9 minutes ago, ImperialCaptain2017 said:

Please no more percentage games Pod...

Im not gonna put all my faith in the numbers, instead im gonna use my*noodle (*thats pompey talk for head)

27 minutes ago, BrobaFett said:

Hah I wasn't throwing shade on you ninj, I was just using you as an example for why we need to take crumbs with a grain of salt.

What I understand so far is that if you crumb fishing you are town, or scum trying to be town. But my flavor as nothing to do with nautical flavor at ALL but yet is 100% town. So much so I am willing to come out and say it against the current crumbs.

If there has been a hint beyond the flavor to actual substance that i have missed. But then, I have been working on a big deadline and playing GK on vassal at the same time today, so my attention has been admittedly slim.

Didn't know I would raise your ire that much, but again, man are people snappy this game.

I'm not the one whose ire's up...

I think I've got one...

1 hour ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

@ovinomanc3r why don't you just full claim? What part of subtle did you not understand?

34 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

You're much too smart to NOT catch something about what we've talked about so far...

##Vote BrobaFett

Woah, man. First you ask for a full role reveal and then you blast the guy making perfectly rational points? You're really out of character this game so far. I'm used to you being quiet and deliberate on day one.

##vote CaribbeanNinja

6 minutes ago, Truthiness said:

Woah, man. First you ask for a full role reveal and then you blast the guy making perfectly rational points? You're really out of character this game so far. I'm used to you being quiet and deliberate on day one.

##vote CaribbeanNinja

I cannot believe you and Ovin really. You two that have voted for me are the ones that should KNOW that I'm a town.

The first quote there was totally sarcastic.

Next, having been Broba's scum buddy last game, I have a feeling.

50 minutes ago, PodRacer said:

I reckon theres a 75% chan.ce theres more

Umm...what is this truncated quote you've done here?

1 minute ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

I cannot believe you and Ovin really. You two that have voted for me are the ones that should KNOW that I'm a town.

The first quote there was totally sarcastic.

Next, having been Broba's scum buddy last game, I have a feeling.

Missed the sarcasm completely. My and there. That's enough for me to

##unvote

But you're still out of character for your usual self. Broba is 100% right about the breadcrumbing. It doesn't really mean a damned thing, as last game showed. In retrospect I feel stupid for starting it. That's why I don't really get your read here.

Have I mentioned how much I hate day one?

Im not a setup guru by any means, but based on my role, i suspect its a solid reckon.

Also i feel like i vaguely remember vis saying theres no chance his next game ends on D3 at some point in the past.

@Truthiness

Also @Truthinessread my posts calmly and deliberately (And NOT through the "snappy" lens Broba is inflating) and you'll see just that.

Just now, Truthiness said:

That's why I don't really get your read here

Broba's post feels like an "Hey guys, I'm here post." Cal and him are really good at them.

It is the best read I have so far.

2 minutes ago, PodRacer said:

Im not a setup guru by any means, but based on my role, i suspect its a solid reckon.

Also i feel like i vaguely remember vis saying theres no chance his next game ends on D3 at some point in the past.

@Truthiness

That doesn't answer my question. Let me be more clear: you quoted me, but changed the text to be something completely different. Why?

Just now, Truthiness said:

That doesn't answer my question. Let me be more clear: you quoted me, but changed the text to be something completely different. Why?

Oh nevermind, I see what happened. You quoted me quoting Mad and it somehow ended up looking like it was my words. Disregard.

ah, TBH i thought i was quoting @Madaghmire

Btw Pod, I promise you that Gink has NO problem throwing shade my way or any way. That is the way he plays. That's not to say we shouldn't keep an eye on him.

100% @CaribbeanNinja

He will have to be on his best behavior =)

is this post useful to the town?

Cninj I will admit I 100% don't get why you are voting for me, but at this point I don't particularly care. If I get the d1 lynch I will just laugh.

I get that we were scummates last game, but that was last game this is this game. I made an accurate and in my mind pro-town statement and you are accusing me of just saying hi? There are people who have down far less and getting far less scrutiny.

#FishInABarrel

i can play along today

##vote Broba

1 minute ago, BrobaFett said:

Cninj I will admit I 100% don't get why you are voting for me, but at this point I don't particularly care. If I get the d1 lynch I will just laugh.

I get that we were scummates last game, but that was last game this is this game. I made an accurate and in my mind pro-town statement and you are accusing me of just saying hi? There are people who have down far less and getting far less scrutiny.

I hear ya dude. And I could be totally wrong. It is day one.

However, Looking at your post and then reaction, It is how I'm voting so far.

1. You came out and called me and Pod snappy, when I'd characterize only Mads and Gink as getting after each other. I'd say I was "less than snappy". When you're scum you try to throw the shade.

2. I personally think that the "over you head" defense is a stretch. (Only Dras gets to use that and in a limited fashion.)

3. I think the scum could easily hide behind the "hey guys don't breadcrumb" defense.

Again, I could be wrong,

2 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

snipped all the quotes talking about crumbs

I didn't miss anything, I just chose to keep information to myself. The less the scum know the better. Least the fish jokes were rather funny.

36 minutes ago, Truthiness said:

Have I mentioned how much I hate day one?

Join the club...I still have no solid read on anyone. I plan to keep an eye out for more mysterious outbursts of "snappyness" (yes I just made that word up), but for now there's nothing to do but make fish jokes, apparently.

@GhostofNobodyInParticular, your thoughts?

@ImperialCaptain2017

He thinks that you're stalling

1 hour ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Again, I could be wrong,

This is it, you're just wrong

I don't really have much else to add, other than isn't it middle of the night for NIPPY right now?

Hey guys, I'm here.

5 hours ago, JJs Juggernaut said:

I didn't miss anything, I just chose to keep information to myself. The less the scum know the better. Least the fish jokes were rather funny.

I agree with this. Even breadcrumbing could help the scum. Don't forget that at this point they know more than the townies, because they know about 3-5 (depending on the setup) roles for sure. This not only eliminates a lots of unknowns from the equatin but their own role may actually could indirectly figure out the existence of town roles for them.

I don't think breadcrumbing too much is a good idea, especially not wheh you detail it so much like @ovinomanc3r did above or as the "triumvirate" did in the previous game.

Regardless of the above, those who were part of the breadcrumbing feel like town to me at the moment. Partly because there were too many of them, so at least some of them should be town.

On the other hand, I am really interested in the Broba-Ninja clash. Carry on!