2 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:Sif stown. Sfind sbetter scase
Sif sscum. Sclaim
I've explained myself ad nauseum. Not sure what better case there is to build outside of the truth.
Further explaining why I went for a hammer outside of my previously stated reasons would require a claim.
7 minutes ago, Caldias said:I've explained myself ad nauseum. Not sure what better case there is to build outside of the truth.
Further explaining why I went for a hammer outside of my previously stated reasons would require a claim.
Scase sagainst ssomeone selse
7 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:Scase sagainst ssomeone selse
I did. Against Mad. Best case I have so far. Every time I start to talk about other people I am accused of deflecting.
Am I the only one here suspecting Cal and Mad are different scum factions?
5 minutes ago, Visovics said:Am I the only one here suspecting Cal and Mad are different scum factions?
No you're not
2 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:Under the new hypothesis both could be scum but from different factions.
I need to read all the thread again... sshit!
2 hours ago, Lord Preyer said:Let the record show marines, that I filed my analysis, saw there was plenty of time on the clock, stated my intended vote time and then (because my bodyclock is on Planet Engerland time from my last deploy) checked out at what was 0126hrs intending to vote after I got some shut eye and could see where the talkin’ had got us by then. I was actually a bit surprised to wake to the sound of DH-17s after all. If not voting when there’s more than 30% time on the clock and it’s very late locally is a scum tell than so be it. But in my book it ain’t.
Soldier, give us some feedback on who you think is scum! If you're town that is what we need!
What is your analysis of the current argument between Caldias and Madaghmire!
8 hours ago, Madaghmire said:I actually like Cals case against me. I’ve had a rough game.
The one thing is, I did vote Ebonhawk (albiet inebriated) Cal, so its not that I’m not voting. Then you came in and hammered before I got a chance to read Jabba’s defense that I asked for. I still believe that my choice to let him mount a defense was the right choice, but given how it worked out I can’t fault the line of inquiry. I simply didn’t expect him to answer and be hammered before I woke up. My point is that its somewhat disingenuous to nail me for not voting when you’re the reason I didn’t have the opportunity. If this was a concern, (and you say I’m your best lead and this is a crucial piece of that argument) why not let it go a bit further out and see if I was willing to drop the vote?
Broba, I see your arguments against Vis, but I dont like them. I don’t think Vis would have started a train on a scumbuddy D1, and if I don’t believe that the whole thing tumbles down. And as I’ve already said, I think the right play with that much daylight (re:the unvote) remaining is to see what other information might be extracted.
Despite my feelings on that play, I liked Cal for town at the end of D1, especially post flop after Pod watched his foozeballz. My concern now is as follows; his first post of the day, he shades Visovics, another player I like for town and one whose starting the train buys more cred with me than the hammer. But ok, the reasoning is solid, Vis did “actively try to save” Jabba, now confirmed scum. But again, I think the time left in the day is a mitigating factor. Still, this on its own doesn’t ruffle my feathers.
But then when Broba calls him out for deflecting, he immediately drops me out there. Again, as I’ve said, I like the case. Except that its also pretty deflecty. And now the argument that I dismissed before gains some weight with me. That, plus my already stated belief that the best scum play at that point was to hammer Jabba, has led me to this;
##vote @Caldias
After another reread of the day's actions, I'm gonna lean this way. I'm more swayed by this argument right now.
##vote Caldias.
I think this puts him at L-2
I think we've heard from everyone other than @MandalorianMoose today. Mando, wipe the bachelor party off and get in here and contribute.
Yeh Cal, started the day thinking you could actually be town, but there being the high likelihood of 2 mafia factions kinda swiped that feel
## vote Caldias
that's L-1, at least this time we can wait for the claim before a lynch
(my @ isn't working, could a kind sould tag him for me?)
##sunvote sCal
Suse sthe sday / stime sto sclaim
4 minutes ago, Visovics said:Yeh Cal, started the day thinking you could actually be town, but there being the high likelihood of 2 mafia factions kinda swiped that feel
## vote Caldias
that's L-1, at least this time we can wait for the claim before a lynch
(my @ isn't working, could a kind sould tag him for me?)
All righty, here goes.
Aside from my role, I had a one-shot proximity mine which killed any visitors I had at night. I hammered Jabba because I was about 80% sure he was scum, and I hoped to seem threatening enough, if Jabba ended up being scum like I thought he was, to lure another scum to try and kill me. The gambit didn't work; they went after Gink instead. And apparently my mine is gone, so be careful visiting folks out there.
My role? I'm a tracker. I can track movement at night if I don't set my mine. But I set my mine, so no tracking info from last night.
Now, can someone explain why my attempt at analyzing mads is deflecting, but him immediately counter-accusing is not?
2 minutes ago, Caldias said:All righty, here goes.
Aside from my role, I had a one-shot proximity mine which killed a ny visitors I had at night. I hammered Jabba because I was about 80% sure he was scum , and I hoped to seem threatening enough, if Jabba ended up being scum like I thought he was, to lure another scum to try and kill me. The gambit didn't work; they went after Gink i nstead. An d apparently my mi ne is gone, so be caref ul visiting folks out there.
My role? I' m a tracker. I can track movement at night if I don't set my mine. But I set my mine, so no tracking info fro m last night.
Now, can someone explain why my attempt at analyzing mads is deflecting, but him immediately counter-accusing is not?
so you're a tracker, but for one night you could set up a mine and anyone who visited you that night would die?
12 minutes ago, Visovics said:so you're a tracker, but for one night you could set up a mine and anyone who visited you that night would die?
Correct
Just now, Caldias said:Correct
interesting role
absolute lie though, but well planned, the effort was good
13 minutes ago, Visovics said:so you're a tracker, but for one night you could set up a mine and anyone who visited you that night would die?
It seems. He also didn't track to set the mine that didn't explode and the mine is gone so he can't actually proof anything without dying.
Man, scum deserves to win this one. Just kill me off so I can go to deflect in Observer's doc.
You want to lose tracker and cop, be my guest.
Swhat sis syour scharacter sname?
2 minutes ago, Caldias said:Man, scum deserves to win this one. Just kill me off so I can go to deflect in Observer's doc.
You want to lose tracker and c op, be my guest.
so you didn't track to set a mine, conventional that you end up not having a result to prove it
you lost that mine already, so you can't prove that bit neither
most importantly, I'm not dead, so you are lying, and Lynch All Liars...
4 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:It seems. He also didn't track to set the mine that didn't explode and the mine is gone so he can't actually proof anything without dying.
If anyone has my missing mine, that is one way of corroborating.
2 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:Swhat sis syour scharacter sname?
Le Tissier
1 minute ago, Visovics said:so you didn't track to set a mine, conventional that you end up not having a result to prove it
you lost that mine already, so you can't prove that bit neither
most importantly, I'm not dead, so you are lying, and Lynch All Liars...
Wait, are you saying you visited me? Did you disarm my mine?
Just now, Caldias said:Wait, are you saying you visited me? Did you disarm my min e?
yes I did, and I didn't disarm anything
Just now, Visovics said:yes I did, and I didn't disarm anything
After I die, lynch this dude, please.
