33 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

and then you unvoted clon, and revoted him remember.. so there's more to it than he had not been voted yet.. as the vote you made that mattered was the 4th vote on him

Well yes. At that point clon was getting increasingly vague and so three more people voted for him. I was still unsure if clon was scum, so I considered pulling out my vote and waiting for the next day. (Actually, I did unvote, as you mentioned.) Cal, Pod and Mad all convinced me its a bad idea to no-vote on Day 1. Pod and Mad both suggested this post would make me look like scum potential. I voted for pod again.

After pod said "I've got a cool power I want to use tonight..." or something like that, I thought oh great, he's gonna claim PGO. He did. I was fully onboard the clon-killing train station at this point, and I thought "if we don't kill clon, he's gonna kill me tonight."

Turns out I totally read the situation entirely wrong.

3 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:

Well yes. At that point clon was getting increasingly vague and so three more people voted for him. I was still unsure if clon was scum, so I considered pulling out my vote and waiting for the next day. (Actually, I did unvote, as you mentioned.) Cal, Pod and Mad all convinced me its a bad idea to no-vote on Day 1. Pod and Mad both suggested this post would make me look like scum potential. I voted for pod again.

After pod said "I've got a cool power I want to use tonight..." or something like that, I thought oh great, he's gonna claim PGO. He did. I was fully onboard the clon-killing train station at this point, and I thought "if we don't kill clon, he's gonna kill me tonight."

Turns out I totally read the situation entirely wrong.

I missed the part where Pod claimed PGO?

3 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:

"if we don't kill clon, he's gonna kill me tonight."

why would you think that? by your own admission earlier you where of the mindset you didn't start the clon train...

Just now, Madaghmire said:

I missed the part where Pod claimed PGO?

was about to raise that

Whoops, I meant clon when I wrote pod.

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

why would you think that? by your own admission earlier you where of the mindset you didn't start the clon train...

I thought he was scum, and he voted to kill me.

so who is on your radar for a top 3 then @Bertie Wooster

Just now, Bertie Wooster said:

I thought he was scum, and he voted to kill me.

Ironically, if Clon had been scum, that probably would have kept you safe, as it would look bad if the person he was voting died in the night. Of course, he could argue past it, but it would raise eyebrows and attract attention.

1 minute ago, Bertie Wooster said:

I thought he was scum, and he voted to kill me.

so by your own admission you only voted to kill clon because you thought he was scum and could kill you...

but if we look from the view point of you being scum using the same stance, LTD also voted you and turned up dead... could you be scum and scared LTD could be on to you, you and your chums took him out?

##vote Bertie Wooster

2 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Ironically, if Clon had been scum, that probably would have kept you safe, as it would look bad if the person he was voting died in the night. Of course, he could argue past it, but it would raise eyebrows and attract attention.

Good point. I didn't think about that.

9 hours ago, Bertie Wooster said:

I realize I probably look suspicious to some of you, since LTD and Clon both voted for me. I am hoping there is a loyalty cop (or two) in this game who has a report for us to clear things up.

The assumption there that the Cop scanned you out of 8 other people.. and I doubt there is 2

6 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

so who is on your radar for a top 3 then @Bertie Wooster

I don't know about a third, but I agree with you about Caldias and Jabba seeming like possible scum buddies. Caldias would be my top vote at this point, but I don't know if I want to vote yet.

Although you and me disagree on my innocence, your posts strike me as a townie trying to do a true investigation.

1 minute ago, Bertie Wooster said:

I don't know about a third, but I agree with you about Caldias and Jabba seeming like possible scum buddies. Caldias would be my top vote at this point, but I don't know if I want to vote yet.

Although you and me disagree on my innocence, your posts strike me as a townie trying to do a true investigation.

Fair enough, anything strike you in particular about cal/jabba?

and that we do for now at least, out of you cal and jabba, I gotta feeling at least 2 of you are the scum

7 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

The assumption there that the Cop scanned you out of 8 other people.. and I doubt there is 2

I was thinking about myself, not thinking rationally.

