what percentage was Ebon at when you put a vote out?

Lucky guess I did not have any information at all at that point.

But if there was 4 scum at the time and 11 other people then me. Knowing I wasn't scum lol.

It would have been 36%

That was day one right?

so why isn't 66% enough to vote RN?

Idk I'm inclined to follow caldis ask and let him speak maybe it will change to 100% certainty based on what he says or to 0% town which helps us greatly. We then know for sure without a town kill. Or nothing is resolved and I will vote for him.

I’m not sure about GNIP. He was on the ovi train, did jump off to vote briefly for Jabba, but then jumped back to ovi as that train started picking up steam.

Unlikely scum, but maybe an SK

And he’s still MIA

##unvote, have it your way, Im kinda hoping Gnips also Knocks it out the park RN.

4 scum would explain Ovi's gambit yesterday...

@ Gnips

how does Matt know that your not the medic?

2 hours ago, Matt3412 said:

So if we agree no sk

And we have narrowed it down to 4 but one is the medic

I know Gnips is not the medic based on something I would like not to reveal at this point

Meaning he is one of 3, if we agree on there being 2 scum left.

66% hes scum

Just feels to me like you know more than Cal does at this point u know?

Alright - I lost my post, and I don't have time to write it again. The gist of it was that I think that we likely have 2 scum left and no serial killer.

I saw a list of 4 names up above, and I would like to know the reasoning behind it @Matt3412 ? Why that group of 4?

Ok time for some roleplay

Im a mod hosting a game, and Im dropping a new player in D2 to a game Town lynched correctly D1.

Am I thinking...

a)here town have a re-enforcement

b)here scum have a re-enforcement

c)

When in doubt pick c.

@Onidsen the list of four seems to be:

matt3142 declared himself paranoid to prove ovi a liar and get him lynched.

Lord Preyer was almost killed by scum night one.

Gengis Jon saved Lord Preyer by stealing a med kit from the doctor and using it

Caldias who says he knows who the doctor is and it ain’t Gengis Jon but it probably isn’t me either but how else would he know that unless he is the sergeant so he’s probably the doctor

6 hours ago, Matt3412 said:

What if out of this group of people there is 2 scum, 1 SK, and a medic

Onidsen

GnIps

LTD

Visovics

Or no SK and instead another town.

Visovics can’t be the medic - he arrived day two.

There's gotta be a scrap of info out there that can help us break this...

## vote visovics

My LTD WHIM TM is tingling.

Vis stuck with a vote on Matt after it became clear Ovi was lying. He turns up day two, night two we have two kills.

Thanks for the rundown.

My analysis now. With the reveal of the deserter, both Lord preyer and gengis are as confirmed town as they can get.

Matt is... probably town? The interaction with ovi seems really town. The fact that ovi was a deserter and not scum means that it doesn't prove it, though. Although, I can't think of a reason why Matt would lie if he were scum - maybe it proves more than I initially assumed. I'll call him mostly confirmed.

Caldias - I'm not willing to discount him at all. His claim is a fine place for a scum to hide - the scout role could give him the information he's claimed.

So the 2 scum are in the group of caldias, pod, ltd, nippy, and Visovics.

I'm up for lynching ##vote GNips

@PodRacer you were on this train earlier. Want in on it again?

Those voting for GNIP, how do you explain his voting on the last hammer?

I’m not saying it confirms him town, but what else are you going on otherwise?

Eager to here LP’s analysis. I’d caution against making any decisive moves until he’s had a chance to shake off the lightspeed lag.

Also, curious to see if GNIPs will surface on this day.

Gengis - ovi turned out to be scum that none of the scum knew was scum.

24 minutes ago, Gengis Jon said:

Those voting for GNIP, how do you explain his voting on the last hammer?

I’m not saying it confirms him town, but what else are you going on otherwise?

Are you talking about the hammer on the scum-aligned deserter, whose role description explicitly says that the rest of the scum-aligned don't know who they are? During that hammer, the scum knew that neither player involved in the standoff were one of theirs (except the possibility of a deserter), so it was a safe way to get a lynch without getting too much scrutiny. And, if they were in on the lynch of the real marine, they could safely lead the charge against the fake one and get 2 lynches for the price of one. Unless they were explicitly worried about the deserter, that is.

I almost think that I'd expect to find both (assuming 2, but I've publicly done that already, so all future posts will assume 2 remaining unless given good reason to think otherwise) scum in on the ovi lynch, although a case could be made for a 1-1 split to try and distance themselves from each other.

Frankly, my vote was based on looking at the group of 5 players among whom the scum are hiding and picking the one that I had the worst gut feeling about.

Still got my eye on LTD and pod, but that's just paranoia about possible gambits. If we have a sergeant, one or both of those would be excellent targets. Actually, if we have a sergeant who has scanned anyone in that group of 5, we can narrow it down further, but I don't think that I want to call for a reveal yet. Unless you - by some excellent luck - can confirm 2 of the players in the following group:

Gnips

Vis

LTD

Podracer

Caldias

Or myself - that info isn't useful to me, but all the town in this list have me on their list of 5.

9 hours ago, PodRacer said:

Got any reads @Visovics ?

Still on my lingering feel on Oni, on both days he voted on the 3th/4th slot, which is the ones that least draw attention, you’re not starting the train, but also not the one responsible for finishing

I still don’t understand the case against Gnips btw

@Onidsen - how can I still be suspect?

I started the train on Ebon - why would I do that if I were scum? Sure, if I were the deserter it could be an option - but we know who the deserter is / was and it ain’t me.

What is your voting record onidsen? Which scum have you helped eliminate?

***SPECIAL EVENT***

As you are mulling about the ship, discussing the next course of action the Ship begins to tremble Violently. the Structural integrity is pushed to the limit and much of the internal supports of the ship fail as another series of explosions course through the derelict vessel, caused by some unknown force... as the dust clears many passages are blocked. The group has been divided, and it will take some time to clear a path through.

You will be split into two randomly assigned groups, for the remainder of the day no-one may post in this thread. Instead each group will have their own Google Doc where you may continue to discuss and a majority vote withing each group will still result in a hammer. the day will end when Both parties have hammered or the clock runs down