Well now I admit to being stumped. I don’t think Moose is the SK (his willingness to suicide before that was ruled inadmissible seems a pretty good defence). I also don’t think there’s a third Scum so we just need to make one more kill to get this right!
Vis and GNIPs and Pod all *feel* more like Town today but I know that’s a poor read. But my own theorising earlier leaned me against CNinja so now I’m really confused!
Let me have a quick reread. Will be back in 20.
16 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:Well now I admit to being stumped. I don’t think Moose is the SK (his willingness to suicide before that was ruled inadmissible seems a pretty good defence). I also don’t think there’s a third Scum so we just need to make one more kill to get this right!
Vis and GNIPs and Pod all *feel* more like Town today but I know that’s a poor read. But my own theorising earlier leaned me against CNinja so now I’m really confused!
Let me have a quick reread. Will be back in 20.
Hammer is down @Madaghmire
No more posting guys till mad is on
As the hot desert sun descends behind the dunes, long shadows run into short tempers. The Jokers aren’t finding anything funny these days, and when one allows his depression to drag him down, his comrades decide to help him along. They tie Geonosis Goose to a rocket chair, and fire him off over the horizon.
(MandalorianMoose is dead, he was vanilla town)
It is now night. Night will end at 12pm EST on Friday July 27th.
Edited by Madaghmire22 hours ago, Ginkapo said:Anyone judged to be making deliberate intentional errors will be banned from ALL future mafia games and vassal tournaments.
Dont even think about starting that sh1t as a legitimate strategy.
I’d like the highlight the rediculoussness of this one more time. Like, I get now that that’s not a viable strategy, and will refrain from doing so if I participate in any future mafia games.
But to say that you will ban someone from completely unrelated VASSAL TOURNAMENTS ???
And on whose authority? Go kick rocks
Edited by MandalorianMoose55 minutes ago, MandalorianMoose said:I’d like the highlight the rediculoussness of this one more time. Like, I get now that that’s not a viable strategy, and will refrain from doing so if I participate in any future mafia games.
But to say that you will ban someone from completely unrelated VASSAL TOURNAMENTS ???
And on whose authority? Go kick rocks
Why worries?
To me it sounds like when my little sister told me "I am not your sister anymore" when she was mad. It is not something she could do anything about.
1 hour ago, MandalorianMoose said:I’d like the highlight the rediculoussness of this one more time. Like, I get now that that’s not a viable strategy, and will refrain from doing so if I participate in any future mafia games.
But to say that you will ban someone from completely unrelated VASSAL TOURNAMENTS ???
And on whose authority? Go kick rocks
41 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:Why worries?
To me it sounds like when my little sister told me "I am not your sister anymore" when she was mad. It is not something she could do anything about.
Can we keep this thread to game?
I think if you want to talk that then necromance the Day 0 thread, otherwise quiet, please
Edited by Visovics2 hours ago, Visovics said:
Can we keep this thread to game?
I think if you want to talk that then necromance the Day 0 thread, otherwise quiet, please
Is this a mod kill? 
night and an edit... Tut tut
No modkill, Vis is actually the voice of reason here. Keep it out of game thread guys, thats why we have observers.
(Sorry for the late start. Got caught up at work)
The sun rises over a decidedly less lethal night than the last, and the Jokers are perversely pleased to find only one of their number has become one with the force. The aptly named Kartkrasher discovered the hard way his brake lines had been cut on his nightly drive.
(Podracer is dead. He was vanilla town)
4 Remain. 3 votes to lynch.
Day 4 is upon us. It will end at ~2:30pm EST on Sunday, July 29th.
Dangit I was thinking Pod was a Vig...
TTTTT = Goon + Godfather, Serial Killer (Investigation Immune OR 1-Shot Bulletproof)
TT = Goon + Roleblocker + Godfather
and seems we are still 50/50 on SK or Roleblocker
My theory remains that there is one SK and no Scum. But it makes little difference - we just need one more kill I think for victory!
I fear for our chances if @CaribbeanNinja is the rotten apple and thus begin today by:
##vote @CaribbeanNinja
14 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:My theory remains that there is one SK and no Scum. But it makes little difference - we just need one more kill I think for victory!
I fear for our chances if @CaribbeanNinja is the rotten apple and thus begin today by:
##vote @CaribbeanNinja
Very interesting.
Are you sure you're not the one that needs the kill to win as a Serial Killer?
Either you're town, in which you've latched onto me from the start with absolutely zero evidence other than an incorrect read on Cal's post, or
you're the SK we're looking for.
