51 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:Unless there is a role-blocker or strongman goon. Cop/doc are not invulnerable to their powers. Hopefully we can kill at least one of them this day.
Busdriver is dead, so is clon who was basically a vet..
Still if I'm role blocked in the night at least I'll know I'm onto the right people
so i think the three scum are in this list.
Jabba
Bertie [pretty confident]
Mag
Con Val
cal seems town do to his willingness to vote for bertie the others are dancing around it and con is not present.
2 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:so i think the three scum are in this list.
Jabba
Bertie [pretty confident]
Mag
Con Val
cal seems town do to his willingness to vote for bertie the others are dancing around it and con is not present.
I agree, I see Mad as town imo, though like Cal they're both hard to get exact reads on
i think town kills Bertie and you check one of the others at night. and i'm sure the medic will do what needs to be done
1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:i think town kills Bertie and you check one of the others at night. and i'm sure the medic will do what needs to be done
Yep, same as what I was thinking.. either way we have a max block of 3 town tomorrow, or 2 town 1 scum.. either one gives us options then on narrowing down the field
3 hours ago, EbonHawk said:nope, because there is only 1 and scum wouldn't dare
2 hours ago, EbonHawk said:Now 50% chance of hitting a scum. 2 cleared. 6 left 3 town, 3 scum...
Good odds in my book, and favour town more. If Doc does heal me tonight and I can read someone else, we look even better for tomorrow
1 hour ago, Bertie Wooster said:Unless there is a role-blocker or strongman goon. Cop/doc are not invulnerable to their powers. Hopefully we can kill at least one of them this day.
And this is why I hate early claims when you aren’t being pressured.
What we know for sure;
We had at least two power roles to begin the game, PGO (Clon) and Busdriver (LTD).
What we may reasonably assume is true;
Ebon is a loyalty cop (inference made by lack of counterclaim, weakness of other roles if they are only ones)
What that tells us about the scum faction;
Presumably, at least one of them can bust Ebons plans. There are three possible scum roles; Goon, Xshot Strongman, Roleblocker. Now, if there are three scum, its possible all three are goons, with the roles being used to balance the numbers. But its more likely, regardless of the number but especially if therr are only 2, that scum was given at least one role, in which case either can eliminate Ebons efficacy in the night. (Roleblocker by blocking, Strongarm through kill overriding possible doc protection)
This makes it all the more important that we are able to get a scum today. Ebon, if you have a negative result you for some reason have thus far been hesitant to share, I suggest doing so now and I’ll follow the cop. If you have something to clear someone, it would be beneficial to know that as well so we can stop looking at them.
3 hours ago, Constantine Valdor said:Just in case people think I'm always afk, here's my weekly schedule. Sometimes online during lectures.
You germans play a lot of tag.
15 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:i think town kills Bertie and you check one of the others at night. and i'm sure the medic will do what needs to be done
After reading my previous post, do you still feel confident in this action?
I only had one class before noon in collage you Germans try to hard haha
yes i still think bertie is the best suspect. that's all i'm really in control of
6 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:
And this is why I hate early claims when you aren’t being pressured.
What we know for sure;
We had at least two power roles to begin the game, PGO (Clon) and Busdriver (LTD).
What we may reasonably assume is true;
Ebon is a loyalty cop (inference made by lack of counterclaim, weakness of other roles if they are only ones)
What that tells us about the scum faction;
Presumably, at least one of them can bust Ebons plans. There are three possible scum roles; Goon, Xshot Strongman, Roleblocker. Now, if there are three scum, its possible all three are goons, with the roles being used to balance the numbers. But its more likely, regardless of the number but especially if therr are only 2, that scum was given at least one role, in which case either can eliminate Ebons efficacy in the night. (Roleblocker by blocking, Strongarm through kill overriding possible doc protection)
This makes it all the more important that we are able to get a scum today. Ebon, if you have a negative result you for some reason have thus far been hesitant to share, I suggest doing so now and I’ll follow the cop. If you have something to clear someone, it would be beneficial to know that as well so we can stop looking at them.
Only result I've had was last night, no pre-game stuff
and with a 50% chance, I feel getting a scum today is well within reach
well i guess my spelling took a hit because of that lol. good thing i'm good at math
@Madaghmire Ebon claimed that he investigated Podracer and result was negative. It was helpful information for me; now I suspect Ebon and Pod much less and Cal is my #1 suspect again.
Just now, Bertie Wooster said:@Madaghmire Ebon claimed that he investigated Podracer and result was negative. It was helpful information for me; now I suspect Ebon and Pod much less and Cal is my #1 suspect again.
this further enforces my cal being town theory
4 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:@Madaghmire Ebon claimed that he investigated Podracer and result was negative. It was helpful information for me; now I suspect Ebon and Pod much less and Cal is my #1 suspect again.
reasons for cal?
11 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:I only had one class before noon in collage you Germans try to hard haha
Efficient is the word
16 hours ago, Bertie Wooster said:Actually, I'm having a hard time finding something against Caldias...I think what makes me suspicious is that when he posts, he sounds very reasonable, but he holds off on accusing anyone definitely or voting for someone until the last minute, or he may not vote at all. This is how he played in the last game, and he turned out to be scum.
I'm probably a little biased from the last game.
This still holds true for me.
I haven't been in a game where Cal played town, so it's hard to know if what he says is true, that he plays town and scum in a similar reserved fashion.
I don't agree with those saying Cal is scum most of the time, so he's probably scum this time, etc. Poor logic.
But he tends to jump on trains when is scum. Granted, town do the same thing. Actually, I'm doing the same thing he is, waiting for information before making a vote. So I guess I'm a hypocrite.
The only other person who seems kind of suspicious is CV, who still has not given much information.
If there are four votes on me, please notify me before the last vote is cast.
2 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:I don't agree with those saying Cal is scum most of the time, so he's probably scum this time, etc. Poor logic.
But he tends to jump on trains when is scum. Granted, town do the same thing. Actually, I'm doing the same thing he is, waiting for information before making a vote. So I guess I'm a hypocrite.
The only other person who seems kind of suspicious is CV, who still has not given much information.
If there are four votes on me, please notify me before the last vote is cast.
Honestly, I look like I jump on trains regardless of faction, which is due to being busy with 2 kids and work being kind of high-traffic this go around. When I vote early I sometimes can't check in before a train forms.
Due to that, I am careful with my vote and make sure to declare my intentions to the rest of the players whenever possible. But sure, I can see how it could seem scummy and trying to hide behind other people's actions.
1 minute ago, Caldias said:Honestly, I look like I jump on trains regardless of faction, which is due to being busy with 2 kids and work being kind of high-traffic this go around. When I vote early I sometimes can't check in before a train forms.
Due to that, I am careful with my vote and make sure to declare my intentions to the rest of the players whenever possible. But sure, I can see how it could seem scummy and trying to hide behind other people's actions.
It's not a lot to go on, I realize. And I don't think you're lying about having two kids and not being able to check in.
BTW I can totally understand why people want to vote for me, I really don't blame you. I have put my foot in my mouth too many times in this thread, and I probably should have been more reserved like you.
So right now we have 2 votes on Bertie and one on Matt? Is that right? Did I miss any votes?
seems legit
Vote Count:
5 to hammer.
I don't want to die, but I'm not sure about voting for Matt either. He seems townish. I can't think of anything he said that I would question.
36 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:I don't want to die, but I'm not sure about voting for Matt either. He seems townish. I can't think of anything he said that I would question.
So vote for someone else without a vote on them then? saying you don't want to die isn't helpful in not dying
