I dont understand why we wouldnt immediately lynch anyone who has killed a town player. My mind is boggled.

@GhostofNobodyInParticular wait till tomorrow to push a lynch on me.

3 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

I dont understand why we wouldnt immediately lynch anyone who has killed a town player. My mind is boggled.

Who do we know has killed a town player. I'll be the first to admit I got lost in you and OVi's back and forth.

4 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Yeah but it makes little practical difference in this discussion. It matters if you have a timed effect, but for the guy on fire posting an S before every word hammer d2 or beginning n2 is probably best expressed as night.

That's is a huuuge assumption. Sorry if I cannot buy that saying stonight is better than stoday.

why casting some shades on Gink when you know he will be dead at the end of the day, tonight or whenever.

Most of what Ovi and I are discussing are what the possibilities are, to figure out the best play. I’m saying I am certain that Preyer killed Gink. I am so sure of this, I’m willing to bet my life on the flop. Wont even need to push a lynch on me, he flops town and I will call the ewoks down on myself. I posted my case.

Ovi and Gnips seem to feel that even if we accept that Preyer killed gink, we shouldnt kill him. Ovis concern is that there will still be two night kills, which I have argued agaisnt as being most likely but cannot disprove. Gnips seems to accept preyer might have had a one shot lighter, used it to kill Ginkapo, and now is in fact not capable of killing others.

I dont think you’d give a player a one shot lighter, and then no other way of killing. I think its more likely he’s an SK with an item that allows him to kill on delay, or the ability to just shoot someone. I think it comes from one source because I think otherwise we’d have seen 2 nightkills n1 in addition to gink burning up. We saw two last night because he chose a different weapon, perhaps to confuse us.

3 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

That's is a huuuge assumption. Sorry if I cannot buy that saying stonight is better than stoday.

why casting some shades on Gink when you know he will be dead at the end of the day, tonight or whenever.

So someone will say this.

6 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

That's is a huuuge assumption. Sorry if I cannot buy that saying stonight is better than stoday.

why casting some shades on Gink when you know he will be dead at the end of the day, tonight or whenever.

Fine. Its a pretty minor point either way.

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

I dont think you’d give a player a one shot lighter, and then no other way of killing. I think its more likely he’s an SK with an item that allows him to kill on delay, or the ability to just shoot someone. I think it comes from one source because I think otherwise we’d have seen 2 nightkills n1 in addition to gink burning up. We saw two last night because he chose a different weapon, perhaps to confuse us.

I am ready to buy this what bothers me of the 1-shot spit. It is just like two comets crashing against each other.

Is*

1 minute ago, ovinomanc3r said:

I am ready to buy this what bothers me of the 1-shot spit. It is just like two comets crashing against each other.

You mean the extinguisher? You mean from a balance perspective or you dont belive I have it? I can waste the use if a consensus needs me to (i think, no on fire target but i dont believe one is necessary.) If it was a fake day action id be mod killed, so i dont need the effect to trigger to prove I have it.

Balance wise, shrug. I’d argue its one shot because im not meant to be able to stop all the fires.

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

You mean the extinguisher? You mean from a balance perspective or you dont belive I have it? I can waste the use if a consensus needs me to (i think, no on fire target but i dont believe one is necessary.) If it was a fake day action id be mod killed, so i dont need the effect to trigger to prove I have it.

Balance wise, shrug. I’d argue its one shot because im not meant to be able to stop all the fires.

It would be a kind way to proof that. I mean if there is no more fireworks is meaningless and if there are more better you use it cause we are re not sure about the victim knowing so someone could be already primed. In the worst case it proofs you saying the true and we can just lynch LP so it won't be necessary anymore.

Anyone think they might be on fire? Dont have to say in case you arent allowed, just tell me the Jets will be good this year and I’ll spray you with celebratory fire retardant foam.

Just joining in.

My theory on the double night kill is that they just happened to be in the one bed - the Doc and the neighborizer. One kill got them both.

I think Gink was doused in alcohol (fire water?) or just told he woke up covered in alcohol - so acted along as a drunk - maybe? Did he realise he would combust? If he did, why didn’t he say “hey, anyone got a thing that prevents fires?”

I think Preyer could easily be scum or serial, but so could be persuaded to vote for him instead.

23 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Anyone think they might be on fire? Dont have to say in case you arent allowed, just tell me the Jets will be good this year and I’ll spray you with celebratory fire retardant foam.

If there is a chance of the arsonist being third party better save whoever you read most town. So, basically you if that's possible.

Four votes have been cast so far.

Brobafett - 1 - GNIPS

Madaghmire - 2 - LTD, Lord Preyer

Lord Preyer - 1 - Madaghmire

Yet to vote are Brobafett, Visovics, and Ovimanc3r.

I find Madaghmire's accusations against Lord Preyer to be pretty solid. I don't think GNIPS case against Brobafett amounts to much.

My vote analysis indicates that GNIP, Madaghmire, and Lord Preyer are my chief suspects - so what am I to make of two of my chief suspects voting for each other? Hmmm.

We have about 22 hours left (and I'll be sleeping for the last six or so of those, so I think I'm going to switch my vote to Lord Preyer. Let's put some pressure on him to claim or defend or explain.

## unvote

## vote Lord Preyer

1)CaribeanNinja-Town Doc- Deceased

2) @Madaghmire (1) LTD , Lord Preyer

3) EbonHawk-Town Cop- Deceased

4) @GhostofNobodyInParticular

5) @ovinomanc3r

6) @Lord Preyer (2) LTD, Madaghmire

7) MandalorianMoose Town neighbourizer-Deceased

8] @BrobaFett (1) Gnip

9) @Visovics

10) Jabbawookie- Mafia Framer- Deceased

11) @LTD

12) Caldias-Town Tracker- Deceased

13) Ginkapo-Town Lynchproof-Deceased

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch

##extinguish madaghmire

for you ovi

4 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

##extinguish madaghmire

for you ovi

Waiting the Ewoks for a while. @PodRacer ?

@Madaghmire Pulls out his fire extinguisher and discharges a cloud of white powder.

Everything alright then.

As he is already at l-1 I will him a chance of a last defense / claim.

@Lord Preyer it's not coming home anymore so give us something please

thanks for pointing out he was L1 - I miscounted and almost hammered. Yes lets please get the last squeeze out of Preyer

My mistake, he is at L-2

4 minutes ago, BrobaFett said:

thanks for pointing out he was L1 - I miscounted and almost hammered. Yes lets please get the last squeeze out of Preyer

He actually is not. Pod said he was but now edited that post with the proper count and he is at l-2

Ninjad

Rapier Blade calling Targ Girl, Rapier Blade calling Targ Girl.