4 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Cause I would like to steal Megamind memes from @Truthiness .

Actually I didn't notice I didn't confirmed yet. But how to proof it?

##role confirmed

Happier?

God that game was fun.

"Edit*

Ah, ****, sorry! I followed the notification and responded without noticing it was a game proper.

Don't worry Truthi, just follow me over here to my Ewok pit.....

2 minutes ago, Truthiness said:

God that game was fun.

"Edit*

Ah, ****, sorry! I followed the notification and responded without noticing it was a game proper.

Imperial spies everywhere... you're forgiven truthi

So we should kill someone. People I find of interest:

@ovinomanc3r for being weird and claiming to have info on Ebon.

@Ginkapo for general surliness and quick lynch nominations (not too out of character, though. ? )

Anyone who’s been really quiet.

51 minutes ago, Truthiness said:

God that game was fun.

"Edit*

Ah, ****, sorry! I followed the notification and responded without noticing it was a game proper.

Classic jester play

26 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

So we should kill someone. People I find of interest:

Anyone who’s been really quiet.

Well, I don’t know what to post. I’m relatively new to these games, so I don’t know the protocol. Do I post in character in line with my flavour and get criticised? Do I post IC, go with awful memes, never ending silence, or increasingly angry crud? I expect I’ll be lynched / murdered by the end of day 2 – if I make it to day 3 it’ll be a personal best.

We need to vote for various people so that we have something to discuss post lynch / hammer, yes?

Do I just vote for the person who seems the most annoying? Or is that a deliberate ploy to get themselves killed?

Relatively provacative day one play.

A couple things;

Playing into flavor is fine, but I’d be concerned about getting too cute and providing scum with more than you want. Or even showing something you don’t intend to which leads to scum taking actions that are bad for town because of something you didn’t mean to communicate but they interpreted something oddly.

Which leads us to point two; I’m actively against breadcrumbing. You don’t know who will catch it. Its nice to have something to come back to later in the event you want to try and provide evidence for your claim, but honestly, all it proves is you were thinking ahead. An honest breadcrumb carries the risk that scum sniffs your role, and a dishonest one is scumplay.

Now, on to specifics;

7 hours ago, EbonHawk said:

As we're only 3 posts in wait and see.. Its using my flavour that i received in a big paragraph from pod. Assuming you had the same..

7 hours ago, Ginkapo said:

Why are you sharing flavour with the game?

I agree with Gink here, see what I said above.

6 hours ago, EbonHawk said:

Not this game, my post will have meaning for someone

And again.

6 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Breadcrumbs... why?

Yep.

6 hours ago, EbonHawk said:

If people had used flavour in my game and spotted the Jedi stareing at them in Mad the game would've finished two days earlier....

Honestly, that was bull. You should have just made me mafia, if I couldn’t win that with the game I played. Only mistake was not hammering Moose. But flavor should be just that. Flavor. Not a mechanic.

5 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Ebontrain? Why? He is gonna die tonight anyways.

Yeah, I think we’re all looking at the Ebon/Ovi interaction. For the most part I agree with what Ovi is saying, but things like this are concerning.

1 hour ago, Caldias said:

All this snow is really making it hard to travel. Couldn't we just flamethrow all the snow or something? Well, AFTER we cross the lake, of course.

Also +1 to not claiming anything, esp Day One, unless someone slips #icepun #sorrynotsorry

Don’t you have a patrol to go on?

1 hour ago, EbonHawk said:

Do you have a flamethrower?

Fishing much?

1 hour ago, EbonHawk said:

I admit it's pretty cold would be nice to have some warmth out here. And some bum padding...

Don’t hide behind flavor.

32 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

So we should kill someone. People I find of interest:

@ovinomanc3r for being weird and claiming to have info on Ebon.

@Ginkapo for general surliness and quick lynch nominations (not too out of character, though. ? )

Anyone who’s been really quiet.

Its July 4th. Anyone in America probably has a lot going on today.

6 minutes ago, LTD said:

Well, I don’t know what to post. I’m relatively new to these games, so I don’t know the protocol. Do I post in character in line with my flavour and get criticised? Do I post IC, go with awful memes, never ending silence, or increasingly angry crud? I expect I’ll be lynched / murdered by the end of day 2 – if I make it to day 3 it’ll be a personal best.

We need to vote for various people so that we have something to discuss post lynch / hammer, yes?

Do I just vote for the person who seems the most annoying? Or is that a deliberate ploy to get themselves killed?

We do need to vote. I would recommend looking over some of the previous games. You should vote for the person you think is most likely to be scum.

2 minutes ago, LTD said:

Well, I don’t know what to post. I’m relatively new to these games, so I don’t know the protocol. Do I post in character in line with my flavour and get criticised? Do I post IC, go with awful memes, never ending silence, or increasingly angry crud? I expect I’ll be lynched / murdered by the end of day 2 – if I make it to day 3 it’ll be a personal best.

We need to vote for various people so that we have something to discuss post lynch / hammer, yes?

Do I just vote for the person who seems the most annoying? Or is that a deliberate ploy to get themselves killed?

^ This is mafia.

It boils down to the fact that as town we have to root out the scum. The scum need to say stuff so they don’t look like they are scum-marining.

Day 1 we need a lynch. That’s beneficial to town because we talk and there is a vote trail.

