27 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:A set up where partial information is known to all from the start.
All you really need to know is that me and Mad are unlikely to slip up if scum at any point. Truth is getting to be a pretty good town leader.
Varying degrees of ability in everyone else.
@TheToad that took you far to long to write.
If people just did what I ask for...
49 minutes ago, Rajam said:##vote CaribbeanNinja
The best, balanced, well elaborated analysis thus far.
I agree 100%
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:I didn't ignore it, I just didn't see it as anything serious...
think youre scumdar may need some tuning... as I'm not the only one to miss it
and with 14 players I'd probably say 3
I'm new here; a completely unknown player. From a town mindset, you would've either tried to pressure me or find out about my reasonings for my vote instead of dismissing it out so quickly as non-serious. You already know I'm town son
12 minutes ago, Visovics said:I’d push for a lynch if the contrary happened
As you should since spoiling the film would absolutely be a scum move.
##vote EbonHawk
btw mod I'm not unvoting my previous vote on Caribbean. I'm voting both slots
1 minute ago, Rajam said:##vote EbonHawk
btw mod I'm not unvoting my previous vote on Caribbean. I'm voting both slots
Don't know what you mean by other slot?
and you've voted me and ninja now no reasoning...
also friendly tip I wouldn't use the I'm new here defence it's been done
2 minutes ago, Rajam said:##vote EbonHawk
btw mod I'm not unvoting my previous vote on Caribbean. I'm voting both slots
I think you cannot. But maybe I miss the rules. Actually I don't care about rules. I am a smuggler.
5 minutes ago, Rajam said:I'm new here; a completely unknown player. From a town mindset, you would've either tried to pressure me or find out about my reasonings for my vote instead of dismissing it out so quickly as non-serious. You already know I'm town son
And wrong, I wanted to see how the others would react first, I think your shady ATM don't know about the rest, hence wanting to see their replies
Just now, ovinomanc3r said:I think you cannot. But maybe I miss the rules. Actually I don't care about rules. I am a smuggler.
A joke ovi? Or a claim as a pilot?
Just now, EbonHawk said:A joke ovi? Or a claim as a pilot?
Neither. I mean. We all are smugglers right? Is not the theme?
Also are you role fishing again?
You almost died last time. Hopefully I was town then...like now.
Just now, ovinomanc3r said:Neither. I mean. We all are smugglers right? Is not the theme?
No, we're all currently smuggling but that doesn't make us actual smugglers
2 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:No, we're all currently smuggling but that doesn't make us actual smugglers
Mama always say stupid is as stupid does.
Just now, ovinomanc3r said:Mama always say stupid is as stupid does.
Roles with smuggler backgrounds:
pilot, scout, possibly zealot.
roles that don't have a smuggling background:
investigator, Jedi padawan, hacker, the scum
also for everyone else, I'm not rolefishing I don't care about roles yet
I'm just interested in getting a read on the flavour of the game, and some D1 cross analysing
1 hour ago, Ginkapo said:Ebon. Consider timestamps.
One of me and Toad posted quickly without pause for thought.
One of us uncounciously sided with town and one of us did not.
The evidence is all there. If I didnt have a track record of being silvertongued this would be sufficient to clear me.
Help me lynch either Caribbean/EbonHawk toDay, and I'll help you lynch Toad toMorrow. Deal?
Who would you pick between Caribbean/Ebon tho?
16 minutes ago, Rajam said:##vote EbonHawk
btw mod I'm not unvoting my previous vote on Caribbean. I'm voting both slots
Sorry, this should have been in the setup post...
Every player gets one vote. If you want to vote on a new person, you must first unvote. If the turn ends with a player having a vote on more than one person, only the first vote will get counted.
I'll quote our standard rules here.
On 12/1/2017 at 4:10 PM, TheToad said:Stealing from Biggs now:
THE RULES, BRIEFLY:
No editing your posts.
No talking Out Of Thread unless you are able to do so.
Don't quote (or pretend to quote) Moderator PMs.
Don't spectator-post or like.
Don't post after hammers or day-kills.
No voting for yourself.
Don't post after dying.
Don't fake day actions.
DON'T EDIT YOUR POSTS.
DON'T TALK OUTSIDE OF THE THREAD!
20 minutes ago, Rajam said:Help me lynch either Caribbean/EbonHawk toDay, and I'll help you lynch Toad toMorrow. Deal?
Who would you pick between Caribbean/Ebon tho?
Care to explain any of your reasons on me or ninja?
You're just throwing around votes.. and adding nothing to the game right now?
Also what's your beef with the toad besides the obvious first post
33 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:Also what's your beef with the toad besides the obvious first post
Everybody got beef with Mr. Toad... it ain’t easy being green
Okay, this is actually really good. We have bunch of conversation happening day one, which has seemed to be lacking a bit the last couple games. The interesting most interesting points to me so far are the Toad/Gink situation, and the Rajam situation. For toad vs gink, I'm not sure what to think just yet. The argument is still rather flimsy at this point, and gink seems to be reaching a bit for his argument.
As for the new guy...he definitely doesn't feel like a new player to me, I'm just not getting that vibe. I don't understand the vote on Ninja, especially with no explanation. Then the jump to Ebon after for not questioning his questionable vote. That makes slightly more sense to me. Then he goes and offers gink that they can vote block to lynch their suspicions. That last post is rather suspicious to me as you are basically trying to setup two lynches in a row. If you are scum, that's two dead town players plus the scum night kills....
And at this point since joke voting is done for: ##unvote
I'm back. The only comment I'll make about the film is that I'm so glad it was dedicated to Carrie Fisher. She truly was a princess.
I think @JJs Juggernaut observation succinctly captures the essence of the conversation here thus far. I agree that Rajam's Gink post reads a bit suspicious. I don't like the "let's make a deal" aspect of it as it doesn't seem like something a townie would do.
I'll comment further before I head to work tomorrow morning. Night all.
10 hours ago, Visovics said:What about Sands of the New Republic? I know many got frustrated, but cmon at least remember it...
Ah, yes. It took me a while to remember my role. I was referring to ## actions, not the passive stuff like a masonry.
14 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:Ah, yes. It took me a while to remember my role. I was referring to ## actions, not the passive stuff like a masonry.
Well they all still had, fishermen, arsonist, vigilantes, motivator, encryptors and cult recruiters if I recall my setup correctly, all actions, those were exhausting nights to manage
1 minute ago, Visovics said:Well they all still had, fishermen, arsonist, vigilantes, motivator, encryptors and cult recruiters if I recall my setup correctly, all actions, those were exhausting nights to manage
Yeah the tri-cult one qualifies.
I feel like Rajam is new here but not new to the game itself. I can see why he voted both. Although his vote on Cninj is quite unsubstantiated...