1 minute ago, Visovics said:Serial Killer, a self aligned with day kill that wins if he is the last man standing, and actually it fits with the gunsmith interaction, as its results say it has no guns.
Ah...I see. So, it's possible that there could be multiple self-aligned roles in this game.
1 minute ago, Visovics said:I also think it's the most likely, funnily enough once again the way to prove is lynch/gunsmith
A gunsmith and a cop make a lot of sense in this set up. Assuming Pod is a Vig, he would test positive for the gunsmith, but not the cop. JJ, if being truthful, would test positive for the cop, but not the gunsmith.
2 minutes ago, Visovics said:I also think it's the most likely, funnily enough once again the way to prove is lynch/gunsmith
What are the odds that we have no gunsmith in this game?
1 minute ago, WigTii said:Ah...I see. So, it's possible that there could be multiple self-aligned roles in this game.
Last time we had a role madness (last game, run by Biggs) had only 1 town, the rest were 3rd parties. Although Ghost must have a more normal setup, I wouldn't discard the possibility of multiple 3rd parties in this game
1 minute ago, Visovics said:Last time we had a role madness (last game, run by Biggs) had only 1 town, the rest were 3rd parties. Although Ghost must have a more normal setup, I wouldn't discard the possibility of multiple 3rd parties in this game
Well, this shakes things up a bit.
3 minutes ago, WigTii said:What are the odds that we have no gunsmith in this game?
Never tell me the odds...
On a more serious note, we are only thinking of a gunsmith because it's a peculiar interaction with the claimed role, and it's a role madness. The odds seem to increase as we see more and more roles that react differently. The poisoner would also be a no-gun result, and yet be a threat to town, and show up as 3rd party to a normal cop.
So if we are assuming right, this could be a big spider web of a setup
3 minutes ago, Visovics said:Never tell me the odds...
On a more serious note, we are only thinking of a gunsmith because it's a peculiar interaction with the claimed role, and it's a role madness. The odds seem to increase as we see more and more roles that react differently. The poisoner would also be a no-gun result, and yet be a threat to town, and show up as 3rd party to a normal cop.
So if we are assuming right, this could be a big spider web of a setup
You might be right about the spider-web...seems to fit the scenerio Ghost created. I wonder why there was no revenge kill on Pod for taking out Ninja. Any thoughts about that?
Just now, WigTii said:You might be right about the spider-web...seems to fit the scenerio Ghost created. I wonder why there was no revenge kill on Pod for taking out Ninja. Any thoughts about that?
Maybe they thought Pod would be protected OR they think they can turn this around on Pod OR Pod is one of them, although I don't think that's likely
Well, I'm quite interested in hearing what Pod has to say when he posts.
I wonder why they killed mad? I hadn't pegged him as a gung ho townie, in fact he was on my radar as a potential scum. As I re-read things this morning he seemed to be stirring the pot but never taking a definitive side, playing the third party survivor.
Im also curious if is poison kill will still happen?
1 minute ago, TheToad said:I wonder why they killed mad? I hadn't pegged him as a gung ho townie, in fact he was on my radar as a potential scum. As I re-read things this morning he seemed to be stirring the pot but never taking a definitive side, playing the third party survivor.
Im also curious if is poison kill will still happen?
Can a doctor or another role cure a poison?
1 minute ago, WigTii said:Can a doctor or another role cure a poison?
When I GMed, if the doctor was there in the night of the death he could save
Normally tho, a poison medic is the only way to protect from a poisoner
I believe Ghost will not allow normal medic to save from poisoner
2 minutes ago, Visovics said:When I GMed, if the doctor was there in the night of the death he could save
Normally tho, a poison medic is the only way to protect from a poisoner
I believe Ghost will not allow normal medic to save from poisoner
Okay. I appreciate the education. ?
@PodRacer once again D2 starts with requirements of a clarification and explanation by you 
So I suppose we will find out tomorrow if Mad used his poison.
Sorry about the no lynch guys, I thought we had till Wednesday! I wish we had that clock like in Oni's game.
On my way home from work, will add more later.
33 minutes ago, Visovics said:Last time we had a role madness (last game, run by Biggs) had only 1 town, the rest were 3rd parties. Although Ghost must have a more normal setup, I wouldn't discard the possibility of multiple 3rd parties in this game
Is that an admission of third party? You made a similar statement last game when you were third party.
Okay, I'll be truthfull here, I believe it's in the town's best interest and so that we don't waste the day on speculations related to this. Mad used his poison, he visited Wig last night...
Just now, Truthiness said:Is that an admission of third party? You made a similar statement last game when you were third party.
No, I'm town this time
Just now, Visovics said:Okay, I'll be truthfull here, I believe it's in the town's best interest and so that we don't waste the day on speculations related to this. Mad used his poison, he visited Wig last night...
And how do you know this?
Good lord, I am so frekkin' confused.
Ok, so let me see if I got this right-Cninja is dead, not because of lynching or scum, but because Pod killed him. Pod killed CNinja because he had some 'day' action that allowed it (## target?), that I failed to notice or ask about it. As it turns out, Pod got lucky because CNinja is/was a traitor to the town, and thus, Scum. But I'm unclear as to whether or not Pod knew that...if he did know that, how did he know that and why didn't he just tell us? If he didn't know that...he was just..what..randomly killing people? If he's just randomly killing people, regardless of whether or not he's scum (ie, 3rd party/unaligned) doesn't he hurt our cause? Shouldn't we lynch him?
And where does one get a definitive list of the roles? I checked out some Mafia wiki but it seems there are literally hundreds or roles available...does the GM of the scenario just randomly pick them?
Just now, WigTii said:And how do you know this?
Because I'm the watcher, and like another person, I believed in the potential of a power role, so I thought people would come after you, I got 2 names, and as Mad flipped poisoner, I have no doubt you'll die, unless we have a poison medic/if medic can cure poison
2 minutes ago, Visovics said:Okay, I'll be truthfull here, I believe it's in the town's best interest and so that we don't waste the day on speculations related to this. Mad used his poison, he visited Wig last night...
Oh boy. I better come clean then. I'm the town bus driver. I can swap night actions targeting two people. I...uh...kinda swapped Wig and Pod. My thought we the mafia might target a confirmed townie in Pod and With was my next most suspicious. Sorry Pod, but um...you gonna die. Does it help that I was trying to save you?
3 minutes ago, Rocmistro said:And where does one get a definitive list of the roles? I checked out some Mafia wiki but it seems there are literally hundreds or roles available...does the GM of the scenario just randomly pick them?
Generally the GM tries to pick what he wants and some roles that interact togheter, but some are more common to happen, such as medic, cop, mafia godfather... mostly they will be put in a way the game is balanced, although role madness is more about fun than balance
My thought *was*
Just now, Truthiness said:Oh boy. I better come clean then. I'm the town bus driver. I can swap night actions targeting two people. I...uh...kinda swapped Wig and Pod. My thought we the mafia might target a confirmed townie in Pod and With was my next most suspicious. Sorry Pod, but um...you gonna die. Does it help that I was trying to save you?
Damnit I thought you were the medic, I was trying to breadcrumb so you noticed I knew you visited, thus validating my claim, but **** I was wrong!