So who was cal Tracking when he died?

Did neither of you think to soft suggest a protect earlier?

Theres to much to the story you tell that doesn' t sit well with me, All of the information you have produced was already known in game. You could have revealed yesterday and had Cal track the killer at night. Bosh. Outside of ninjascum you would have detected all visitors no? I just cant help but think you havn't played that optimally either.

All i sense is you are trying to softly pocket Ovi and Broba and cast doubt into the townblock.

Im happy to leave my vote as is for now... If you flip town it confirms broba and Ovi. Im convinced Ebon is town. And me.

If you are town Im pretty sure that scum can only be in Mad and Vis. If you flip scum its 50/50 broba or Ovi.

Cal was watching Ebon when he died. It was speculative, but we were testing out a theory about the difference between deserters and refugees.

If you need more evidence, @PodRacer , I can tell you how many refugees and how many deserters there are in the game.

I can also tell you whether Broba and ovi are refugees or deserters

im listening...

At the start of the game, there were 2 intelligence officers, 5 refugees, and 3 deserters

Now, there is 1 intelligence officer, 4 refugees, and 2 deserters.

Unfortunately, I'm not aware if refugees can have another role.

Which is why I'm skeptical of your claim. The village started out with 2 power roles, connected in a masonry. Forgive me for not believing that there's a town aligned doc out there too

This should make for an interesting next 24 hours.

Im semi convinced by your claim. I will let the others review their positions, but this doesnt change much for me in terms of reads or outcomes. Only possibly scum in Broba or Ovi that you are trying to slip past us. Lets hope its not that sinister and we have found our scum in Mad and Vis.

So when you voted me earlier did you have an ulterior motive?

So there seems to be a plan. So we need Pod alive for it...

##unvote Pod

well Ebon has read most suspicious of the 2 that are lined up alongside me so

##vote EbonHawk

1 hour ago, Onidsen said:

Forgive me for not believing that there's a town aligned doc out there too

This is particularly interesting. Because Pod claimed to be the medical officer of the ship, not a refugee...

On 5/12/2017 at 3:59 AM, TheToad said:

Gaius Feaon, Code-Name GhostofNobodyinParticular, has died. He was a town-aligned Defector .

Lol and me wondering if that was flavour or an actual role.

@TheToad do you wanna fix it?

4 hours ago, Onidsen said:

I can also tell you whether Broba and ovi are refugees or deserters

Please tell me what are us?

2 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Lol and me wondering if that was flavour or an actual role.

@TheToad do you wanna fix it?

Seems like all flips have been with flavour, no roles really. We had a refugee, a defector, and an Intelligence Officer flip. Nothing more we had on them, so I’m assuming that this difference also has some kind of importance

1 minute ago, Visovics said:

Seems like all flips have been with flavour, no roles really. We had a refugee, a defector, and an Intelligence Officer flip. Nothing more we had on them, so I’m assuming that this difference also has some kind of importance

No defector. Note that Oni said 1 of each (intel desertor and refugee) died. However any desertor officially did.

4 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

No defector. Note that Oni said 1 of each (intel desertor and refugee) died. However any desertor officially did.

Nice catch, I hadn’t realized that

9 hours ago, Onidsen said:

That's L-2 on me, then, so I'll claim. I was hoping to get one more night out of it, but whatever.

I'm the second alliance intelligence officer. I was in a Masonry with Caldias. He could either watch or track each night. Night 1, Pod didn't leave (unless he's a ninja).

I can either be a cop or a Masonry recruiter each night. I scanned Broba N1 and ovinomanc3r N2. Unless one of them is a godfather (but that's a meta discussion), they are both innocent.

Pod, you get to prove yourself tonight. Protect me, por favor.

We should lynch one of Mad, Vis, or Ebon. I prefer Vis, but whatever you want. I'll scan one of the others. If I live, we'll almost certainly have a suspect. If I die, we have a suspect.

Just catching up as my mac charger has died so on the phone, this I can buy...

i know toad enjoyed my games and the flavour and I can see him roleing with a masonry...

my reads are you, mad, vis..

if I take you at your word, and I know that I'm not scum, you have my role as I've posted earlier

so that means the majority of us are all seeing vis and mad...

gunna read the rest and come ba

I'm convinced by what o is put forward it seems plausible and I'm buying the setup with the masons...

instresring about the roles though 5 refugees and 2 deserters...

as said it a defector, I continued my service after the droid war and was XO on the VSD judicatior, I here to defect to the rebels and my only mission is to get my intelligence on the empire to them...

the problem that gives me is 1 scum minimum must be a refugee? Trying to figure the flavour on that one...

im hesitant at this point to still have a vote on oni so ##unvote

@Onidsen you say you can recruit so do so tonight and doc protect him, if he recruits we can confirm everything he says tonight if the recruited comes forward

out of mad and vis they both seem scummy to me but only one has a vote on me so ##vote vis

Also oni you say that we started with two power roles? So what is pod claiming doc then?

Vis you've looked stairght past the point oni says 2 power roles him and cal, and yet unvote the guy claiming doc and vote me for nothing yet again so scummy

6 hours ago, Visovics said:

So there seems to be a plan. So we need Pod alive for it...

##unvote Pod

well Ebon has read most suspicious of the 2 that are lined up alongside me so

##vote EbonHawk

1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:

Vis you've looked stairght past the point oni says 2 power roles him and cal, and yet unvote the guy claiming doc and vote me for nothing yet again so scummy

Yeah, the thing is, Pod is on the test tonight, if he's telling the truth, Oni is alive tomorrow, then Pod is truthful. And so now if Oni's truthful, Broba and Ovi are cleaned. Oni and Pod will be judged based on how this night goes. Therefore there is me, Mad and you lined up. Ergo of the the 3 you are most suspicious.

One way or another, @PodRacer your claim conflicts with truth in many ways. Anything to say?

7 Players= 4 to Hammer

@PodRacer (1) Visovics, Onidsen

@Visovics (3) Onidsen , Madaghmire, BrobaFett, EbonHawk

@Madaghmire (0)

@ovinomanc3r (0)

@Onidsen (1) EbonHawk , PodRacer

@EbonHawk (1) Visovics

@BrobaFett (0)

Sorry Guys I had missed a vote and mixed up an unvote... this is where we stand.

4 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Lol and me wondering if that was flavour or an actual role.

@TheToad do you wanna fix it?

Fix what?

Sorry folks. Apparently I wrote deserter instead of defector. Must have mixed up the words in my mind before writing. My bad.

So I hate deduction through flavor, but I think maybe we need to start using it? Since we arent getting roles on death?

On 04/12/2017 at 0:54 AM, Madaghmire said:

I was joking regarding his initial comment, but trying to use flavor to establish towniness will draw a vote from me every time.