3 hours ago, BlindSamurai13 said:The thing with Iaijutsu is that it is embedded in law.
The Book of Air p.16 for 4th Edition
3 hours ago, nameless ronin said:If you want Iai to not be the standard for formal duels, for resolving matters of honor, I get that. Multi-discipline duels are cool. That said, where does that leave the Kakita and their reputation as masters of single combat? It’s not exactly plausible that they can dominate duels if everyone gets to do whatever they do best, yet that is what they are supposed to be able to do (and I’m not even going into the mechanical side here). If they can’t, what does that mean for the Crane? And why would they devote as many resources as they do to a dueling school that can’t deliver consistent dueling champs and doesn’t deliver proper training for warfare either? If the nature of the formal duel is changed, then the Kakita and to a certain extent the entire Crane clan need to be changed accordingly as well.
Except what we see is that the Crane are practically the only clan that cares, with Dragon thrown in - as the spiteful counter-meta Niten duelists* - meaning the only other clan that actually cares for Iaijutsu doesn't even use the Crane's established method of Iaijutsu in the duels. The other clans have few, if any techniques for it, and no schools centered around it. Whether its "in the laws" or not, its rarely bothered with beyond the Crane lands once we step outside of fiction and look at actual mechanics.
I do believe this is mostly a flaw in the mechanics side - where Iaijutsu is constantly put in as its own system with its own mechanics, and surprise surprise CRANE have a technique for it, and no one else is going to care.
Its not likely to change because of the Iaijutsu cult embedded deep within the culture of players of L5R. Even people who don't play Crane are certain Iaijutsu is the way its supposed to be yet no one else gets a dueling school or ranks in Iaijutsu...
You would think - if it was really intrinsic to the law - that every clan would have a school dedicated to the practice, since it would obviously be a very important advantage to have if you wanted to do anything legally...
What I propose is that we simply require a player forfeit honor to use any weapon other than a katana in a duel, unless their opponent also uses a weapon other than a katana. This can respect the Iaijutsu "legality" while preventing every clan from needing a dueling school to enjoy the dueling system. It also means the Crane can have some dueling advantage, but that it may be mitigated by using unorthodox styles - as the primary advantage of Iaijutsu is that you are drawing and cutting at once, where dueling with a Naginata would not require me to even draw.
*While the fiction recently depicted a Niten duelist actually drawing both weapons... this is highly unrealistic. You typically use 2 hands to draw a weapon into a strike as you need to both clear the sword from the saya as early as possible to transition from a drawing motion to a cutting motion, and to lend enough power to the strike to cut. It is called Sayabiki and is one of the more important skills in Iai. Niten should start with both weapons drawn.