{Mafia} Jokes on Jakku
* were
Very suspicious.
2 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:I’m not entirely sure I follow your logic Ebon. Is it that you believe me to be scum because I think I have found a sign of scum based on a previous scum precedent and thus my uncovering of a possible scum tell makes me scum?
In which case, scum hunting will be really rather difficult indeed.
No I'm saying there's a chance you could be scum or the SK..
Based on your argument against ninja being too similar to mads a couple games back.. And even quoting said mads scum playing in your post.. The way you put it, cal called ninja out, ninja killed cal.. A tad obvious and just like I said about mad when he tried it (when cal crumbed doc) it seems more likely you saw what cal said could be interpreted that way, killed him, and run with the argument..
while you could be right about ninja, if i had to bet I'd bet on you out the two
@Visovics, @GhostofNobodyInParticular
we need your contributions. (We also need Mando, but I’m guessing he started his honeymoon. )
I think Ebon’s argument against Preyer is very far fetched and overcomplicated and forced...
Tho LTD’s really has me believing that Preyer it at least not town, not having many opportunities to check in, but will try as much as I can for the next few days, I think during the week I’ll have Wi-Fi
I imagine the Moose’s new bride would be happy if we were to vote him out...
Goodnight chumpions - enjoy your Sunday.
13 minutes ago, Visovics said:I think Ebon’s argument against Preyer is very far fetched and overcomplicated and forced...
Tho LTD’s really has me believing that Preyer it at least not town, not having many opportunities to check in, but will try as much as I can for the next few days, I think during the week I’ll have Wi-Fi
People said the same when i called it as an option last time, not saying I'm 100% but it was only 2 games ago and is just too similar, he hasn't offered a defence perform either other than reinforcing his read on ninja being possible scum..
I see it this was
Last game Mad cal crumb cop killed him and then spun it the next day as a possibility someone else saw it
This game, preyer sees cals post *could* be taken each way, kills him and then throws the possibility ninja did it, again as i said quoting mads scum play.. It just seems off to me
There is the chance preyer is town and saw the ninja/cal link but something's off about it, it just rings imo
1 hour ago, CaribbeanNinja said:@Visovics, @GhostofNobodyInParticular
we need your contributions. (We also need Mando, but I’m guessing he started his honeymoon. )
And trance, he may be new but we've not heard from him, nor nips either all day, and pretty sure pods had a vote on trance a while
Mando can get the honeymoon pass i imagine he has more 'stimulating' 
things to do
16 minutes ago, LTD said:I imagine the Moose’s new bride would be happy if we were to vote him out...
Goodnight chumpions - enjoy your Sunday.
2nd time in less than 8 posts you've mentioned hanging someome random... Joke or not watching you
Sorry folks, I had a busy morning.
I agree that Ebon's read of Preyer is plausible, but think it is a bit unlikely. Still, I shall keep an eye on them both.
LTD, however, is far more suspicious. Wanting to lynch a claimed townie in order to confirm his role? Really? Why not just make him promise not to use his role, and treat him as vanilla (if you are so eager to rid the game of his ability)? Why do the scum a favor and lynch another townie? I don't like it, so I shall
##vote @LTD
as having the most suspicious and detrimental to town proposition yet.
I shall give the thread a reread and get back to you all if something catches my eye.
20 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:Sorry folks, I had a busy morning.
I agree that Ebon's read of Preyer is plausible, but think it is a bit unlikely. Still, I shall keep an eye on them both.
LTD, however, is far more suspicious. Wanting to lynch a claimed townie in order to confirm his role? Really? Why not just make him promise not to use his role, and treat him as vanilla (if you are so eager to rid the game of his ability)? Why do the scum a favor and lynch another townie? I don't like it, so I shall
##vote @LTD
as having the most suspicious and detrimental to town proposition yet.
I shall give the thread a reread and get back to you all if something catches my eye.
This was my point against ltd, he has seemed odd this game, even the posts about typos just to appear to be posting..
Just seems bizarre you would make a town confirm and then still lynch them
I have 3 suspicions right now:
@CaribbeanNinja because of the Cal thing (I’d grade this as an admittedly lower ranked suspicion)
@EbonHawk for his somewhat freewheeling ‘LYNCH Pod! No, only Lynch Pod On day 1! Now look at Preyer! Now look at LTD!’ approach. This may just be how he hunts scum but it is a little bit eyebrow-raising to me. (Thus I’d still grade this as a lower ranked suspicion also)
@LTD what began as “vanilla” has now gone to ‘let’s force a Town confession and then lynch a Town’. (I’d grade this as a higher ranked suspicion)
—
Does anyone else see anything in my CNinja suspicion or am I barking up the wrong tree? I’m tempted to switch my vote now to LTD but we’ve still a bit of time left so would welcome other takes on this please.
