3 minutes ago, Truthiness said:

Vis, you backed off pretty quick. A little timid to draw attention on this opening day ?

Not really, it’s just that having a vote on my best (and basically only) town read for now is not exactly what I think best to do at the situation. Because in the shadow of what was directed to regarding my joke vote, Pod also backed off his, but in a more enigmatic way, so I don’t think I can avoid attracting attention, since I can guarantee you someone would jump on me saying I’m trying to defend myself by throwing shade on Pod. (I would bet on Mad or Gnips)

I haven’t backed off anything... is it such a scum move to question you Truthi? You have done nothing to earn my trust... all you’ve done is push on two different people based on weak evidence

1 minute ago, Visovics said:

Not really, it’s just that having a vote on my best (and basically only) town read for now is not exactly what I think best to do at the situation. Because in the shadow of what was directed to regarding my joke vote, Pod also backed off his, but in a more enigmatic way, so I don’t think I can avoid attracting attention, since I can guarantee you someone would jump on me saying I’m trying to defend myself by throwing shade on Pod. (I would bet on Mad or Gnips)

I lost you. Why would I go after you?

1 minute ago, TheToad said:

I haven’t backed off anything... is it such a scum move to question you Truthi? You have done nothing to earn my trust... all you’ve done is push on two different people based on weak evidence

The only evidence. With time running short.

1 minute ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

I lost you. Why would I go after you?

The usual “Throwing shade at someone else while defending”, just feel like you’re one of the players who’d analyze in that and push on it because it looks obviously scummy

2 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

The only evidence. With time running short.

That’s irrelevant... it’s still weak

1 minute ago, TheToad said:

That’s irrelevant... it’s still weak

Well, not entirely irrelevant. If it is the only evidence, it is the only thing you can use to go after somebody, no? Otherwise we'd all just 'stare' at one another whilst nothing happened. At least he is doing something . Is it limited? Sure. But it's something. Better than most of us, at any rate.

The upper levels of Nar Shaddaa are abuzz with life, people teeming in and out of the streets during the day

Vote Count:

@Caldias (0) - Pod

@Visovics (0)

@GhostofNobodyInParticular (0)

@Madaghmire (0)

@TheToad (0)

@PodRacer (1) - Truthi

@CaribbeanNinja (0)

@ImperialCaptain2017 (0)

@Truthiness (0) - Vis

With 9 people left in your little corner of Nar Shaddaa, it takes 5 to hammer

1 minute ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

Well, not entirely irrelevant. If it is the only evidence, it is the only thing you can use to go after somebody, no? Otherwise we'd all just 'stare' at one another whilst nothing happened. At least he is doing something . Is it limited? Sure. But it's something. Better than most of us, at any rate.

Well if it’s good enough for you then cast your vote.... it’s not good enough for me so I’ll hold off for now

3 minutes ago, TheToad said:

Well if it’s good enough for you then cast your vote.... it’s not good enough for me so I’ll hold off for now

It is not worth voting . It was worth investigating . He wasn't saying 'They're scum', but 'here's the only thing even remotely scummy so far - what do you think?'

Ok, I’ll be away so unlikely to be in till after it’s already night, so

##vote TheToad

this defense you’re providing reminds me of when you were godfather and strongly defended your no-vote point despite all experienced players pointing how it was a bad move but you stuck to your point... are you truly town? Or scum again?

10 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

It is not worth voting . It was worth investigating . He wasn't saying 'They're scum', but 'here's the only thing even remotely scummy so far - what do you think?'

Then why haven’t you, or anyone else, **** even Truthi done any real investigation into his “evidence”

No we’re gonna wait until the eleventh hour and lynch one of them based on nothing... or me for questioning it

1 minute ago, TheToad said:

Then why haven’t you, or anyone else, **** even Truthi done any real investigation into his “evidence”

No we’re gonna wait until the eleventh hour and lynch one of them based on nothing... or me for questioning it

He brought it up, and opened up for discussion the question 'Is this significant?' We responded. 'Investigation' was perhaps the wrong word to use.

Yeah evidence is pretty much always weak on Day One. Still a crapshoot. But doing nothing is worse than acting on weak evidence.

2 minutes ago, Caldias said:

Yeah evidence is pretty much always weak on Day One. Still a crapshoot. But doing nothing is worse than acting on weak evidence.

And questioning the pusher of weak evidence is apparently worse than doing nothing...

Just now, TheToad said:

And questioning the pusher of weak evidence is apparently worse than doing nothing...

No, but you seem to attack the fact that he took action, rather than why he took it.

4 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

No, but you seem to attack the fact that he took action, rather than why he took it.

That’s not true at all... but that is the way Truthi (and Mad a little bit) have made it seem...

All I did was question his motives. I pointed out that what he was doing was either a genuine townie move or a sneaky scum move... either is entirely possible at this point.

1 minute ago, TheToad said:

That’s not true at all... but that is the way Truthi (and Mad a little bit) have made it seem...

All I did was question his motives. I pointed out that what he was doing was either a genuine townie move or a sneaky scum move... either is entirely possible at this point.

'Tis how I interpreted your later statements.

Well the end is nigh... I got a sneaking suspicion the inevitable turbo is going to come my way

my list of suspicion is as follows

Truthi... Gnips...Mad... and Vis

each of the first 3 have done work casting shade my way by either twisting my words or “misinterpreting” them

Vis threw a vote on me and then bounced saying I’m playing like I did on my first game

so if (more like when) I get lynched the rest of town will at least have a little to go on

Unfortunately, I think your are right concerning your own death, for I think I must vote you or go for a no-vote, given my present reading. I shan't vote Truthi, and Mad hasn't really done much I am too suspicious of, save point out that you could have had dual motives. . . much like you claim him to have, and maybe like Ebon did last game - claim the scum are doing something because he was . I could I think be convinced by an argument on either at the moment, but I am leaning slightly more towards you.

*you

1 minute ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

Unfortunately, I think your are right concerning your own death, for I think I must vote you or go for a no-vote , given my present reading. I shan't vote Truthi, and Mad hasn't really done much I am too suspicious of, save point out that you could have had dual motives. . . much like you claim him to have, and maybe like Ebon did last game - claim the scum are doing something because he was . I could I think be convinced by an argument on either at the moment, but I am leaning slightly more towards you.

##vote Gnips.

I'm going on gut, but right now that seems a lot more substantial than any weak *** evidence we "have".

Mucho scum signs here.

@Caldias

@Madaghmire

@PodRacer

@ImperialCaptain2017

@Truthiness

what do you guys have to say?

Just now, CaribbeanNinja said:

##vote Gnips.

I'm going on gut, but right now that seems a lot more substantial than any weak *** evidence we "have".

Mucho scum signs here.

Understandable. But I have no other reads worth voting on. Do you think that in this short time we can find anything more worthwhile than the flimsy stuff we have on Toad? I do not think so.

Much like the votes against JJ and Vis on Day 1 last game, I am not happy with it, but it is the best I can come up with in the amount of time we have. You will notice I have not actually voted yet - I still have hope for something else to come up.

Well, I can see the reasoning for voting for The Toad, but he is also usually right and suffers at the hands of scum pushing, so I can also see why CNinja might be suspicious of GNiPs. I don't think Truth is acting scummy, though we don't have much to go on there. Mads is being jokey Mads, which is how he is if he's scum or town, really. I'm going to vote before time but I'd like to hear more before I do.

Day One is always the hardest.