Gnips died with 0 votes?

So I ran a rankling suspicion through some simulations and I can confirm that we have a poisoner or an arsonist, or both.

I’m inclined to believe its both, given the thematic flavor an arsonist brings and that Gnips died last night after a no-kill on N1. But we def have a poisoner.

Sorry that was unclear.

I believe we have an arsonist because it would be thematic and Ebon loves theme, and I believe we def have a poisoner because of gnips death.

Well that’s a crappy turnout, now I know I can’t trust my results, specially since I got scum again :/

46 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Sorry that was unclear.

I believe we have an arsonist because it would be thematic and Ebon loves theme, and I believe we def have a poisoner because of gnips death.

Hmm. That would be interesting...not sure who's who.

Right now I have two questions:

1. @Madaghmire, you confirmed earlier that you have a role that was blocked by Toad. Care to elaborate? If it's something you'd rather keep quiet, that's fine, but it looks a bit suspicious.

2. @Visovics, do you have any idea why you seem to be 'getting false results'? (I put that in quotes because I'm even less convinced that you're a cop now)

Honestly, the 3rd party theory is sounding more and more plausible by the day- I could believe that there are only 3rd party players and we've just got a serial killer or something similar, like Mads mentioned.

1 minute ago, ImperialCaptain2017 said:

2. @Visovics, do you have any idea why you seem to be 'getting false results'? (I put that in quotes because I'm even less convinced that you're a cop now)

No idea, but I don’t think I have been told everything about my role

2 hours ago, ImperialCaptain2017 said:

Hmm. That would be interesting...not sure who's who.

Right now I have two questions:

1. @Madaghmire, you confirmed earlier that you have a role that was blocked by Toad. Care to elaborate? If it's something you'd rather keep quiet, that's fine, but it looks a bit suspicious.

2. @Visovics, do you have any idea why you seem to be 'getting false results'? (I put that in quotes because I'm even less convinced that you're a cop now)

Honestly, the 3rd party theory is sounding more and more plausible by the day- I could believe that there are only 3rd party players and we've just got a serial killer or something similar, like Mads mentioned.

I soft claimed in my first post of the day.

2 hours ago, Visovics said:

No idea, but I don’t think I have been told everything about my role

Three thoughts here;

1. Vis could be an insane or paranoid cop.

2. Vis identifies third party as scum

3. Vis is a filthy liar

7 hours ago, BrobaFett said:

Gnips died with 0 votes?

I think he was the Nk no?

6 hours ago, Visovics said:

Well that’s a crappy turnout, now I know I can’t trust my results, specially since I got scum again :/

Care to share?

4 minutes ago, PodRacer said:

Care to share?

Imp cap this time, not trusting it this time tho

Did @CaribbeanNinja died?

7 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

So I ran a rankling suspicion through some simulations and I can confirm that we have a poisoner or an arsonist, or both.

I’m inclined to believe its both, given the thematic flavor an arsonist brings and that Gnips died last night after a no-kill on N1. But we def have a poisoner.

How did you confirm two roles in one night? Are you an oracle?

So Vis is useless or lying?

Well lets try and find the poisoner.

Maybe it's under the radar Cninj?

@CaribbeanNinja what do you think? You a poisoner?

1 hour ago, PodRacer said:

How did you confirm two roles in one night? Are you an oracle?

I didnt confirm two roles, I confirmed the existence of delayed action killers. And yes.

21 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

I didnt confirm two roles, I confirmed the existence of delayed action killers. And yes.

Well that explains things quite nicely.

Here's something else interesting.

2 hours ago, Visovics said:

Imp cap this time, not trusting it this time tho

This would support the theory that Vis detects 3rd party as scum, since I'm 3rd party too. Now I'm very confused by the setup. Delayed action kills, an Oracle, a roleblocker, and a faulty cop (maybe)...and we haven't found the killers yet. I suppose the Hutts just like to watch us suffer.

2 hours ago, PodRacer said:

Did @CaribbeanNinja died?

No.

2 hours ago, BrobaFett said:

@CaribbeanNinja what do you think? You a poisoner?

Questioning Mads and Vis, but their actions don’t seem evil.

No.

Mad what what question are you asking tonight?

I dont know yet.

Ookay, things are getting whacky. Is there any way we can "trust" results from Vis, assuming he's telling the truth, as in can we at least confirm that his results are always a lie?

33 minutes ago, Caldias said:

Ookay, things are getting whacky. Is there any way we can "trust" results from Vis, assuming he's telling the truth, as in can we at least confirm that his results are always a lie?

We can probably trust him if he finds a town result.

37 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

We can probably trust him if he finds a town result.

I’d be actually more worried of a town result, cos if 3rd parties come scum, what does town mean then?

8 hours ago, Visovics said:

I’d be actually more worried of a town result, cos if 3rd parties come scum, what does town mean then?

Town, probably?

I could ask.

10 hours ago, Caldias said:

Ookay, things are getting whacky. Is there any way we can "trust" results from Vis, assuming he's telling the truth, as in can we at least confirm that his results are always a lie?

Perhaps Mad could ask if there was a cop at the start of the game??