3 hours ago, Visovics said:This takes too many assumptions as facts
That’s a fair criticism. I could probably have done a better job caveating my assumptions as theories rather than bald statements. The latter was not my intent. But I do hope my attempt to lay out what my thinking/suspicion is and why still got the point across.
1 hour ago, MandalorianMoose said:Sorry ur barking up the wrong tree, plain Jane vanilla townie here. Does that help narrow down the setup possibilities that Cninja laid out?
Also, I gotta say I’ve got a bad feeling about our Caribbean brethren boys
Please expand on your bad feelings. You’ve happily followed me so far. (even in this same post)
Just now, CaribbeanNinja said:Please expand on your bad feelings. You’ve happily followed me so far. (even in this same post)
You’ve been helpful... almost... TOO helpful lol. Again though, I’ve been predisposed this weekend and haven’t been following too closely so this is mostly just a gut feeling rather than a “case”
anyone know when he voted for the last scum we lynched? And who started the train agaisnt our last Lynch who ended up being town?
I’m definitely the one who pushed both trains I’m glad to have done it too.
Now what I’m interested here is the fact that @PodRacervoted for you with zilch explanation, but I’m the one you have a bad feeling about.
Of the surviving 6, me Pod and Mando voted on Trance
Vis, Gnips and LP did not.
##unvote
##vote Visovics
The net is closing.
I can feel it.
4 hours ago, PodRacer said:##unvote
##vote Visovics
An actual case or just trying to get reactions again?
How much time do we have left please?
3 hours ago, Lord Preyer said:How much time do we have left please?
About 30 hours.
I do not know who I suspect the most here, since all my reads are pretty weak.
Pod is most suspicious for providing no reasons for his votes, though as he always does this and tends to be correct enough times to not discount it, I am not sure about him.
Mando is next because he seems to have been perfectly willing to follow CNinja before, and turns on him now based on a 'gut feeling'. I can't help but feel that if it were truly a gut feeling, it would have appeared earlier. Additionally, he hammered Trance without even seeming to know what he was doing (by stating a hangover), which concerns me as it almost implies he didn't care enough to make sure he was doing the right thing (especially since everybody else was waiting for Trance's response/defense). Still, he has been distracted for the past few days, so I can see a possibility (or even probability) of either the gut feeling being ignored and/or it and the quick hammer overlooked in a rush to participate. Due to the distractions, I am prepared to give him a pass, hence Pod is my number 1.
##unvote
## vote GNIP
final answer.
Came after me on day one, coming after me now.
3 minutes ago, PodRacer said:##unvote
## vote GNIP
final answer.
Came after me on day one, coming after me now.
Only very barely and, admittedly, not enough to vote on without anything more substantial. From experience I know your methods, though I cannot understand them, tend to work. So, I am as always a tad suspicious of you for the lack of explanations, but am aware that that is how you roll, so to speak.
Really I am more suspicious of Mando's behavior than yours, but chalk it up to his distraction rather than role, so that only leaves you #1 by default. I am a bit lost at this point.
How do we read Preyer here?
34 minutes ago, PodRacer said:How do we read Preyer here?
Just vote on him, then you can vote on me and you'll have hit us all 
I'm currently doing a read of the remaining players and for LP, I wonder if he dropped any flavor because of the SK role. It would make sense, since he's gotten pegged last few times using it. After taking everything in, he could have known there was an SK out there, and that's why it would make a bit more sense to reason that I was scum (SK). LTD made a decent case against him.
Still re-reading.
@GhostofNobodyInParticular, you actually did vote on Pod though.
Well If Preyer could be double bluffing with a whole new playstyle, Mando is more likely deceiving us with his vanilla claim.....
Unless we just let that slip by at face value...
18 minutes ago, PodRacer said:Well If Preyer could be double bluffing with a whole new playstyle, Mando is more likely deceiving us with his vanilla claim.....
Unless we just let that slip by at face value...
Yeah the case against Mando is his hammer against Trance (right after Vis asked for his claim) and then Pod votes on him and he quickly spits out a vanilla claim.
30 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:@GhostofNobodyInParticular, you actually did vote on Pod though.
Day 1, sure. I meant now, when things are more serious, and we no longer need to vote randomly.
But in Mando's defense, he's never had a problem with claiming.
The case against Pod:
erratic votes with no reason.
In his defense:
That is what he always does. Also, his flavor read (or question really) led to the demise of jabba. Now, that could have been a scum play to look up the PMs, and pose the questions about it. Ovi and I definitely sealed the Jabba train with his help.
GNIPs/Vis are in the same place with me. They haven't been around enough to read. That of course is quite possibly a scumMarining position.
Do we have a vote thief too??!!
nvm
I memeber
1 hour ago, CaribbeanNinja said:Yeah the case against Mando is his hammer against Trance (right after Vis asked for his claim) and then Pod votes on him and he quickly spits out a vanilla claim.
I can see how this looks suspicious. TBH I had had a gut feeling about you from pretty early on but didn’t voice it as you did seem to be helping town by scum hunting.
But then I rembered what gink said “always be hunting, especially as scum”, so when trance flopped town I thought I’d better express my concerns
On 7/21/2018 at 4:50 PM, MandalorianMoose said:Ballsack our cop is gone...
I didn’t think he was actually cop, thought he was just trying to soft claim for some credibility at a poor attempt at avoiding suspicion.... Someone must have believed him though. That hurts
This post still sounds odd to me as an excuse type of post
It serves no purpuose as town
and could just be the killer trying to make himself have an opinion that the killer wouldn’t