was there a list of madaghmire town reads that i missed?

It seems we have one choice, really, which is to lynch Broba. Because either he's lying, and thus is scum/cult, or he's telling the truth, and thus will likely be recruited by cult.

Shame. The one potential savior is if cult can't access him either, just like CNinja and Dras couldn't. Is it likely? If so we can keep him around.

Hey all, I'm here, and totally understand I need to put myself out more. I get that I look like a snake in the grass, but I'm more of a guy cleaning poop from a bathtub because someone decided that would be fun.

I gotta say, the Broba/CNinja showdown I did not see coming. The results are really weird. I looked but couldn't really find anything, but do you more experienced folks know if there is any role combination where both could be telling the truth? It looks to me like one of them is lying.

My other concern is, we have an annoying *** cult leader out there. So the old tactic of well lets lynch one and then trust or kill the other, well even if Broba flips scum or cult and CNinja is like see guys, he could become cult that night. I mean, if I was the leader I'd start popping those that are confirmed town, so to speak.

We really need to find out who the leader is before this gets out of hand like last game. My night ability doesn't help discover that, but maybe someone else's does (if so don't say anything, just start sniffing).

@TheToad

Unofficial voting record after Day start stands at:

BrobaFett ##vote carribeanninja
PodRacer ##vote Caribbean ninja

CaribbeanNinja ##vote Brobafett
Onidsen ##vote Broba
Truthiness ##vote BrobaFett
GhostofNobodyInParticular ##vote Broba

BrobaFett ##vote Brobafett

13 minutes ago, PodRacer said:

was there a list of madaghmire town reads that i missed?

No, I just want to hear your reasoning.

5 minutes ago, Drasnighta said:

@TheToad

Unofficial voting record after Day start stands at:

BrobaFett ##vote carribeanninja
PodRacer ##vote Caribbean ninja

CaribbeanNinja ##vote Brobafett
Onidsen ##vote Broba
Truthiness ##vote BrobaFett
GhostofNobodyInParticular ##vote Broba

BrobaFett ##vote Brobafett

I have a vote in on him too.

Also broba cant actuslly vote himself.

So he's l-2?

So either Broba is telling the truth and needs to be lynch so the cult dosnt go nuts

or he's lying and therefore needs to be lynched...

Ill put him at -1 unless you guys would rather me wait

Well, this is interesting... But Broba is ultimately right. We KNOW there is a cult. We know that he is either the leader with an enormous bluff or he says the truth which means he is clearly the best target for the cult.

We have two choices: Either we really lynch Broba for the good of the town, or we figure out who is the cult leader for sure and lynch him. Can we do that?

What still makes me concern is why Dras couldn't shot at Broba? Granted, if he couldn't be turned it would be a great town ability. But with a cult around that's a double-edged sword because the tank townie can be turned instantly into a tank cult member. So either Broba says the truth but in this case he should have some additional ability that prevents actions against him (mirror comes to my mind). But then he shouldn't be concerned about being turned into a cultist!

@PodRacer it's really a moot question who I would have shot. Based on what I was thinking after day 1 it would have been Ninja probably. But now I honestly can't answer the question

4 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

I have a vote in on him too.

You are correct, I missed it in the wall because my Toddler wanted up on my Knee.

BrobaFett ##vote carribeanninja
PodRacer ##vote Caribbean ninja

CaribbeanNinja ##vote Brobafett
Onidsen ##vote Broba
Truthiness ##vote BrobaFett
GhostofNobodyInParticular ##vote Broba
Madaghmire ##vote brobafett

BrobaFett ##vote Brobafett

Result:

The Ninja on 2 (1)
The Broba on 5 (6)

I couldn't find a rule on Vis' initial post about voting for yourself. Instead, this is all it states (as a copy-paste), and of course, if its elsewhere, I didn't really look for it.

You can do this by typing "##Vote PlayerName". You only get one vote, so if you vote again it changes your vote to another player. You can also "##vote no one" and skip your lynch for the day if the majority agrees.

Pretty sure Broba's vote of himself does not count. We stopped that a while ago when I ruined it.

I assuming it doesn't count either

Just now, Truthiness said:

Pretty sure Broba's vote of himself does not count. We stopped that a while ago when I ruined it.

Probably.

But when have I ever accepted word of mouth over RAW?

Vis'll let us know officially, and I'm sure I'll be in the wrong - but I wanted to record it for posterity, since it is my unofficial voting record

4 minutes ago, Norell said:

it's really a moot question who I would have shot. Based on what I was thinking after day 1 it would have been Ninja probably. But now I honestly can't answer the question

correctamundo.

I missed the link with your killing Gink equating to town, but im warming too it.

who do you think would want a guy like gink on their team?

@Drasnightaraw you've voted for me and Broba like 14 times now.

@Visovics much votes. Few counts

Moar doge

1 minute ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

@Drasnightaraw you've voted for me and Broba like 14 times now.

Then my opinion is completely worthless now, as I'm likely to be ModKilled any minute.

1 minute ago, Drasnighta said:

Then my opinion is completely worthless now, as I'm likely to be ModKilled any minute.

not at all.

nothing is stopping you from voting...

that being said, I am very interested in what you think.

Sorry people, was in school, now out for birthday dinner, a bit non-stop for the last few hours.

I'll try to get a vote count going, just a bit of time

Btw voting yourself is indeed illegal, will fix the opening text shortly

1 minute ago, Visovics said:

Btw voting yourself is indeed illegal, will fix the opening text shortly

Goodie.

Now I know.

@TheToad

Hold off, for now at least, With norells action going off, we are missing some investigation time.

Dras needs more intel.

13 Players alive, 7 to hammer.

1-@Madaghmire (0) -

2-@ImperialCaptain2017(0) -

3-@Drasnighta(0)

4-@Norell(0)

5-@Caldias(0) -

7-@GhostofNobodyInParticular(0) -

6-@PodRacer (0) -

7-@JJs Juggernaut(0) -

8-@Onidsen(0)

9-@Truthiness(0)

11-@TheToad(0)

12-@CaribbeanNinja(2) - Broba Fett, PodRacer

13-@BrobaFett(5) - CaribbeanNinja, Onidsen, Truthiness, Nippy, Madaghmire

@Visovics

im on ninja too