Which option is better?

By Trudem, in Imperial Assault Skirmish

Onar or Vinto and Devious Scheme?

Once completed I would have 8 total activations either way. The dilemma is which character to take.

Decide what u need more, heavy hitter or a char who can finish off several figures at once. I'd go for vinto +Devious

The answer is pretty much always "it depends"

Having said that, vinto and Devious for me in 90% of instances

Devious Scheme is widely considered the best 1-point you can play.

Onar is better than Vinto, IMO, but not better than both Vinto + DS.

If you already included DS in your list, Onar > Vinto usually.

Appreciate all the opinions. Here is what im thinking:

Jabba - 6

2 X r Weequay - 14

Hera - 4

Gideon - 3

rJawa - 3

C-3PO - 2

Black Market - 1

Temp. Alliance - 1

Onar/Vinto & Devious - 6

I prefer Onar over Vinto, but Vinto and devious can really come in handy with the current map rotation. What I do think your list has too much of is support. you could just drop Jabba and run both.

5 minutes ago, IamtheBendu said:

I prefer Onar over Vinto, but Vinto and devious can really come in handy with the current map rotation. What I do think your list has too much of is support. you could just drop Jabba and run both.

I never make it through my command deck. Jabba is for card draw, but I will figure it out tonite after testing.

Edited by Trudem

Its ok. I "Support" your decision in this

2 minutes ago, IamtheBendu said:

Its ok. I "Support" your decision in this

Your puns dont get any better on a message board...

2 minutes ago, Trudem said:

Your puns dont get any better on a message board...

I thought a friend like you would be more supportive

1 minute ago, IamtheBendu said:

I thought a friend like you would be more supportive

It certainly isnt as good as DeNym...

1 minute ago, Trudem said:

It certainly isnt as good as DeNym...

Back on the jeans thing. Kinda a stretch. Lol

Just now, IamtheBendu said:

Back on the jeans thing. Kinda a stretch. Lol

DeNym = Jeans...thats pretty clear

2 hours ago, Trudem said:

Appreciate all the opinions. Here is what im thinking:

Jabba - 6

2 X r Weequay - 14

Hera - 4

Gideon - 3

rJawa - 3

C-3PO - 2

Black Market - 1

Temp. Alliance - 1

Onar/Vinto & Devious - 6

23 minutes ago, IamtheBendu said:

I prefer Onar over Vinto, but Vinto and devious can really come in handy with the current map rotation. What I do think your list has too much of is support. you could just drop Jabba and run both.

I actually made this exact same change to the current list I'm running. Didn't feel like I had enough attacks combat the current heavy hitter lists. Dropping Jabba hurt aspects of Command Card draw and potential extra attacks, but I was able to more quickly dispose of figures with the addition of Onar. In other words, I'd drop Jabba as well.

17 hours ago, wannabepudge said:

In other words, I'd drop Jabba as well.

Dropping Jabba to get Onar, as well as Vinto and Devious would be my recommendation.

19 hours ago, Trudem said:

Jabba - 6

2 X r Weequay - 14

Hera - 4

Gideon - 3

rJawa - 3

C-3PO - 2

Black Market - 1

Temp. Alliance - 1

Onar/Vinto & Devious - 6

rWeequays? Did you mean to put eWeequay?

3 minutes ago, ImperialOfficer said:

Dropping Jabba to get Onar, as well as Vinto and Devious would be my recommendation.

rWeequays? Did you mean to put eWeequay?

Ive seen people do it both ways, e for elite and/or r for red

Ah makes sense. I've always done E for Elite. But I can support your decision.

4 hours ago, Trudem said:

Ive seen people do it both ways, e for elite and/or r for red

and this is partially why posting costs matters too - that way there's no confusion

but yeah I think it's the first time I saw r = red, I always thought e = elite (red guys), r = regular (grey guys)

Trudem normaly likes to do things bass ackwords.

Only sometimes

Edited by Trudem
typo