As far as protocol, really the only thing you have to avoid is the ewoks and the rules. Also, as I’ve posted, I would not give up your roles unless there is no other option. The scum can kill us at night and want to pop our power roles.

Just make sure you post and give us a vote. I know the time difference is big, but just give us your reads and votes before the days end.

How many baddies should we expect in a 13 player game? 3?

@Visovics get in here

5 minutes ago, LTD said:

How many baddies should we expect in a 13 player game? 3?

It depends on how many roles are flying around, 3rd parties, etc, but I'd imagine 2-3, maybe 4 depending on role distributions. But I think I'd guess about 3.

Based on that, I'll vote for the 3rd player in the list.

## vote EbonHawk

Then my theory goes the 7th, and then the 11th.

I'm offline now for a number of hours - so I'll just be quietly trudging along in the snow.

13 minutes ago, LTD said:

Based on that, I'll vote for the 3rd player in the list.

## vote EbonHawk

Then my theory goes the 7th, and then the 11th.

I'm offline now for a number of hours - so I'll just be quietly trudging along in the snow.

Roles would presumably have been assigned randomly.

30 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Relatively provacative day one play.

A couple things;

Playing into flavor is fine, but I’d be concerned about getting too cute and providing scum with more than you want. Or even showing something you don’t intend to which leads to scum taking actions that are bad for town because of something you didn’t mean to communicate but they interpreted something oddly.

Which leads us to point two; I’m actively against breadcrumbing. You don’t know who will catch it. Its nice to have something to come back to later in the event you want to try and provide evidence for your claim, but honestly, all it proves is you were thinking ahead. An honest breadcrumb carries the risk that scum sniffs your role, and a dishonest one is scumplay.

Now, on to specifics;

I agree with Gink here, see what I said above.

And again.

Yep.

Honestly, that was bull. You should have just made me mafia, if I couldn’t win that with the game I played. Only mistake was not hammering Moose. But flavor should be just that. Flavor. Not a mechanic.

Yeah, I think we’re all looking at the Ebon/Ovi interaction. For the most part I agree with what Ovi is saying, but things like this are concerning.

Don’t you have a patrol to go on?

Fishing much?

Don’t hide behind flavor.

Its July 4th. Anyone in America probably has a lot going on today.

We do need to vote. I would recommend looking over some of the previous games. You should vote for the person you think is most likely to be scum.

You're not helping yourself mad.. Good work trying to build a case outta nothing. I've not breadcrumded or said my role, simply using some flavour! And also no the only bull was not hanging the jedi. Flavour is not a mechanic but helps the game flow, and in your case right now trying to jump in and make a point bout nothing following ginkss questions... You're looking scum mad so might as well vote day 1 with meaning

#vote @Madaghmire

If we can't use flavour then i see no point in playing these games personally... Whats the point in a setting and backstory if we ignore it

18 minutes ago, LTD said:

Based on that, I'll vote for the 3rd player in the list.

## vote EbonHawk

Then my theory goes the 7th, and then the 11th.

I'm offline now for a number of hours - so I'll just be quietly trudging along in the snow.

why vote me just for being the 3rd person on the list? Loool

2 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

You're not helping yourself mad.. Good work trying to build a case outta nothing. I've not breadcrumded or said my role, simply using some flavour! And also no the only bull was not hanging the jedi. Flavour is not a mechanic but helps the game flow, and in your case right now trying to jump in and make a point bout nothing following ginkss questions... You're looking scum mad so might as well vote day 1 with meaning

#vote @Madaghmire

Ok.

#vote ebonhawk

I wasnt building a case. I’ve always been pretty clear about how I feel regarding breadcrumbing and flavor.

And it was nonsense. First, the game should have ended as soon as the mafia died. Second, a win by yourself win con with no kill ability, is stupid.

4 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

If we can't use flavour then i see no point in playing these games personally... Whats the point in a setting and backstory if we ignore it

The point is to play the game. If you want to act, join an improv class.

Just now, Madaghmire said:

I wasnt building a case. I’ve always been pretty clear about how I feel regarding breadcrumbing and flavor.

And it was nonsense. First, the game should have ended as soon as the mafia died. Second, a win by yourself win con with no kill ability, is stupid.

I didn't breadcrumb though, that's others opinions! On flavour see above, good players can use flavour to spot chinks in scum armour.

You had a kill ability if you managed to mislynch again. When it was 2 left

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

I didn't breadcrumb though, that's others opinions! On flavour see above, good players can use flavour to spot chinks in scum armour.

You had a kill ability if you managed to mislynch again. When it was 2 left

At no point do I even allude to you breadcrumbing, let alone accuse you of it.

And thats not a kill ability, thats the bare minimum you had to give me to make it even theoretically possible.

2 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

The point is to play the game. If you want to act, join an improv class.

HOW IN A GAME IN WHICH YOURE GIVEN A ROLE, A SETTING, AND BACKSTORY, DO YOU NOT USE FLAVOUR???

"I don't like flavour so no one can use it or they're scummy" loooooool

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

At no point do I even allude to you breadcrumbing, let alone accuse you of it.

You quote ovi asking why i 'was' breadcrumbing and agreed

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

HOW IN A GAME IN WHICH YOURE GIVEN A ROLE, A SETTING, AND BACKSTORY, DO YOU NOT USE FLAVOUR???

"I don't like flavour so no one can use it or they're scummy" loooooool

Strawman. Not what I said.