4 ship vs 5 Ship

By kayarn, in X-Wing Squad Lists

HI,

Looking for some advice on a rebel list. Trying to decide whether to go with a 4 or 5 ship setup.

First the 4-ship list:

BTL-A4 Y-wing - “Dutch” Vander - 55
•“Dutch” Vander - Gold Leader (42)
Expert Handling (2)
Proton Torpedoes (9)
R4 Astromech (2)

RZ-1 A-wing - Arvel Crynyd - 36
•Arvel Crynyd - Green Leader (36)

HWK-290 Light Freighter - Kyle Katarn - 52
•Kyle Katarn - Relentless Operative (38)
Jyn Erso (2)
Moldy Crow (12)

T-65 X-wing - Thane Kyrell - 57
•Thane Kyrell - Corona Four (48)
Proton Torpedoes (9)
Servomotor S-foils (Open) (0)

Total: 200/200

View in the X-Wing Squad Builder

And now the 5-ship:

RZ-1 A-wing - Arvel Crynyd - 36
•Arvel Crynyd - Green Leader (36)

Z-95-AF4 Headhunter - Lieutenant Blount - 30
•Lieutenant Blount - Team Player (30)

T-65 X-wing - Wedge Antilles - 59
•Wedge Antilles - Red Two (52)
Marksmanship (1)
R2 Astromech (6)
Servomotor S-foils (Open) (0)

T-65 X-wing - Biggs Darklighter - 48
•Biggs Darklighter - Red Three (48)
Servomotor S-foils (Open) (0)

Z-95-AF4 Headhunter - Bandit Squadron Pilot - 26
Bandit Squadron Pilot - (23)
Homing Missiles (3)

Total: 199/200

View in the X-Wing Squad Builder

Any advice would be appreciated.