Looking for Feedback

By RPLev, in X-Wing

Hello all. I was not sure where to post this. I have been getting my ideas tested, and have been getting official support. I don't want to say too much as I am not sure what I am allowed to say (also concerned I may explain it wrong)

Anyways.. out of all the ideas I have been getting help with testing, there is one that I can't seem to get people to agree on, or find a solution. Some people want to modify it, others want to trash it. I decided to take it to the forums, see if perhaps someone else can help get things in the right direction
----------------------------------------
Stealth X X-Wing, Actions: Focus, Target Lock, Boost, Stats: 3 Damage, 2 Agility, 3 Hull, 2 Shields. Dial same as T-65 X-Wing except the 2 maneuvers and all straights are green

Luke Skywalker Stealth X X-Wing, Pilot Skill 10 (6, v2), 34 cost, Elite, Torpedo, Modifcation

After you become the defender (before dice are rolled), you may recover 1 Force

Jaina Solo Fel Stealth X X-Wing, Pilot Skill 9 (5, v2), 33 cost, Elite, Torpedo, Modifcation

When attacking with Jedi Shadow Bombs or Proton Torpedoes, the defender rolls 1 less dice. You may spend 1 Force to roll 1 more attack dice. Gain 1 Force on Attack (before dice is rolled)

Mara Jade Skywalker Stealth X X-Wing, Pilot Skill 9 (5, v2) 33 cost, Elite, Torpedo, Modifcation

When attacking, you may spend 1 Force to change all hit and eye results to critical. Gain 1 Force on Attack (before dice are rolled)

Stealth X X-Wing Rule/Reference Card: You may not be targeted by Missile or Torpedo. When Defending, the attacker rolls 2 less attack dice (to a minimum of 1). May not increase hull or shields. May not receive, or give bonuses from/to other ships. If you fire a Torpedo, Missile, or give/receive a bonus, flip this card face down until the End Phase (lose your protection)

Give/Receive Bonus is reffering to things like Jans Ors Pilot Ability, Garven Dreis and so on
---------------------------------------------------------------------
The idea was later modified to drop the first sentence, and keep it at the "attacker rolls 2 less dice (to a minimum of 1)". After that, the attacker rolls less dice was dropped, and the torpedo or missile sentence was kept. Apparently that was not enough. Some people were saying it's rule/reference card is too complicated. After awhile people wanted to give it the Cloak token/rule that Whisper has. No one could agree on that

When V 2.0 was announced, I did change the pilot abilities to keep up. I was thinking this would be a perfect opportunity to provide the first Force expansion after the 2.0 release. So far that hasn't been an issue. It seems the conflict is because of that Stealth X rule/reference card

My goal with this idea was to provide the Rebels an expensive, small ship that is a "jack of all trades". I decided a "jack of all trades" ship that is also solo fighting capable would be best (similar idea to Dengar vs the World list). Corran is not the best in the current meta so I was thinking this could fill the void until fixes are made (so Corran can return)

Any help to resolve this impass is appreciated. Thank you!

I see what you did thar

Lets stay on topic though please :)