I think hes the idiot...

so we should not kill him? Lol

On now and catching up from last night

11 hours ago, Caldias said:

Emphasis mine. Ebon, you weren't really on my radar but your distortion of what I said is making me suspect you. All I said re: Pod and Ebon fighting was in defense of you two as scum typically leaps on this as a way to cast shade.

Yes, the defence was there but in the context of berties post as said it felt pre-planned to me, like he says that, you reply this..

11 hours ago, Bertie Wooster said:

This post still haunts me. Not sure Ebon was scum pretending to be unaware that LTD was dead, or town and made an unbelievably fantastic blunder (how do you have time to post a YouTube video but not read GNIP's very important update?)

It's called getting an email saying the game had started, and posting what I'd knew from the night before, and forgot to check a night kill, which after a doobie and just waking up ain't that big a blunder... also more suspect of someone pushing scum overtures for purely forgetting to check someone had died (sidenote: if i was scum I would've known ltd was dead and wouldn't have made the mistake) so really think about it rationally

9 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

I mean he named 6 of the 8 remaining players, odds are good he pegged someone.

The way I worked it,

Pod - Town

Matt - town

Con - town

mad - town

the only 3 people I don't have any town read on are Cal, Bertie, and Jabba...

That is why I'm pushing those 3, with half the day gone

10 hours ago, Bertie Wooster said:

Well, not exactly. I said in an earlier post that Cal is my top suspect. To break it down, I suspect the scum are one of these two groups:

1. Caldias
2. Jabba
3. Matt

or

1. Ebon
2. Pod
3. Madaghmire

BUT CV could easily replace one of those three. He's obviously hard to read, since he hasn't said much.

what confirms this for me is Bert himself!!!!

I know from GNIPS I'm Town, and I know from GNIPS Pods Town, I'm not reading scum from Mad eitehr...

so lets look at your other list ey bert... the Exact same as my scum list but you swapped yourself with Matt.. could be could be, but he reads more town than you.. so why not make the other scum list the real scum?

Also to Clarify

9 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

Ebon on initial read seems the same, although the weaksauce argument on Cal is mildly concerning, depending on how I feel abouts Cals alignment. I need to reread his imteractions with Matt/Pod/Bertie.

Only Cal is saying my main thing is on him, in fact my vote is on Bartie, and my main area of pushing is Bertie, I've only mentioned cal in a couple posts of seeming to be in cohoots with bertie IMO... and when you account for my reads (see above) you see why I would think cal/jabba for being scummy with their history and what I know in the game/ and the other players seeming more town

7 hours ago, Bertie Wooster said:

I would like to hear from @PodRacer on why he voted for me and then bolted. Even Ebon was puzzled.

I like votes with reasons, no matter how small, you just gotta have reasons, can't vote and buzz off

9 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

It's called getting an email saying the game had started, and posting what I'd knew from the night before, and forgot to check a night kill, which after a doobie and just waking up ain't that big a blunder... also more suspect of someone pushing scum overtures for purely forgetting to check someone had died (sidenote: if i was scum I would've known ltd was dead and wouldn't have made the mistake) so really think about it rationally

OK. I didn't get that email, and I don't smoke doobies, so I didn't think of those two possibilities.

1 minute ago, Bertie Wooster said:

OK. I didn't get that email, and I don't smoke doobies, so I didn't think of those two possibilities.

You can turn it on via settings when you get tagged in posts

10 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

I know from GNIPS I'm Town, and I know from GNIPS Pods Town

Are you claiming to be the loyalty cop?

Just now, Bertie Wooster said:

Are you claiming to be the loyalty cop?

That Loaf was dropped days ago

With 2 Town power roles dead, and a likely Doc as well that means max chance of 3 scum.

So today we have high odds with clearing 2 people as town for taking 1 of you out

38 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

@PodRacer why did you vote for me? Like I'm looking and I cant even find a reason?

Felt like being on a wagon you couldn't follow me onto.

Well I'm town boys

2 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

Well I'm town boys

Yep you read as such IMO, as does Mad.

Con I feel less and less the quieter he is, but his excuse is believable

and you see how I reach Cal, Bert, Jab

also if there is a Doc on me tonight please and thank you

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

Yep you read as such IMO, as does Mad.

