1 minute ago, Lord Preyer said:at this point you would have led the lynch mob on 3 Towns in a row
Mis-information
I didn't lead the vote on pod at all, as i didn't post about it. You on the other hand hammering him played more of an active role than I.
The 2nd one I cede
the 3rd, I only started on you after Clon was cleared by his role, and LTD and Gengis by a re-read... that leaves only you. Process of elimination
So (assuming there is 1 rebel) we can make 1 more bad lynch, as LP pointed out.
Before the town will lose...
3 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:so wouldn’t that significantly endanger you? If I die tonight then surely Town kills you tomorrow!
not at all, the game ends and we all go to observers and chat about a good game and your good scum play
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:this is one of many times LP talks of trying to kill a vet yesterday, hoping to get me or Ovi, in the hopes we wouldn't spot him..
No. That was not the case. The offer was genuine and I included myself in the vet category accordingly.
2 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:A grand plan LP,
Alas, there is no grand plan. Just me trying my best to figure this out.
Just now, clontroper5 said:So (assuming there is 1 rebel) we can make 1 more bad lynch, as LP pointed out.
Before the town will lose...
correct, but only 1
Just now, Lord Preyer said:No. That was not the case. The offer was genuine and I included myself in the vet category accordingly.
Alas, there is no grand plan. Just me trying my best to figure this out.
including yourself if just good cover for scum, makes people assume you're town because you offered it
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:Mis-information
I didn't lead the vote on pod at all, as i didn't post about it. You on the other hand hammering him played more of an active role than I.
Apologies. I thought you were the first vote for Pod.
5 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:- Oh, and the thing is, it would be true the other way round too. If I succeed in killing you in the vote today and I am Mafia than having been responsible for three incorrect kills the other way round Town should surely kill me tomorrow
CURIOUS!
Nope, because you know I won't budge onto the others as I see them as town so the only way you even make it to tomorrow is by killing me and hedging your bets
Just now, Lord Preyer said:Apologies. I thought you were the first vote for Pod.
I was, then was AFK due to family issues. So hardly leading a vote on someone, 1 joke vote post does not make a lead
But matty was all me and my bad
2 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:not at all, the game ends and we all go to observers and chat about a good game and your good scum play
I ask you to imagine for a moment that you are wrong in your suspicion of me and then see the consequences of that. We have both been wrong enough times in this game alone that surely that’s not unreasonable as a request?
Really the big question for us, if it's not me, and not you..
who is it, considering we both think the other 3 are town.... I wouldn't know
Just now, Lord Preyer said:I ask you to imagine for a moment that you are wrong in your suspicion of me and then see the consequences of that. We have both been wrong enough times in this game alone that surely that’s not unreasonable as a request?
Seems we hit the post button at the same time, with the same thought lol
I'm thinking about it don't worry
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:I was, then was AFK due to family issues. So hardly leading a vote on someone, 1 joke vote post does not make a lead
Casting the first vote (even in jest) still counts as leading. After all, you could have recanted it. As such, I do not believe your accusation of misinformation on my part is fair.
##unvote to stop a errant hammer
Just now, EbonHawk said:##unvote to stop a errant hammer
I want to name my next VSD ‘The Errant Hammer’
If we're taking clon at his word
that's LTD or gengis
both claim Vanilla
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:If we're taking clon at his word
that's LTD or gengis
both claim Vanilla
No wonder we suspect each other so much!
2 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:If we're taking clon at his word
that's LTD or gengis
both claim Vanilla
And both would have been AMAZING, the utter lack of suspicious behavior is the ONLY suspicious behavior from them
LTD - Playing his normal game in every way, his unusual posting schedule is great scum cover, but reads town
Gengis - Re--read seems to be new player trying in get to grips with the game, has been pretty solid on just LP, which good cover for solo scum maybe, but also leans me to mroe new player thinks he's got his target
both seem town arghhh
Just now, Lord Preyer said:No wonder we suspect each other so much!
I think you're right LP, if i wasn't me, and you weren't you we'd probably hammer ourselves this game
2 minutes ago, clontroper5 said:And both would have been AMAZING, the utter lack of suspicious behavior is the ONLY suspicious behavior from them
Clon sums it up brilliantly here
So
Cons: any vote on either would be a complete stab in the dark for me, i couldn't call it either way
Pros: (if you can even call it that) we can one mislynch left
Gengis's constant questions lead me to think he's not the scum.
Every and I mean Every thing Gengis has said all game, has either been, good reasons for his votes, or questions about people, playstlyes, and generally trying to be better town.. something I don't think you have time for in your first ever game, plus being scum in it...
but i don't have any reasons for LTD other than the weaksauce, his usual timezone constraints is good scum cover
3 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:think you're right LP, if i wasn't me, and you weren't you we'd probably hammer ourselves this game
Ha! Yes! This. So much this.
@LTD @Gengis Jon get in here, we need you
I’m trying to put myself in the shoes of a neutral third party observer. As cub I could:
- vote for the player who cast the first vote on each of the incorrect lynches (Ebon)
- vote for the player who cast the hammer vote on each of the incorrect lynches (Preyer)
- vote for the player who voted in the middle of each of incorrect lynches (Clon)
- vote for a player who has not voted for any of the incorrect lynches (LTD and Gengis)
I can see why someone independent would just likely prioritise known incorrect killers (me, Ebon and Clon) to be lynched!
Option 1: lynch ebon for being suspicious and attacky basically
Option 2: lynch LP for those hammer votes
Option 3: lynch someone else, myself, Ltd or gengis. Who we are all pretty much In agreement are town
Option 4: wait 1 more day to figure out what happens (although if it's LP or Ebon, and one of the others gets killed tonight we will likely run into the same problem tomorrow)