Cheers!
24 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:Does anyone else see anything in my CNinja suspicion or am I barking up the wrong tree? I’m tempted to switch my vote now to LTD but we’ve still a bit of time left so would welcome other takes on this please.
I don't. It's such a commonly thought of idea (killing the guy who was after you) that most experienced scum never do it, as it is so obvious. Additionally, I didn't really read Cal as being suspicious of CNinja, so can't see a motive.
After rereading, I will note that LTD has not offered any defense of his idea to lynch the vig, despite responding to other points brought up in the same posts that criticize it. After it is mentioned two or three times he pops off with a mention of random voting (despite being in day 2 already, where we should be beyond the stage of random voting) and not even an acknowledgment of the criticism.
9 hours ago, LTD said:In the event Caldias or BrobaFett was killed by a Vigilante, it would be best for that Vigilante to come forward so we can lynch you in order to prove your claim and gain more data.
Suicide. One always ask for a suicide. It saves time.
2 hours ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:Sorry folks, I had a busy morning.
I agree that Ebon's read of Preyer is plausible, but think it is a bit unlikely. Still, I shall keep an eye on them both.
LTD, however, is far more suspicious. Wanting to lynch a claimed townie in order to confirm his role? Really? Why not just make him promise not to use his role, and treat him as vanilla (if you are so eager to rid the game of his ability)? Why do the scum a favor and lynch another townie? I don't like it, so I shall
##vote @LTD
as having the most suspicious and detrimental to town proposition yet.
I shall give the thread a reread and get back to you all if something catches my eye.
His point is based in the case the second night kill came from a vigilante. As he would be one-shot he promising not using his ability is stupid. His way we would know the number of mafia members.
3 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:His point is based in the case the second night kill came from a vigilante. As he would be one-shot he promising not using his ability is stupid. His way we would know the number of mafia members.
Maybe, but he wanted to lynch him. Why, especially if he is one-shot? Just to confirm his claim? As Ebon pointed out, it gives the scum a free townie dead. If he is lying, why would he come forward in the first place, especially knowing it's suicide? Additionally, if we don't lynch him, the scum can kill him, since he would be a confirmed townie, and that's a dangerous thing for the scum to have alive. So why ask for the reveal of the vigilante if all it means is help for scum? Seems silly to me.
It’s a ROUGH morning boys.... they generally follow good nights though!
I’ve read through most of the stuff, but my screen was swimming last night and I’m a lil out of it today so I’m not exactly taking everything in right now....
I’ll wait a bit more to go through it all again before voting, but off the cuff LTD does look suspicious
And I doubt Cninja kills the guy that was coming after him, it’s too on the nose and especially since like, no one had jumped on that train
3 hours ago, Lord Preyer said:I have 3 suspicions right now:
@CaribbeanNinja because of the Cal thing (I’d grade this as an admittedly lower ranked suspicion)
@EbonHawk for his somewhat freewheeling ‘LYNCH Pod! No, only Lynch Pod On day 1! Now look at Preyer! Now look at LTD!’ approach. This may just be how he hunts scum but it is a little bit eyebrow-raising to me. (Thus I’d still grade this as a lower ranked suspicion also)
@LTD what began as “vanilla” has now gone to ‘let’s force a Town confession and then lynch a Town’. (I’d grade this as a higher ranked suspicion)
—
Does anyone else see anything in my CNinja suspicion or am I barking up the wrong tree? I’m tempted to switch my vote now to LTD but we’ve still a bit of time left so would welcome other takes on this please.
Cheers!
##unvote for now, and as nips says below...
3 hours ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:I don't. It's such a commonly thought of idea (killing the guy who was after you) that most experienced scum never do it, as it is so obvious. Additionally, I didn't really read Cal as being suspicious of CNinja, so can't see a motive.
I agree, that's not a move i see ninja making as scum... And preyers response is enough for now..
Right now it's either preyer for pushing the ninja (although he seems to be in agreement with me and nips that he could've read it a different way) or LTD for soft claiming day 1 and repeated calls for hanging anyone for the sake of it, and what seems to be correcting grammar (a new move for him) in a way to keep up his posting..
Been at the grandparents all afternoon thought I'd come back to more conversation than this..
16 hours ago, EbonHawk said:
I know this will be the 2nd-3rd time today I've said it but we need to speak, half the time has gone and 50% of the conversation so far is just me.. And we've yet to hear from @Tranceform.. I know you're new but you must have something...
Gunna go back through ltds posts now
On 7/19/2018 at 11:08 AM, ovinomanc3r said:ok, that's the weirdest breadcrumb ever!
