Well light of the recent development I'm gonna hold off voting on Mad or Ninja... until we can look into this further
which brings me to my next candidate Imp cap... he keeps jumping in saying he'll give some analysis but then either ghosts on us or regurgitates the consensus
its not gold but it's what I got
##vote ImpCap
4 minutes ago, JJs Juggernaut said:I don't trust Mad's claim. Maybe it's just coming off a game GMing were I gave everyone fake claims, but I know Vis has talked about his game not being susceptible to mass claim. Mad's claim is perfect...too perfect.
Indeed. You know, the information he dropped can be found right here basically word-for-word:
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Fisherman
So, basically his claim tells us nothing. If he's scum, he has every reason to lie. If he's who he says he is, then CNinja is probably lying, since there wouldn't be two fishermen.
If you flip town, I'm sorry, but if you're scum...not so much.
Hmm...I think the point on not punishing pod for improvements in playstyle is well taken.
In light of recent developments:
## unvote
## vote BrobaFett
I concur with mad's analysis that, of the players who voted on him, Broba seems most likely to be scum.
16 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:Guys, unless Mads got a perfect fake claim I do not think he's scum. Go back and check my drops (Binoculars, Magnifying Glass) It is a perfect match.
Something tells me this is the vanilla of this game.
2 minutes ago, TheToad said:which brings me to my next candidate Imp cap... he keeps jumping in saying he'll give some analysis but then either ghosts on us or regurgitates the consensus
its not gold but it's what I got
##vote ImpCap
So as you might remember from last game, I don't post in a hurry then disappear because I like it...I'd rather play Mafia than be in class or at work.
1 minute ago, Truthiness said:Something tells me this is the vanilla of this game.
That would explain the fish jokes...
Question is
Four Scum or Five?
5 minutes ago, ImperialCaptain2017 said:Indeed. You know, the information he dropped can be found right here basically word-for-word:
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Fisherman
So, basically his claim tells us nothing. If he's scum, he has every reason to lie. If he's who he says he is, then CNinja is probably lying, since there wouldn't be two fishermen.
If you flip town, I'm sorry, but if you're scum...not so much.
He also got every bit of the flavor right (which yes, Vis warned us about) so it isn't just a cut and paste from that site.
I very specifically didnt cut and paste my pm. I wrote that **** out on my phone.
And they changed it up ninja, you can use the director from anywhere no more orbit, pick a locale, load, nonsense.
10 minutes ago, ImperialCaptain2017 said:So as you might remember from last game, I don't post in a hurry then disappear because I like it...I'd rather play Mafia than be in class or at work.
I understand your busy Imp, I've got no issue with a player who can only pop in every once in a while
i do have a problem with a player who promises analysis and then brings little
and like I said this is a D1 gut vote
Seen the posts but driving. Still driving. Have plenty of second thoughts on Mad but not going to unvote yet despite mads heavy deflecting to me as alternate lynch.
As I said before. My gut says ovino but I also said pod and ghost weren't good options in my mind.
That left you and cninj with votes. Cninj and you both hopped on me hard, there wasn't a good choice here for me, so I voted the one I felt more likely to flip scum of the two. Where is the conflict? Nowhere. Not saying its the right choice, but there is a very clear train of thought as to how I got there.
The main reason I DIDNT want to vote for you mad was JJs post which seemed did very weighted to convey an opinion not the truth. Honestly it read scummy. If we want to vote JJ id lend my vote but that isn't what is on the table right now.
Anyway good job deflecting so hard you got me votes. Lynching me100% won't get you a scum today, but hey whatever it takes to save your neck.
52 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:In fact, here;
I'm a New Republic Agent, town aligned fisherman. I can go through the ships lost and found each night with my ##fish command and find gadgets to use on subsequent nights. I can have more than one item at a time but only one action per night. (A little swiss army but of mild import. Honestly, I'm not sure the role is totally worth protecting but it has some upside)
Items (role they mimic) and percentage chance:
syringes (doc) 10%
magnifying glasses (cop) 15%
guns (vigilante) 15%
1-shot vest (bulletproof) 20%
binoculars (watcher) 25%
gps locators (tracker) 25%
Thats all I got folks. And I'll throw a vote on
##brobafett
For his defensive post earlier, and his inconsistency in my vote.
Wait... the ships lost and found?... aren't we in a cantina?
5 minutes ago, TheToad said:Wait... the ships lost and found?... aren't we in a cantina?
Beats me dude. This is what was in my pm.
personally im going vigilante. Its easier that way. Im a pretty good watcher, but i think that would be too hard to sell.
its gonna be breadcrumb city 2moro.
still not 100% on the best place to leave my vote before i put my head down
i dont really want to have to set an alarm!
i could use $0.02 @Madaghmire
Just now, PodRacer said:personally im going vigilante. Its easier that way. Im a pretty good watcher, but i think that would be too hard to sell.
its gonna be breadcrumb city 2moro.
still not 100% on the best place to leave my vote before i put my head down
i dont really want to have to set an alarm!
i could use $0.02 @Madaghmire
I dunno what to tell you. I dropped my vote. Although Broba's post does have me rethinking it a little.
Going to bed and unfortunately I see no compelling reason to change my vote. I'm just not seeing whatever it is some of you are seeing in Broba. Sticking with Ninja, unfortunately.
Ok @Visovics is there any chance we can get a vote count? I just got caught up.
He's been buzzed 3 times, but hasn't been online for 4 hours.
##vote @GhostofNobodyInParticular
for tonight-
@Caldias it small hours of the morning local time, i expect you will be waiting 2-3 hours minimum.
Just now, Drasnighta said:He's been buzzed 3 times, but hasn't been online for 4 hours.
He's asleep. I'm pretty sure he's europe.
1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:He's asleep. I'm pretty sure he's europe.
Which would explain it.
Must have an alarm to be up for lynchin' time.
I am unsure where the vote is, and I am sorry to be late, of course, but I think I'm gonna vote.
##vote JJsJuggernaut
He appeared a little too HAM in accusation mode in my opinion, and I think the CNinja/Broba thing might just be residual from last game.
Ok all...time for bed now, so see you in the morning. Hopefully we can come to a conclusion.
Does anybody have a rough count?
I posted an accurAte one a page back. Update it for me? I am almost home, traffic and picking up kid is making me run super late.