Either way:
##vote Lord Preyer
I was kind of expecting this and am prepared to reveal if that is what the others wish too.
2 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:I was kind of expecting this and am prepared to reveal if that is what the others wish too.
Yup, was totally expecting you to come after me. Sadly I have zilch defense, and you've been shading me since the beginning. Again, if you're town, next time consider your tactics when you lock onto another player. I'm town as f. If you're scum, well done, you've made it this far.
8 hours ago, CaribbeanNinja said:Yup, was totally expecting you to come after me. Sadly I have zilch defense, and you've been shading me since the beginning. Again, if you're town, next time consider your tactics when you lock onto another player. I'm town as f. If you're scum, well done, you've made it this far.
Thanks for the advice. Can I ask you to consider the following please? And while you do (##unvote @CaribbeanNinja )
- I am Town
- I have told the truth throughout this whole game (you may recall from my three previous games when I was a Cop, a Mafia and a SK that on each occasion I sought to maximise truthtelling - that’s my tell if you will!)
- I am using this game to try and learn how to Scum hunt
- I admit I am on the green side of experience and seemingly in possession of no noted ability for this - alas!
- Thus my ‘locking on’ to you is a genuine (though admittedly potentially flawed) attempt to scum hunt
- But it is compounded by the difficulty I have had in taking a read on our compatriots
- I have not feared being lynched by Town as I will reveal myself as Town and then I hope the remaining Town can turn on whoever pushed for my death
- But I know this fails if you are not Scum!
- So I’m left at something of an impasse. In many ways it feels a little like D1 again: I know I am not Scum. I do not know who is. Hunches more than evidence now seems to be affecting my vote decision. (I am sure to a more experienced/able player there are lots of signs showing who the Scum actually is but to me there aren’t - sorry!)
So what I will now do is go back and do a total reread of everything and look to see if there is anything that I missed before. I may well still end up with nothing but at least I will try!
Hope this helps (Town ).
you guys playing? 
I’m about to be in a Store Championship all day today.
9 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:you guys playing?
I’m about to be in a Store Championship all day today.
Yeah, but I have been busy. I am not quite sure what to make of the day. All my reads are dead. So, I'm trying to make time to read over the thread in an attempt to get a better perspective on things. I was planning to refrain from posting until I had something more worthwhile to add.
Hopefully, that will be soon. I am also waiting for LP's input on the same subject.
Current count-
Lord Preyer- (1) Cninja
Well, the best I can conclude is that Vis has been acting somewhat strangely. He has long tracks of silence to be broken primarily by statements like "we need to talk more" or arguments that seem original but are basically rehashes of previous points. Until, of course, his push on Mondo yesterday, when he broke character, so to speak.
All this wouldn't be particularly suspicious to me, normally, except that it doesn't seem like normal Vis, and I haven't anything better.
2 hours ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:Well, the best I can conclude is that Vis has been acting somewhat strangely. He has long tracks of silence to be broken primarily by statements like "we need to talk more" or arguments that seem original but are basically rehashes of previous points. Until, of course, his push on Mondo yesterday, when he broke character, so to speak.
All this wouldn't be particularly suspicious to me, normally, except that it doesn't seem like normal Vis, and I haven't anything better.
Yeh, I have had some complications in life, and ended up getting very little time for mafia
I am absolutely lost on the situation, trying to get a good read, but can’t see any of you as scum...
I have reread everything.
God D1 went on forever.
And some of the histrionics were less than HELPFUL TO TOWN to put it mildly.
I came to no hard conclusions I’m afraid but did take the following impressions from the reread:
- @CaribbeanNinja has performed exquisite service to Town throughout the game. It is possible that he is the SK but there is nothing that is actual evidence of that (my D2 Cal suspicion is classed as suspicion not evidence)
- @GhostofNobodyInParticular has been fairly quiet but seems to have been helpful to Town (and arguably more helpful than I have been to be fair as I think I’m right in saying he was on both anti-Scum trains - is that right GNIPs?)
- @Visovics has been very quiet. He says he has internet/wifi/real life stuff going on and that may well be true. Or he could just be scummarining.
Therefore on grounds of rewarding active play combined with service to Town (and kudos if you are the SK nonetheless/even more CNinja!) I’m shifting my slight suspicion from CNinja to a anti-quiet, anti-nothelpfultoTown Vis position:
##vote @Visovics
Yeh I do agree I had quite the lack of activity...
and usefulness...
my only issue with dying is that it gets town even closer to losing
Count;
Lord Preyer- 1; Cninja
Visovics- 1; Lord Preyer