First thought: clon is scum and wants to kill me!

Second thought: clon and LTD voted for me, the cop will surely investigate me!

@Constantine Valdor how was your lecture? any thoughts on the scum?

@Matt3412 , @PodRacer would be nice to hear if you have any details to share (aside from the vote pod, do you have your reasons yet?)

13 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

Fair enough, anything strike you in particular about cal/jabba?

and that we do for now at least, out of you cal and jabba, I gotta feeling at least 2 of you are the scum

Actually, I'm having a hard time finding something against Caldias...I think what makes me suspicious is that when he posts, he sounds very reasonable, but he holds off on accusing anyone definitely or voting for someone until the last minute, or he may not vote at all. This is how he played in the last game, and he turned out to be scum.

I'm probably a little biased from the last game.

3 hours ago, The Jabbawookie said:

I think Ebon's the baker, 'cause he keeps throwing bread at us. Ebon and Pod fighting doesn't interest me, but I am interested in their agreeing with one another so quickly. If memory serves, one of them was scum last time that happened.

I think it was this post that made me kinda suspicious. I didn't really understand what he was trying to say (although his posts on page 8 clarify this comment quite a bit).

1 hour ago, EbonHawk said:

less pushing a vote more sowing the seeds for a case was what I put

Then why did you say this:

4 hours ago, EbonHawk said:

we never disagreed, I didn't vote him, and said I would hold off till today...

The people trying to make that more than it is interest me... Considering we have max 3 scum, maybe it's you for my top 3 eh Jab?

After all after Cal, you seem to role scum the next most often...

Of you, cal, and bertie, all 3 of you seem to be trying to push the vote on me or pod, reaching at times to do so .. it reeks of pre-planned (as see above, i never voted for him, or pushed him... bar the joke post on the first page when I signalled my intent to play)

Emphasis mine. Ebon, you weren't really on my radar but your distortion of what I said is making me suspect you. All I said re: Pod and Ebon fighting was in defense of you two as scum typically leaps on this as a way to cast shade.

26 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:

Actually, I'm having a hard time finding something against Caldias...I think what makes me suspicious is that when he posts, he sounds very reasonable, but he holds off on accusing anyone definitely or voting for someone until the last minute, or he may not vote at all. This is how he played in the last game, and he turned out to be scum.

I'm probably a little biased from the last game.

That's a fair point. I am pretty reserved when playing, either as scum or town. And the two kids thing makes it difficult for me to react immediately and I can see how my holding off can seem scummy.

Kids will be bed in an hour, after that I'll have time to dive into the past comments.

5 hours ago, EbonHawk said:

So Pod will not be getting a vote on him from me this game, he told me his plans for leaving the Republic

I believe him to be loyal to the cause fellow separatists.

My current Top 3 as it stands:

LTD (voted Clon then switched once the wagon had been set in motion, identical to his scum play previous when he went under the radar so long)

Caldias (literal 80% chance you hang this man and he's scum any game ever, he also seems to be trying to make a point about me and pod)

Bertie (He and Cal seem to reading off slimier hyme sheets, maybe in cahoots)

This post still haunts me. Not sure Ebon was scum pretending to be unaware that LTD was dead, or town and made an unbelievably fantastic blunder (how do you have time to post a YouTube video but not read GNIP's very important update?)

Anyone have time/vote tracker

12 hours ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

@LTD

1. @The Jabbawookie
2. @Caldias
3. @Bertie Wooster
4. @PodRacer
5. @EbonHawk
6. @Matt3412
7. @Madaghmire
8. @Constantine Valdor

I couldn't figure out how to not quote the names.

Okay well I have voted for ebon has anyone else voted yet?

Bertie Wooster - (2) Podracer, Ebonhawk

Ebonhawk - (1) Matt3412