Can't decide between to fleets for a tournament need some help

By Payens, in Star Wars: Armada Fleet Builds

So I am going into a fun Tournament tomorrow and I can't decide between 2 fleets so I figured I would take it out to the community and ask which would you NOT want to see across the board from you.

400 Points

Assault Objective: Most Wanted

Defense Objective: Contested Outpost

Navigation Objective: Salvage Run

SHIP POINT COST
Gozanti-class Cruisers 23
Interdictor-class Suppression Refit 90
commander-icon-black.png Admiral Sloane 24
title-icon-black.png Interdictor 3
officer-icon-black.png Captain Needa 2
support-team-icon-black.png Projection Experts 6
offensive-retrofit-icon-black.png Disposable Capacitors 3
experimental-retrofit-icon-black.png G-8 Experiemental Projector 8
experimental-retrofit-icon-black.png Grav Shift Reroute 2
Victory II-Class Star Destroyer 85
title-icon-black.png Dominator 12
weapons-team-icon-black.png Gunnery Team 7
offensive-retrofit-icon-black.png Disposable Capacitors 3
Gozanti-class Cruisers 23
fleet-support-icon-black.png Comms Net 2
Total cost of ships and upgrades, commander included =293
SQUADRON AMOUNT POINT COST
Dengar 1 20
Soontir Fel 1 18
"Howlrunner" 1 16
Maarek Steele 1 21
Ciena Ree 1 17
Lambda-class Shuttle 1 15
Total squadron cost =107

POINTS
397/400

Assault Objective: Most Wanted

Defense Objective: Hyperspace Assault

Navigation Objective: Solar Corona

SHIP POINT COST
Assault Frigate Mark II B 72
commander-icon-black.png Admiral Ackbar 38
title-icon-black.png Gallant Haven 8
officer-icon-black.png Intel Officer 7
weapons-team-icon-black.png Gunnery Team 7
defensive-retrofit-icon-black.png Electronic Countermeasures 7
turbolasers-icon-black.png X17 Turbolasers 6
Assault Frigate Mark II B 72
officer-icon-black.png Intel Officer 7
weapons-team-icon-black.png Gunnery Team 7
defensive-retrofit-icon-black.png Electronic Countermeasures 7
turbolasers-icon-black.png X17 Turbolasers 6
Nebulon-B Support Refit 51
turbolasers-icon-black.png Dual Turbolaser Turrets 5
GR-75 Medium Transports 18
fleet-support-icon-black.png Comms Net 2
Total cost of ships and upgrades, commander included =320
SQUADRON AMOUNT POINT COST
Jan Ors 1 19
Biggs Darklighter 1 19
X-Wing Squadron 3 39
Total squadron cost =77
2015-17 © Armada Warlords

Thoughts which would you NOT want to go against?

The second one is stronger

However, you can just can Gallant Haven and bring another Fighter instead (A-Wing for example or a Z-95 if you want a bid)

That gives you 7 deployments and you already have enough dmg resistance for your screen to somewhat handle most threats.

Also: pick another objective for Yellow: Hyperspace assault isn't what you are looking for with the list.
Fire lanes could be your pick

"Side arc ships like Assault Frigates can orbit the Fire Lanes tokens to keep pinging them for victory points while also presenting their other side arc to potential interlopers and obstructing shots at the tokens that would happen through them in some cases."
From @Snipafist's blog about the objectives
http://cannotgetyourshipout.blogspot.de/2017/03/armada-objectives-yellow-objectives.html

Maybe exchange the Neb-B for a CR90A with TRC and Jainas light, so you can add a final X-Wing

Edited by Doppelganger

I also think you should swap out the Nebulon-B for a TRCR-90, but instead of Jaina's Light, use the saved points to add either Toryn Farr or Bomber Command Center to your GR-75s.

Thank you for the input guys making some adjustments now...

Let us know which fleet you roll and how you do. Always good to hear about how the advice pans out on the table.

17 hours ago, stonestokes said:

I also think you should swap out the Nebulon-B for a TRCR-90, but instead of Jaina's Light, use the saved points to add either Toryn Farr or Bomber Command Center to your GR-75s.

To me a BCC for four Bombers total with mostly red dice seems not worth it, especially since the comms net can do some good work here.
I could get behind Toryn on the list with a Z-95; all ships and almost all squads will profit from this.

Edited by Doppelganger