okay out of these 4 who do you think is most likely scum? @EbonHawk @Madaghmire @Constantine Valdor

LTD, JAbba, GNIPS, and LP

7 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

what if con is just making this up?

also no counter claim

also i missed the other guy but hes literally not doing anything

1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:

okay out of these 4 who do you think is most likely scum? @EbonHawk @Madaghmire @Constantine Valdor

LTD, JAbba, GNIPS, and LP

of those 4 Jabba and I'd say broba but that's my opinion

to answer your question in order of scumminess though Jabba/LTD/LP/Gnips

Just now, Matt3412 said:

also i missed the other guy but hes literally not doing anything

yes broba is scum marine central right now

from my analysis

LTD Jabba and LP are playing a joint game,

Gnips is doing his own thing still could be bad

and the other guy sorry im blanking has done nothing

Broba comes in end day, pushes the vote on Vip, then falls asleep unable to vote himself, and presumes to say nothing since

Just now, Matt3412 said:

from my analysis

LTD Jabba and LP are playing a joint game,

Gnips is doing his own thing still could be bad

and the other guy sorry im blanking has done nothing

3 scum and a 3d party seems alot,

Mads role as lyncher is town, but so could his target.. meaning 2 scum IMO

I can see LTD/Jabba, why LP though? His end of D1 read very town to me.

i agree but i'm having difficulty sorting out which one is which

Look at it this way

Mad kills his target - rolls town

town kills mad - rolls town lyncher

I'm tubro'd as a hated town late on

3 easy town kills, so 3 scum would be OP for me

Just now, Madaghmire said:

I can see LTD/Jabba, why LP though? His end of D1 read very town to me.

What about Broba?

2 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

Broba comes in end day, pushes the vote on Vip, then falls asleep unable to vote himself, and presumes to say nothing since

He may just have been working until now. The workday in the states isnt over yet. The rest is valid, but his silence over this period is very plausibly explained as IRL commitments.

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

I can see LTD/Jabba, why LP though? His end of D1 read very town to me.

i agree they just as a collective have not butted heads yet and voted similarly however i do read LP as the most town of the group.

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

What about Broba?

I’m not as into Broba as you are yet, see above. I wanna see what he says next.

Just now, Madaghmire said:

He may just have been working until now. The workday in the states isnt over yet. The rest is valid, but his silence over this period is very plausibly explained as IRL commitments.

I don't mind his silence so much as I know his IRL stuff, but I find his game lurky

Think when LTD was scum and got 3 people killed on the lynch without voting himself lurky

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

I don't mind his silence so much as I know his IRL stuff, but I find his game lurky

Think when LTD was scum and got 3 people killed on the lynch without voting himself lurky

I think I missed that game.

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

I’m not as into Broba as you are yet, see above. I wanna see what he says next.

Yes, I too am waiting for him to reply before fully going in, just a vote RN to get him in game...

But it's him or Jab for me, seen Jab play so many scum games of late due to his luck in rolling the roll and can't help feel like I'm in one of his games again

Just now, Madaghmire said:

I think I missed that game.

He nearly won it, best scum play I've seen IMO considering he was solo after his partner died

Just now, EbonHawk said:

Yes, I too am waiting for him to reply before fully going in, just a vote RN to get him in game...

But it's him or Jab for me, seen Jab play so many scum games of late due to his luck in rolling the roll and can't help feel like I'm in one of his games again

What behaviors of his do you find consistent? Last two times I’ve played with Jabba as scum he went down D1. Im not sure what his scum game looks like.

i feeling like my analysis from earlier that reveled LTD, and Jabba as consistently voting against town is holding more water with the info we have gotten

I would prefer to go with LTD for his early vote.

##vote @LTD

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

Yes, I too am waiting for him to reply before fully going in, just a vote RN to get him in game...

But it's him or Jab for me, seen Jab play so many scum games of late due to his luck in rolling the roll and can't help feel like I'm in one of his games again

As Watto would say, I’ll be needing something more substantial. Hopefully *someone* will scan me tonight so I can ascend to the cleared name club. My suspects right now are GNIPs, Broba (timing on both) and Matt (sorry, but I’ve been given no reason to drop that yet.)

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

What behaviors of his do you find consistent? Last two times I’ve played with Jabba as scum he went down D1. Im not sure what his scum game looks like.

He's a bit to eager to defend town, which is easy when you know who they're all are..

See how quick he was to jump in on you and me, to win an ally in you from aiding your defence.. to me that is jabba every scum game

where as town I find him more distanced in that sense imo, he defends more as scum, and accuses more as town, this game he's done more defending

Also Jabba and Broba were both on last night at the time viewing this forum and then logged in similar fashion...

Yes I was stalking the forum...

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

Also Jabba and Broba were both on last night at the time viewing this forum and then logged in similar fashion...

Yes I was stalking the forum...

to expand on forum this topic specifically