3 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:The whole problem is that from my perspective it is an equally bad town play or scum play. However, I do think I'll place my vote on him.
##vote EbonHawk
Hey @PodRacerwhere are you at?
It’s a terrible town play, and a terrible scum play if that scum were undetected. But it’s a good play by a scum player who fears not making it back into the scumchat to share his info.
@Rajam Seeing as you got screwed over already. What was your night action?
It sucks but you probably die tonight.
7 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:@Rajam Seeing as you got screwed over already. What was your night action?
It sucks but you probably die tonight.
I slept last night
8 minutes ago, TheToad said:It’s a terrible town play, and a terrible scum play if that scum were undetected. But it’s a good play by a scum player who fears not making it back into the scumchat to share his info.
This is a pretty good point. If we assume he’s scum, then for a guy who very nearly died yesterday, this play makes a lot of sense. If we believe him, then great for him. We don’t kill him, which is a huge bonus for him while he keeps ID’ing our power roles for at least another night cycle.
If we don’t believe him, and he flips scum, then he hasn’t really lost much, because he was already high on the scumdar list. So a good gambit.
I think we can probably assume hes being truthful about the scanner role, because otherwise Raj would have either counterclaimed it or is also scum. But I think thats exceptionally unlikely, because why point a finger at another scum player?
After Ebons D1 interaction with Ovi it was clear he was saying I'm either Scum or a power role innit, added to the fishing I had a scum lean...
The fact he's alive makes me think scum...
but essentially Mans in the same place as yesterday fam.
If he is scum, I think he has a partner in one of the three who screwed the vote yesterday.
If he's town then likely Vis is scum and aligned to one of (or more) the three.
Mans torn as how best to prove his allegianceses and ting.
2 minutes ago, PodRacer said:After Ebons D1 interaction with Ovi it was clear he was saying I'm either Scum or a power role innit, added to the fishing I had a scum lean...
After day one’s discourse concluded, it was apparent to me that Ebonhawk was casting aspersions unto my own person. When one also accounts for his weak attempt at rolefishing, one must strongly consider the possibility that Ebon could be scum.
2 minutes ago, PodRacer said:The fact he's alive makes me think scum...
but essentially Mans in the same place as yesterday fam.
That he survived the night lends credence to the theory that his loyalties are somewhat dubious. No new information has come to light to change his standing from yesterday, my friends.
2 minutes ago, PodRacer said:If he is scum, I think he has a partner in one of the three who screwed the vote yesterday.
If he is scum, I believe we can narrow the search to one of the three people who had sexual intercourse with the ballot box yesterday.
2 minutes ago, PodRacer said:If he's town then likely Vis is scum and aligned to one of (or more) the three.
If Ebon is town, then it seems likely to me that Vis is then scum aligned, and is in a polyamorous relationship one or more of the ballot box fornicators.
2 minutes ago, PodRacer said:Mans torn as how best to prove his allegianceses and ting.
I’m not sure how to prove where his loyalties lie.
(Translated for funsies)
Joking aside, there is some flawed logic there pod.
1. Why would scum kill Ebon if he’s town? His being alive today doesn’t really make him look less guilty.
2. The deflowering of the democratic process can only really be construed as helping Ebon. I don’t think it paints Vis in a bad light at all.
Sorry, construed as helping ebon if there was a malicious intent to it. The other option is that it was an earnest scew job.
Manz Given a random Role n ting. Big Shaq. SKKKRTT. check the statistacs.
4 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:Joking aside, there is some flawed logic there pod.
1. Why would scum kill Ebon if he’s town? His being alive today doesn’t really make him look less guilty.
2. The deflowering of the democratic process can only really be construed as helping Ebon. I don’t think it paints Vis in a bad light at all.
1. Because he breadcrumbed PR pretty **** 'ard n ting
2. I didnt really scumread Vis D1 at all, Just trying to solve this riddle fam.
4 hours ago, Rajam said:Can you further detail these vibes? Are they still up?
Neither of them voted d1, both have been super under radar.
Yes business is a thing, I had a hellishly busy weekend too so I get it. But it feels different. GNIPS is maybe not as strong Wigtii, but I think there is definitely a need to push Wigtii a bit more about what went on.
Also, Cninj, there was no active timer on the page, and you left us hanging on a no lynch before time was called intentionally over at most 15 seconds disparity? I appreciate your strictness in upholding the letter of the law, but IMO this seems fishy.
Maybe we were 2/2 on scum with Cninj as their mate? Or maybe Cninj is just a paragon of mafia rules virtue. Either way, really left gink and I out to dry on what should have been a pretty easy lynch vote.
Checking in. Catching up on posts. I'll comment further if I have time, otherwise it will have to wait until I'm done at work.
