Fair enough. Sorry, a little annoyed you've been throwing shade at me this whole game without a whole lot behind it.

Yes, Broba is on my suspect list. Which is where he should be. Pushing him doesn't really point to being town, but he's been legitimately suspicious.

And furthermore, his argument is looking more desperate all the while. Matt is probably the second most likely player to get lynched. Or maybe me, but nobody's actually threatened to vote me.

So sure, you can read that as distancing. If you don't, I think you already know why I'm doing it, because you're using the same logic.

9 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

also

To be fair ebon, im not an idiot. I dont think anyone, including myself, would disagree with your "2 of these 4 must be scum" list excepting the fact they remove their name and add yours. It's not a far logical stretch to narrow it down reasonably to a likely 4. But that doesn't do us much good.

If Matt is a likely target I didn't see that in the texts. Maybe that was the vibe and i missed it, but he didnt appear to garner anything but the normal scrutiny and that is why i looked deep at him - not because he was an easy target but because he seemed to have undergone the least critical eye of all those left on the block. And I disagree flatly that Matt has given adequate "reasons" for his votes. But end of the day, I know the situation I'm in and why I'm in it. You are the one that said convince me or get lynched, and then say that I sound desperate? I think that is an organic byproduct of the situation and you are reading Your own words into it.

I didn't lead his statements or overstate my facts. I'm on mobile so mass quoting everything he said exactly isnt something I can do easily, but you can check them.

Final meta point - I messed up an went afk for almost a whole game cause i forgot i was playing. Do you think someone playing scum would do that, or does that sound more like a vanilla town accident? Cause that's what it was.

Anyway, heading into my great aunts birthday party haha I'll check in when I'm not being rude.

Just now, BrobaFett said:

excepting the fact they remove their name and add yours.

Why add his? He claimed hated town, making him a policy lynch soon. That's the last thing scum would want.

6 minutes ago, BrobaFett said:

To be fair ebon, im not an idiot. I dont think anyone, including myself, would disagree with your "2 of these 4 must be scum" list excepting the fact they remove their name and add yours . It's not a far logical stretch to narrow it down reasonably to a likely 4. But that doesn't do us much good.

Why my name?
I've literally told you all you have to kill me in 2 days anyway or town will lose due to scum being able to tubro me... which FYI would be the single worst scum play ever...

So the names stay the same

Just now, EbonHawk said:

Why my name?
I've literally told you all you have to kill me in 2 days anyway or town will lose due to scum being able to tubro me... which FYI would be the single worst scum play ever...

So the names stay the same

To be fair... It's literally the single last thing we'd expect... ?

1 minute ago, The Jabbawookie said:

To be fair... It's literally the single last thing we'd expect... ?

Also I may have been hasty in you at least, either you threw broba under the bus or saw the point same as me.. seems like a townie thing to bring up 10 town points to JabbaPUff

How much time left please?

Oh, and for what it’s worth I believe Broba. I think he may still be scum but I do think he had real life blindside him and that’s what caused his absence. Given my previous inclination to vote for him was largely grounded on a scummaring suspicion I am now in search of new targets.

And yes, that does indeed mean I’m back to looking at you Matt! @Matt3412

1 minute ago, Lord Preyer said:

Oh, and for what it’s worth I believe Broba. I think he may still be scum but I do think he had real life blindside him and that’s what caused his absence. Given my previous inclination to vote for him was largely grounded on a scummaring suspicion I am now in search of new targets.

And yes, that does indeed mean I’m back to looking at you Matt! @Matt3412

I don't not believe broba's excuse for not posting, it doesn't buy him out of scum suspicions... even more so as barring his excuse some of the other things he has said have been eyebrow raising...

Care to expand on why you're voting for Matt? As said he seems like the easy choice for anyone to go for...

5 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

How much time left please?

Just under 5 hours

On 11/9/2018 at 8:50 PM, Lord Preyer said:

I think Matt’s analysis of who voted on Town multiple times is extremely valuable (even though it potentially indicts me).

I further believe CV and Mads and suggest that we *gulp* take Mads at his word and let him play as Town for now.

I continue to think Ebon is Town.