On 7/19/2018 at 2:17 PM, LTD said:Vanilla?
I hardly know her!
Joke?
On 7/19/2018 at 10:11 PM, LTD said:Crumbing?
I don’t even know... um... Een?
Jamaica is of course the classic default. Jakarta is a nice twist I only heard recently (and is closer to home).
And I maintain my vote - I can abide many things, but typing ‘of’ instead of ‘have’ (or even ‘ve) is a crime against brains everywhere.
Another joke about crumbing
On 7/20/2018 at 12:48 AM, LTD said:Lord Preyer - I made no claim of vanilla - that was merely an attempt at demonstrating another classic English joke to our Spanish friend.
We certainly need to vote for someone, and I’ve picked my random target. Should I be eliminated day one I will understand and hope my destruction will speed a town victory. The beauty of this game is that you win even being eliminated.
I think we ought, as a matter of policy, to vote for non-voters - that is the action of a non town individual. We have but our voice and our vote - beware those that speak but do not act.
Could you lead to a speedy town win? And calling again for a random ish lynch on a group of 2 people who didn't vote
12 hours ago, LTD said:Odds are we are searching for 2 more Mafia and one Serial Killer.
In the event Caldias or BrobaFett was killed by a Vigilante, it would be best for that Vigilante to come forward so we can lynch you in order to prove your claim and gain more data.
Again calls for lynching what would be known town
12 hours ago, LTD said:I agree - lesson learnt - also I did not claim to be vanilla.
I feel this is a less than optimal approach.
No he *didn't* claim vanilla at all.. Just joked about being it hmm
6 hours ago, LTD said:I imagine the Moose’s new bride would be happy if we were to vote him out...
Goodnight chumpions - enjoy your Sunday.
Calls for another lynch the 3rd one in less than 10ish posts.. This time not random but on moose.. I get 'another' joke
Not an awful lot from Ltd in over 72 hours... Anything to say? @LTD
3 hours ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:Maybe, but he wanted to lynch him. Why, especially if he is one-shot? Just to confirm his claim? As Ebon pointed out, it gives the scum a free townie dead. If he is lying, why would he come forward in the first place, especially knowing it's suicide? Additionally, if we don't lynch him, the scum can kill him, since he would be a confirmed townie, and that's a dangerous thing for the scum to have alive. So why ask for the reveal of the vigilante if all it means is help for scum? Seems silly to me.
I didn't say it was the most clever thing. I just noticed that you didn't bother to read his post properly.
The easier way to check if there is a SK or if it was a vigilante is, definitely, to wait for tonight's kills. Even if they skip a kill to confuse us it is good for us.
On 7/18/2018 at 7:07 PM, Tranceform said:#role confirmed
On 7/19/2018 at 12:39 PM, Tranceform said:I'm assuming you are referring to me when you say Trances but what do you mean by ##roleconfirm?
On 7/20/2018 at 1:25 PM, Tranceform said:Nothing to share unfortunately, I am just observing the arguments used so far. I would vote for Pod following the logic of:
Logic he agreed with below
On 7/20/2018 at 12:51 PM, The Jabbawookie said:Pod literally admitted he had a different win condition. That means a role. Since he asked if he could share a mod PM, it seems like he was strongly considering a claim.
As for knowing about the rivalry, I couldn’t have been part of an Ebon v Pod game; I’ve only played where Pod was the mod, and where Ebon was the mod. Ovino v Ninja was mentioned in Pod’s game.
The list is a way to get half these people off their laurels to say something useful. One or two joke posts (Ninja, LTD and Vis) doesn’t get you off the list. Posts actually about the game do.
On 7/20/2018 at 4:20 PM, Tranceform said:##vote Jabbawookie. Reason: it would be to scum’s advantage and town’s disavantage if no one is lynched on first day.
Despite saying he would vote pod switches last minute onto jabba to avoid not lynching anyone... He may be new, but like pod, i think he has mafia experience from outside the forums... Giving him new guy cred for now but is worth keeping an eye on imo
That's all from me rn until LTD comes on or the rest of you find mouths...
5 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:
Logic he agreed with below
Despite saying he would vote pod switches last minute onto jabba to avoid not lynching anyone... He may be new, but like pod, i think he has mafia experience from outside the forums... Giving him new guy cred for now but is worth keeping an eye on imo
I would buy the case against trance if his reason to hammer would have been different.
I mean, let's say he is scum. He openly supported Jabba's reasoning. Maybe he didn't think things would turn against his mate but when it comes to hammer time he did his job. Town cred? Maybe but why not build some better reasoning knowing he would flip scum. I mean, I was like 100% sure Jabba was thanks to Pod win-**** stuff. It seems like he really didn't know what Jabba was going to flip to.