12 minutes ago, BrobaFett said:Also, Cninj, there was no active timer on the page, and you left us hanging on a no lynch before time was called intentionally over at most 15 seconds disparity? I appreciate your strictness in upholding the letter of the law, but IMO this seems fishy.
I mean the timer ended like at 2 PM (My time) and y'all were posting past it. And yes, about rules, I am pretty virtuous.
And I know for a fact that Gink was posting at like the same time as me. We posted at least twice at like the same time. If anyone is fishy after the vote **** it is you @BrobaFett. I'm really surprised that you even bring it up.
I was trying to wait until you and gink figured your crap out to prevent a no lynch before deciding after gink voted and you went dark that you must be waiting to make sure it was certain. I know you were posting at the same time, I was posting too, and sitting in line at the drive through refreshing every 2 seconds trying to figure out what the right call was. Eventually I made mine and landed on it. I am not saying that it's now gospel that you are scum, or gink or I are. Obviously the reason I was trying to vote with you conveys the fact that I thought we were all well meaning- but I stand by the opinion that you left us hanging there.
Man, a lot has happened. Again, my apologies for my absence.
I don't like Ebon's action, but I also know that it could be viewed either way. I still would like to know how he knew he was redirected. I also don't like CNinja's willingness to lynch him. It seems like a scum jumping on the opportunity to lynch a declared cop.
25 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:CNinja's willingness to lynch him
Notice how I'm the only one with guts to put in a vote, but a lot of folks agree with me.
Back from work, give me 10 mins to catch up as already rolled
What still puzzles me a about Ebon is the conviction that he has 3 scum nailed down...
@EbonHawk why are you conviced of your scum reads?
1 minute ago, Visovics said:What still puzzles me a about Ebon is the conviction that he has 3 scum nailed down...
@EbonHawk why are you conviced of your scum reads?
Five mins vis and I'll answer you
18 hours ago, Madaghmire said:Finally, re: Ebons post, I’m not sure we should believe him, but if hes town then dude, you need to not out people who arent being pressured.
And to everyone else, may I repeat we're in a game of 14 I know their will be other investigate/Palawan roles out there, which would allow us to confirm 4 town if there's 2 or 6 if there's 3, now 6 town out of 14 players yes please try and convince me how that is bad...
it would be moronic to say that confirming half the players early would in any way be counter intuitive
##vote Ebon.
I have realised that its not him dying tonight, so I am not going to refrain from voting as I was doing.
How do you know there are other investigative roles out there?
Lol again. The role fish thing is weak sauce guys you all know that, I didn't ask what his role was jsut if that was a hint... ovi dropped that not me for a start...
next as said we can get a solid block going, and by tomorrow even if I get targeted for revealing, we can further that block and then apply pressure
to make things interesting and because I want to see how people reply, I'm not a padawan...
and vis to you question mate..
10 minutes ago, Visovics said:What still puzzles me a about Ebon is the conviction that he has 3 scum nailed down...
@EbonHawk why are you conviced of your scum reads?
Pod - always plays more wacky as scum then town(discounting last game) his posts as well read scum, knowing him irl helps to see what tone he's actually writing with
gink - scum marine central watched him in loads of these games before playing could tell from D1 he was scum as they come
JJ - playing the exact same style of game he did in my first game, where funnily enough pod was also scum and they both killed me N1... even his jump on me is the exact same, and like gink he has tells in his style of writing
5 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:##vote Ebon.
I have realised that its not him dying tonight, so I am not going to refrain from voting as I was doing.
How do you know there are other investigative roles out there?
Your also correct because regardless that I'm an investigative role, you and your scum friends would keep me alive to throw the pressure and shade my way, which is jsut what you've set up to do in that post, if I don't get lynched.. also 2nd vote slot isn't that
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:Your also correct because regardless that I'm an investigative role, you and your scum friends would keep me alive to throw the pressure and shade my way, which is jsut what you've set up to do in that post, if I don't get lynched.. also 2nd vote slot isn't that
No. If I was scum I would kill Ragan at night as he is actually a threat. You threw him under the bus to save your skin.
Have you ever heard of christmas parties? Sorry I was drinking, aka "scumarining"
Just now, Ginkapo said:No. If I was scum I would kill Ragan at night as he is actually a threat. You threw him under the bus to save your skin.
Have you ever heard of christmas parties? Sorry I was drinking, aka "scumarining"
I mean I never said you'd kill me, and no you wouldn't. You're far far too expeinaced in mafia to kill Rajam you would never be so obvious in that, jsut like killing me.
and scumarining doesn't mean not posting my friend, it means posting to play undercover scum... which you've been doing sublimely all game.