Hi all
look at picture - end of map is top menue.
Where I should place Ezra if it collides with Falcon?

1 starting position

2 after moving and crashing to Falcon

If any part of your ship’s base is out of the play area, then the ship is destroyed.

See “Fleeing the Battlefield” on page 11 of the Rules Reference.

1 minute ago, jmswood said:

If any part of your ship’s base is out of the play area, then the ship is destroyed.

See “Fleeing the Battlefield” on page 11 of the Rules Reference.

but at 1st he cannot be placed on top of the Falcon. Should I place it near falcon and crossing map edge or move it to place where he can be placed fully on map?

4 minutes ago, Spellscape said:

but at 1st he cannot be placed on top of the Falcon. Should I place it near falcon and crossing map edge or move it to place where he can be placed fully on map?

Other than not wanting your ship to be destroyed, why would you not place him where the rules tell you to: bumping the Falcon and off the map, therefore destroyed?

Also, Vassal has had Auto-Collision Technology™ for a while now.

1 hour ago, Spellscape said:

but at 1st he cannot be placed on top of the Falcon. Should I place it near falcon and crossing map edge or move it to place where he can be placed fully on map?

Follow the directions for “Overlapping Ships” on page 15 of the Rules Reference. If you follow the instructions and any part of the ship’s base lands out of the play area, then boom. Ship destroyed.

Not following the steps with intent to keep the ship on the board is cheating; plain and simple.

It's not cheating. Ezra has 1 Hull left 2 stress and just killed Poe. It's death of hero ?

4 hours ago, Spellscape said:

It's not cheating. Ezra has 1 Hull left 2 stress and just killed Poe . It's death of hero ?

It's immaterial what Ezra's current condition is. If you cannot place the ship at the end of the template because of an overlap, then you move it back to the point where it's touching the other ship and still centered on the maneuver template. If that happens to leave any part of the ship's base outside the play area, that ship has fled the battlefield and is destroyed .

There's no room for any sort of compromise on this. You're either in or you're out, and if you're out, you're destroyed. There's no "take-backs" either. If you planned a maneuver that didn't work the way you hoped it would, then you must live with the consequences.

I think it's more problem for you than for me - I never had such situation before and wanted to know how to correctly place ship. That's all - It has nothing to do with hopes and dreams.

Believe me - some play this as game of trial and error just because we like game and like to know how to play in every known situation simply because want to do it right. And we don't need preaching about cheating - It was simple question about situation not - how to cheat essay. It's your problem that you thought 1st about cheating - not mine.

BTW - there is also thing called humor. Try it sometimes

8 minutes ago, Spellscape said:

I think it's more problem for you than for me - I never had such situation before and wanted to know how to correctly place ship. That's all - It has nothing to do with hopes and dreams.

Believe me - some play this as game of trial and error just because we like game and like to know how to play in every known situation simply because want to do it right. And we don't need preaching about cheating - It was simple question about situation not - how to cheat essay. It's your problem that you thought 1st about cheating - not mine.

BTW - there is also thing called humor. Try it sometimes

I'm hoping this reply was not directed at me personally, because I merely pointed out the rules that apply to the situation you presented.

1 minute ago, Parravon said:

I'm hoping this reply was not directed at me personally, because I merely pointed out the rules that apply to the situation you presented.

as always anyone can decide anything by themselves - this called freedom of speech and thought

10 minutes ago, Spellscape said:

as always anyone can decide anything by themselves - this called freedom of speech and thought

Clearly not the case judging by your first post. You are the one reading more into people's answers than what's there. Helpful hint: If you want to be sarcastic or amusing, an emoji helps, because the language you're using at the moment can be taken as condescending at the least.

Myself and others offered the correct answer to your situation without bias, and you feel the need to say we have the problem?

6 hours ago, Spellscape said:

Where I should place Ezra if it collides with Falcon?

Please amuse me an tell how this could have some hidden meaning?

2 minutes ago, Parravon said:

Clearly not the case judging by your first post.

15 minutes ago, Spellscape said:

as always anyone can decide anything by themselves...

If, as you say, " anyone can decide anything by themselves ", and given the fact the rules are pretty clear, you shouldn't have had the need to even ask the question to begin with. But you did ask, and when answered, you chose to go on the offensive and start this tirade.

29 minutes ago, Spellscape said:

I think it's more problem for you than for me - I never had such situation before and wanted to know how to correctly place ship. That's all - It has nothing to do with hopes and dreams.

Seriously, I can't see how the answers that you received deserved this response. No one has even brought up anything about "hopes and dreams", so I don't know where you were going with that comment. The answers you got were clear, concise, unbiased, factual and even quoted pages in the rulebook for you to look up yourself.

Anyway, I'm not going to indulge this senseless exchange any further. Good luck to you.

oh so many letters ....

21 hours ago, ObiWonka said:

Other than not wanting your ship to be destroyed

14 hours ago, Parravon said:

No one has even brought up anything about "hopes and dreams", so I don't know where you were going with that comment.

I believe Spellscape may have been referring to my reply there. However, my response wasn't meant to start a snark or sarcasm war. I was simply asking that since s/he was given the correct rules reference to determine that Ezra would be destroyed, could s/he provide a reasoning for thinking the situation would be resolved in some other way, other than s/he didn't want Ezra destroyed. An answer s/he doesn't seem to be able to provide.

2 minutes ago, ObiWonka said:

I believe Spellscape may have been referring to my reply there. However, my response wasn't meant to start a snark or sarcasm war. I was simply asking that since s/he was given the correct rules reference to determine that Ezra would be destroyed, could s/he provide a reasoning for thinking the situation would be resolved in some other way, other than s/he didn't want Ezra destroyed. An answer s/he doesn't seem to be able to provide.

Dudes - I didn't think HALF you are referring - it's game with toy ships not life threatening question....

My question was plane simple - Where I should place Ezra if it collides with Falcon?

Anything else - that I didn't want to be it destroyed, that I wanted to cheat only in your heads. I didn't or asked any of that - you can search for it in this topic if you have nothing else to do...

You were told how to do it, twice, with direct references to the rules. Yet you keep insisting there should be another way to do it. If you aren't trying to keep Ezra from being destroyed, why are you trying to put him somewhere other than where the rules tell you (and what are you basing that on)?

You must be kidding - I'm asking where to put him and why - what is cheating is that?

13 minutes ago, ObiWonka said:

You were told how to do it, twice, with direct references to the rules. Yet you keep insisting there should be another way to do it. If you aren't trying to keep Ezra from being destroyed, why are you trying to put him somewhere other than where the rules tell you (and what are you basing that on)?

And yes I thought at 1st that ship if overlapping must be placed in position it can fit and not crossing map. I was wrong and have no problem with it. BTW in game I removed Ezra without problem to research this problem (here) further

Play nice, folks.

16 hours ago, Spellscape said:

My question was plane simple - Where I should place Ezra if it collides with Falcon?

So a simple answer:

Place it out of the table, it is out of play. I place my out of play ships on top of her card, other put it on a case. At your own.

Stop feeding the troll guys