I am now suspicious of Broba. This *feels* like scummarining but I would welcome an explanation.

On 11/8/2018 at 3:56 AM, Lord Preyer said:

I’ve just finished a reread (and no! I am not doing my epic reposting thing! It’s D1 for heavens sake!).

Matt looks more Town-ish (although we should note for the future the Matt/Mads interaction) whole CV looks AWOL.

Also, Matt has funny flavour.

So ##vote @Constantine Valdor (scummarining possibility + D1)

What changed? You seemed to be coming round to Matt

On 11/9/2018 at 4:19 AM, Lord Preyer said:

As for substance, I switched my vote to Vip because of the combination of my reread and my worry that a fragmented town vote would result in a no lynch. Given that our chief grounds for lunching D1 was non-participation I don’t feel a high level of guilt for this decision although I obviously feel Town regret.

As for the killing of Pod... that surprised me. It could be done to set Ebon up or it could be done by Ebon with that defence in mind (I can certainly imagine you cackling “REVENGE!” in ScumChat as you did this @EbonHawk ). Ah, the wine in front of me, strikes again...

Anyway, those are my starting thoughts.

LP testing the waters maybe? Not sure

But I'm rethinking him as town right now

6 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

I don't not believe broba's excuse for not posting, it doesn't buy him out of scum suspicions... even more so as barring his excuse some of the other things he has said have been eyebrow raising...

Care to expand on why you're voting for Matt? As said he seems like the easy choice for anyone to go for...

Just under 5 hours

I’m not voting for Matt yet. I’m signaling my suspicions shift.

I guess Ebon we just read Broba’s posts differently. I do read them as more Townish!

Oh - and the opposite of water testing. Trying not to screw up and end up at Lylo by signalling everything well in advance and inviting thought and challenge to maximise chances of avoiding mistake!

Just under 3 hours remaining

Way I see it,

Broba/LP/Gnips/Jabba pushing matt

So both scum could be on that wagon, or they could all be town and Matt and LTD are scum?

I don't see LTD as scum, nor Gnips or Matt... Which leaves me with Broba/LP/Jabba to vote, my vote is still on Broba and unless we get more talking I don't see myself switching.. Either way tomorrow we get a cop result back all things go well and we clear or find out Jabba...

I’d really appreciate it if one of you guys could start a train on my target that I can hop onto and fulfill my condition.

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

I’d really appreciate it if one of you guys could start a train on my target that I can hop onto and fulfill my condition.

That narrows it down at least

3 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

That narrows it down at least

Target wise - LTD/LP/Me/Jabba/Gnips

I don't think it would be me as it would be too easy, which means one of the above is town, and one of Broba and Matt is scum.. we know who my moneys on but I'll leave it to the rest of you, I'll be on till day end if my vote is needed but I feel happy where it is, especially considering I have to die soon so getting a scum before is imperative

1 hour ago, EbonHawk said:

LP testing the waters maybe? Not sure

But I'm rethinking him as town right now

Also, Ebon: this was ages ago and I don’t think it was saying anything particularly acusatory - it was more outlining what the logic of those moves in the wake of the Night Kill were. I don’t see how that is scummy when it’s (at least an attempt) at logical deduction and scenario theorising.

Just a head’s up guys: it’s 2239 local time now and I don’t see me making it all the way through another 3hrs so may have to vote before time’s up. Will try to stay awake for as long as possible. And will not vote for @Matt3412 for now as I would like to hear from him a bit more.

2 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

Also, Ebon: this was ages ago and I don’t think it was saying anything particularly acusatory - it was more outlining what the logic of those moves in the wake of the Night Kill were. I don’t see how that is scummy when it’s (at least an attempt) at logical deduction and scenario theorising.

Just wanted to see how you would react to it tbf, pretty much how I expected

@GhostofNobodyInParticular

@Constantine Valdor

@Matt3412

@LTD

@BrobaFett

Pinging you guys only as you've not recently been on, 3hrs left

forgot @The Jabbawookie

I haven't read anything yet to cause me to change my vote, really. If the majority goes for somebody other than Matt or Broba, I may join the vote, so as to avoid a no-vote. But I really don't think it is likely.