Well first to explain the gaps, I'm at work.

Earlier today many people were suspicious of truthiness, I suggested that we slow down and stop throwing baseless aqusations,I decided that I would vote for no lynch because I wanted it to be clear that I wasn't ready to vote for anybody.

Truthiness, and others but mainly truthiness, have been using my advocacy for the neutral stance to put all suspicion on me.

This suspiscion is based on "evidence" that is nothing more than meta-gaming

So I guess I'm guilty of simply not remaining quiet rather than stating I wasn't ready to vote on anybody by voting no lynch

Ok, Toad, I can explain why the neutral stance is bad. It has been explicitly stated that the pirate scum get to murder someone at night. So a no-vote means no one dies, and GUARANTEED an imperial officer dies at night, unless there is some form of protection. If we lynch someone day one, then we get to look at WHO voted for them if they are officers or pirates and make some logical conclusions from there. If we no vote we still have no baseline but are down one officer.

We are more likely to lynch town than not, but that is still better for us since it gives us something to go off of. You did say you were being careful with your vote, which is commendable, but then you sort of lashed out at Truthiness, who wasn't really accusing you outright, but was explaining why what you were doing was a bit suspect.

You may want a second opinion, but that's how I see it.

8 hours ago, Truthiness said:

Ha, same joke, same response. Talking and joking somehow equals Scum...again...

*sigh*

My day one methodology gets results...and also tends to get me killed by the Scum or the town. I will be holding the fact that I had the Scum pegged by day 2 last game over your collective heads forever. What was I saying? Oh right, I saw going to an incoherent strong of jokes and memes. Hmm, let's see if I can find a good 'come at me bro' meme again.

This will also be very effective cover if you are scum...

2 hours ago, ImperialCaptain2017 said:

It's beginning to seem like the threat isn't where I thought it was.

## unvote Truthiness

Toad's up to something, I think. Maybe he's not Scum but not townie/regular officer either (doctor/cop/etc.)...

Other than Toad's obvious issues (Caldias' play last game basically gives you little cover unfortunately) the above quote really troubles me...

Toad is the obvious choice so far. Too obvious.

44 minutes ago, TheToad said:

The sudden accusation? He's the one who has been doing a lot of work to make me look suspicious after I simply chose to take a neutral stance, am I to just sit here and let truthiness smear me?

What?! My total posts between you taking a hard stance against voting ever and switching your vote to me because I'm "smearing" you:

5 hours ago, Truthiness said:

Agreed.

4 hours ago, Truthiness said:

I'll reinforce the point. No day one hanging is very bad for the town. Without it, you have less to build a case with on later days. I know how the odds look from your first time because I've been in your exact position. But trust me, the day one vote is good for the town. Worst case scenario you hang a townie and then the people in on the vote have to explain themselves. Odds are at least one of them are scum. I'll keep you off -2 for now, but you're looking like the best candidate for the day one hanging.

I'm the one NOT voting against you at that point in time and trying to give you some advise. I literally just agreed with what Gnippy and Mad said and tried to convey my experience in taking the exact same stance at one point in time.

Yeah, I'm not holding back anymore.

##vote TheToad

FYI, that puts us at -2

13 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Other than Toad's obvious issues (Caldias' play last game basically gives you little cover unfortunately) the above quote really troubles me...

Toad is the obvious choice so far. Too obvious.

I'm the obvious choice... because of meta gaming

and truthiness... in your "advice" you point out that I'm the best candidate for lynching, you may of not accused me out right but you planted the seed.

17 minutes ago, TheToad said:

I'm the obvious choice... because of meta gaming

and truthiness... in your "advice" you point out that I'm the best candidate for lynching, you may of not accused me out right but you planted the seed.

Two people had already VOTED for you. How is that a new seed?!

5 minutes ago, Truthiness said:

Two people had already VOTED for you. How is that a new seed?!

Do we need to explain to you what it means to spread your seed?

49 minutes ago, Truthiness said:

Yeah, I'm not holding back anymore.

##vote TheToad

FYI, that puts us at -2

6 to hammer. Your vote is the third.

3 minutes ago, ForceGhostofNobodyInParticular said:

6 to hammer. Your vote is the third.

Its bad enough hes just planting seeds all over the place, but now hes cultivating them too!

Just now, Madaghmire said:

Its bad enough hes just planting seeds all over the place, but now hes cultivating them too!

Johnny Appleseed like? That is pretty bad. . .

Been travelling- sorry about the gap.

I'm thinking I'll hold back before jumping on the "lynch Toad" bandwagon. His arguments are getting more and more frantic as we go on...but that doesn't necessarily make him guilty.

That being said, he started accusing Truthiness of "smearing" without a lot of evidence. Unless he comes up with some good reasons to match Caldidas' case against him, that's where my vote is going.

12 minutes ago, ForceGhostofNobodyInParticular said:

Johnny Appleseed like? That is pretty bad. . .

Johnny Appleseed was an eco-terrorist and a bananaramaracist.

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

Johnny Appleseed was an eco-terrorist and a bananaramaracist.

He also hated good apples.

19 minutes ago, ForceGhostofNobodyInParticular said:

6 to hammer. Your vote is the third.

Oh yuck, we have 10 don't we? Bleh. Even numbers are bad for the town.

6 minutes ago, ForceGhostofNobodyInParticular said:

He also hated good apples.

Actually this is a common misconception after his efforts to popularize the extremely untasty "Garlic Delcious" Apple, a cross breed between a golden delicious and, well garlic. Johnny lived in a backward time and he thought all Doctors were Vampires, which is why they used all those leeches, and so he wanted to innoculate the populace against the undead scourge that had taken over the medical profession. So it wasn't so much that he hated good apples, its just he was a little crazy.

This is also where we get the phrase "an apple a day keeps the doctor away."

Just now, Madaghmire said:

Actually this is a common misconception after his efforts to popularize the extremely untasty "Garlic Delcious" Apple, a cross breed between a golden delicious and, well garlic. Johnny lived in a backward time and he thought all Doctors were Vampires, which is why they used all those leeches, and so he wanted to innoculate the populace against the undead scourge that had taken over the medical profession. So it wasn't so much that he hated good apples, its just he was a little crazy.

This is also where we get the phrase "an apple a day keeps the doctor away."

I did not know of that aspect of his life. I was referring to his method of planting and transportation, which was just to take seeds and plant them, then dig up the tree and give it to people. Since apple trees sprung from seeds can be nothing at all like the parent, the only way to consistently get good apples is grafting and careful care of the original tree. He didn't do that (dunno if it was invented yet though. . .) and so the apples he passed around, even if from seeds of great, amazing apples, were terrible.

7 minutes ago, ForceGhostofNobodyInParticular said:

I did not know of that aspect of his life. I was referring to his method of planting and transportation, which was just to take seeds and plant them, then dig up the tree and give it to people. Since apple trees sprung from seeds can be nothing at all like the parent, the only way to consistently get good apples is grafting and careful care of the original tree. He didn't do that (dunno if it was invented yet though. . .) and so the apples he passed around, even if from seeds of great, amazing apples, were terrible.

Yeah all of this stuff gets glossed over in the history books.

At least my seemingly imminent lynching has resulted in enlightenment about Johnny Appleseed

#worthit

9 minutes ago, TheToad said:

At least my seemingly imminent lynching has resulted in enlightenment about Johnny Appleseed

#worthit

1- "##" not "#"

2-Worthit is not a valid action :/

Hey @PodRacer, where do you stand? Haven't heard much from you lately.

@TheToadcan you explain why you voted Truthiness and not Madaghmire or GNIPs?

@Visovicsis there pirate day talk in this game?