitely interesting. But none of it is a defense.

Don't forget Ebon's hated role too.

Further increases likelihood of just two Scum right?

Just now, Lord Preyer said:

Ok, if I deprioritise Matt, I have Broba, GNIP and Jabba.

Ebon - say is is Broba and it isn’t Matt. Who do you think the other scum is?

Jabba, then a soft Gnips

But I've thought Broba/Jabba since end of D1, and nothing has really changed that view