16 minutes ago, Radix2309 said:

I think the problem with Seeker is that they have been getting subpar cards for a while, and nothing really to open other avenues of deckbuilding.

Seekers are the main class to find clues, and the other classes haven't completely caught up yet. So you need a seeker who can find clues, Milan fills this role perfectly in so many ways. 

The relic theme is a nice build around but needs some more pieces for now to actually be viable.

I think the support build with stuff like Guidance could also use some more cards. 

I have often described playing Seekers as: Spending actions to gain clues or spending actions to move to get clues or playing cards to make yourself better at getting clues and moving. I do agree with Seekers getting a number of lack luster cards.

On Rex, I saw a poll that stated that over 75% of people play mostly 1 or 2 player. Since Daisy and Minh have a large support component and support gets more powerful with number of players, its not surprising that Rex is viewed as a better choice overall. Ursula may start biting into that space with Rex but you are right, she needs a larger relic pool. Daisy could use some tomes as well that are more "single player".

3 hours ago, SGPrometheus said:

Speaking of things that let you do your job more effectively, what about machete? There are some who would argue that it is the best all-around weapon in the game. Personally I always include 2 in my Guardian decks and they're the last thing I cut when I'm putting in upgraded weapons. Still, I think their targeting requirements keep them from being OP, but I'd like to hear why people think they crowd out all other level 0 weapons.

I did have a Mark Harrigan deck that ran 2 Colts and 1 Machete. But had i been creating that deck now, I would have taken Survival Knife over Machete, as for that deck Survival Knife was better .

1 hour ago, Jobu said:

I have often described playing Seekers as: Spending actions to gain clues or spending actions to move to get clues or playing cards to make yourself better at getting clues and moving. I do agree with Seekers getting a number of lack luster cards.

On Rex, I saw a poll that stated that over 75% of people play mostly 1 or 2 player. Since Daisy and Minh have a large support component and support gets more powerful with number of players, its not surprising that Rex is viewed as a better choice overall. Ursula may start biting into that space with Rex but you are right, she needs a larger relic pool. Daisy could use some tomes as well that are more "single player".

Rex actually is less effective on single player. Almost half the locations only have 1 clue. Ursula is more effective for solo since she can grab the single clue and keep moving. Plus she has a better stat line for it.

Rex actually gets even more effective the more players you have. Just means more clues for you to cheat.

Finn is a good start, as is Pete. But we need more investigators with 4 intellect. Ones who aren't seekers. Either Survivor or Rouge seems likely as Guardian and Mystic have other roles. But an investigation focused Rogue or Survivor would be great.

pre- Forgotten Age, Daisy was better solo than Rex, but I will agree Ursula could claim this title in the Seeker class because of her action compression.

I actually haven't played a lot of single player so I will defer to you folks on it.

1 hour ago, Radix2309 said:

Finn is a good start, as is Pete. But we need more investigators with 4 intellect. Ones who aren't seekers. Either Survivor or Rouge seems likely as Guardian and Mystic have other roles. But an investigation focused Rogue or Survivor would be great.

1

Rogues certainly have the toolkit for it. I'm super excited to try out my revised custom investigator that fits this role to a T. This is a bit of a shameless plug, but it is also absolutely on topic, and I agree.

https://community.fantasyflightgames.com/topic/236896-soakmans-gallery-of-custom-thematic-characters/?page=2