7 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

And scatter, you know?... flotillas!?

10 hours ago, Norsehound said:

Gladiator: A
I think out of the Gladiators presented this may be the most interesting. While I like B, I think the card is a little too limiting since it targets cards that specifically remove dice and evade tokens. All the others pertrain to squadrons, which I'd rather have generic upgrades for using.

Oh yeah, the concept behind Glad A "Twilight" was to address the "make your shots then run away" play, which is completely valid and effective, but what if...you had a little more incentive to keep that ship engaged, for one more round? Do you risk losing it? Do you potentially gain that one more shot to take something big down? Maybe - only the die roll will tell. If it wins, I would probably adjust the points from 7 down to 5 or 6.

All right guys, I've finished tallying up the votes.

Gladiator:
Tied with 5 between Vertigo (D, Norsehound) and Blood Ambition (E, DasSauerkraut)

Victory Star Destroyer:
At 4, Stalwart (C, ovinomanc3r)

Nebulon-B
At 4, Sentinel (B, eliteone)

Assault Frigate MK-II
At 4, Delinquint (E, Norsehound)

Objectives:

Assault:
with 7 votes, DasSauerkraut's Pirate Lair

Navigation:
6 votes, ovinomanc3r's Gravitational Disruption

Defense:
At 5, it's Norsehound's Planetary Assault.

Special:
At 4 votes, ovinomanc3r's Regrouping Attempt.

Thank you for everyone who voted! Next I'll see if I can work up some proxy cards for printing. I'll also post the rules for the next phase of this project, which is testing!

On 7/2/2018 at 3:41 AM, Norsehound said:

Sorry this is a bit late, but here we go with the voting thread!

First a few rules:

1. Voting will continue into next Sunday, 7/8. Polls will close at 10pm PST. Anyone is welcome to vote. You are welcome to change your vote by editing your post, the vote will be tallied at the time the polls close.

2. If you do vote, please vote for a submission other than your own!

3. Slides are arranged by type horizontally and by class vertically. So when you vote, to make things succinct, use the following format as the first part of your submission post:

Gladiator: D
Victory Star Destroyer: B
Nebulon-B: A
Assault Frigate: C

Assault Objective: A
Navigation Objective: D
Defensive Objective: A

*Special Objective: F

*4. I know I said design for each objective, but I didn't necessarily intend for the non-standard objectives in my inquiry. Still, I gathered all the special objectives anyway and I think I'll do the following: Pick ONE of the special objectives to adopt. These special objectives are yoked to the CC, and I don't necessarily think we'd want to do a map to Jakku, but it could be interesting to put one of them on rotation.

5. After a week of voting, the next step of this community project is to put these titles and Objectives on the table and test them. When you vote, consider which titles you want to be facing up against as well as flying in your lists, I will be taking feedback from both for and against. From then we will iterate and tweak on the titles to produce something more balanced.

6. If you wish, you can offer feedback for your decision following your voting block.

------------------

With that in mind, let's begin!

If you find the images too small to read, right click the image to "view Image" so you can see the full size.

Looks like the VSD Umbrage nailed it, but switched names with Harrow lol.

1 hour ago, eliteone said:

Looks like the VSD Umbrage nailed it, but switched names with Harrow lol.

Don’t forget the Conviction neb title.

8 hours ago, eliteone said:

Looks like the VSD Umbrage nailed it, but switched names with Harrow lol.

I like my Umbrage better because it gets the nice juicy attack bonuses to make it mean. If you want the extra clicks, lean on Jerjerrod. My Umbrage really makes VSD-Is awesome.

Shadow Raptor's redeploy thing reappeared on the Corvus.

9 hours ago, eliteone said:

Looks like the VSD Umbrage nailed it, but switched names with Harrow lol.

You ain't the first one to suggest a title that gives the VSD a support slot lol.

7 hours ago, TallGiraffe said:

You ain't the first one to suggest a title that gives the VSD a support slot lol.

I wasn't the one to suggest it at all. Many players participated in the home brew by submitting suggestions for title upgrades and objectives.