Con I feel less and less the quieter he is, but his excuse is believable

and you see how I reach Cal, Bert, Jab

Wut, I posted a lot this morning ?

1 minute ago, Constantine Valdor said:

Wut, I posted a lot this morning ?

Yep, I said your excuse is believable from earlier, I also think you're town, but if you go quiet again I'd reassess (didn't word the best I'll admit)

36 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

The way I worked it,

Pod - Town

Matt - town

Con - town

mad - town

the only 3 people I don't have any town read on are Cal, Bertie, and Jabba...

That is why I'm pushing those 3, with half the day gone

@Constantine Valdor my reads as they stand

Just in case people think I'm always afk, here's my weekly schedule. Sometimes online during lectures.

So to be clear no counter claim on the cop???

3 hours ago, Constantine Valdor said:

See, this happens if someone vote, they got over analysed and everyone is trying to find dirt on somebody.

and of course I'm "suspect" again like last time. Well guess what, I got boring Town role again.

And to follow your own words form last game, "At least I don't contribute to Town death"

and You're always the only person aggressively throwing shade at me, others are fine with it

Hey, nothing personal. I'm just looking at behavior and posts to try and figure out who the scum might be. You were mostly absent and when you finally did post, you didn't really contribute to the goal of finding scum targets. You just stated looks like we have x amount of scum and faded away again. If you state beforehand hey look, I'll be largely busy but will try to check in blah blah people are less likely to think you're scummarining

14 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

So to be clear no counter claim on the cop???

nope, because there is only 1 and scum wouldn't dare

1 hour ago, EbonHawk said:

The way I worked it,

Pod - Town

Matt - town

Con - town

mad - town

the only 3 people I don't have any town read on are Cal, Bertie, and Jabba...

That is why I'm pushing those 3, with half the day gone

what confirms this for me is Bert himself!!!!

I know from GNIPS I'm Town, and I know from GNIPS Pods Town, I'm not reading scum from Mad eitehr...

so lets look at your other list ey bert... the Exact same as my scum list but you swapped yourself with Matt.. could be could be, but he reads more town than you.. so why not make the other scum list the real scum?

Also to Clarify

Only Cal is saying my main thing is on him, in fact my vote is on Bartie, and my main area of pushing is Bertie, I've only mentioned cal in a couple posts of seeming to be in cohoots with bertie IMO... and when you account for my reads (see above) you see why I would think cal/jabba for being scummy with their history and what I know in the game/ and the other players seeming more town

FWIW, this puts you at 50/50 for me now, and especially as there is no counter claim. I still think you distorted what I said, which is a scum thing to do, but maybe it was unintentional/due to a misread. Assuming you really are the cop, and Pod is cleared, that does narrow the field some.

With that, I'm willing to vote on Bertie. I will wait a bit, though, just in case a cop counter claim comes.

Just now, Caldias said:

FWIW, this puts you at 50/50 for me now, and especially as there is no counter claim. I still think you distorted what I said, which is a scum thing to do, but maybe it was unintentional/due to a misread. Assuming you really are the cop, and Pod is cleared, that does narrow the field some.

With that, I'm willing to vote on Bertie. I will wait a bit, though, just in case a cop counter claim comes.

interesting, and this changes my read on you somewhat, I know out of you, jabba, and bertie 1 has to be town at least..

possible I misread you at the start, I'll take it into account

3 minutes ago, Caldias said:

FWIW, this puts you at 50/50 for me now, and especially as there is no counter claim. I still think you distorted what I said, which is a scum thing to do, but maybe it was unintentional/due to a misread. Assuming you really are the cop, and Pod is cleared, that does narrow the field some.

With that, I'm willing to vote on Bertie. I will wait a bit, though, just in case a cop counter claim comes.

Now 50% chance of hitting a scum. 2 cleared. 6 left 3 town, 3 scum...

Good odds in my book, and favour town more. If Doc does heal me tonight and I can read someone else, we look even better for tomorrow

1 hour ago, EbonHawk said:

If Doc does heal me tonight and I can read someone else, we look even better for tomorrow

Unless there is a role-blocker or strongman goon. Cop/doc are not invulnerable to their powers. Hopefully we can kill at least one of them this day.