10 minutes ago, Bike Stunts said:

Not much to say until the others speak up

id post up the mexican standoff at the end of reservior dogs if i thought it would help you see what your opening yourself up too

Jesus. CC is awesome, but that all out crap is exhausting. We called it at Turn 4, 5 hours after starting.

Okay, first, a point of order. You #metabros out there can suss out what exactly happened, but I am the ship's doctor. If you don't believe me, check my past posts. I've been peppering them with doctor-related phrases to try and hint and see if someone would pick up on it. I asked about the cop because I knew I could protect him, which I did, but they must have some role that goes through protection or something. Cause I totally protected ImperialCaptain2017 and he died anyway.

I believe that Bike Stunts is telling the truth. JJ to me is obviously town, as his well-reasoned argument about GNiP was what sealed his fate. That leaves PodRacer, but let's take a look at some posts. I was also told by some weird comms thing that PodRacer looked suspicious, which I was already suspicious of.

This one, to me, is vague and evasive. PodRacer isn't offering any analysis here, just avoiding the question:

On 7/20/2017 at 9:12 PM, PodRacer said:

Really enjoying it so far

#TotallyWorthIt

Saying that "Ninjas death to me suggest we are dealing with someone who knows the meta" seems to be said to throw suspicion off himself, as he called himself a noob. Additionally, Mad is someone who knows the meta and was puzzled by Ninja's death, so that tells me that perhaps the person who killed Ninja might not be super honed into the meta.

On 7/22/2017 at 5:47 AM, PodRacer said:

nope not really, but some others around here seem to have a very good read on things.

Ninjas death to me suggests we are dealing with someone who knows the meta

I believe what BikeStunts says here as it makes a lot of sense.

On 7/22/2017 at 8:21 AM, Bike Stunts said:

I think it's very likely that one of the non-voters is scum, but I don't think both of them are. So far, as I said earlier, the vague playstyle that PodRacer has adapted makes him seem real fishy, like he's trying to obscure any motive he could have. I'm going to hold off on a vote until JJ replies next though, because he's the other prime suspect.

If I'm right, and assuming there are two scum left, then at least one scum player did get in on the vote on Toad, because it would be really strange that both JJ and PodRacer, if they were both scum, would both non-vote with no communication between them. Not sure on who that could be, but Truthiness is possibly absolved, unless he's making a seriously crazy roleclaim gambit.

Here is where PodRacer calls himself a noob, which would distance himself from the CNinja kill per his earlier statement above:

On 7/22/2017 at 9:09 AM, PodRacer said:

Explain your role to a noob one more time @Truthiness , for clarity?

This post to call people who voted for GNiPs nonsense doesn't make sense, maybe a last ditch effort to save him? He didn't think it was hammertime yet.

On 7/22/2017 at 3:06 PM, PodRacer said:

asking what time someone finished work was an honest an inviting way of brinnging some of the lesser seen players from day one into the game, my reason for asking, purely timing coincidence

im not sure it is hammer is it? too many people voting for nonsence, maybe a couple for @ForceGhostofNobodyInParticular

His lamenting of scum being screwed sounds and the sudden Truthiness accusation seems to be just trying to deflect from himself, as he did with JJ about working nights or whatever. JJ reeks of town for leading the charge for lynching GNiP

On 7/22/2017 at 8:22 AM, PodRacer said:

Nice try deflecting to JJ over the length of the night. Explain yourself.

Well at first i had thought that the night had taken so long due to the time to register the kill, a player who would be say returning from work late maybe could be the reason for that.

Its more likely that realising how screwed the scum are after loosing a big player, they would use all the time available to concuct a silly long winded story.

like yours.

4 hours ago, PodRacer said:

Im a known butcher of the english language, Caldius will talk for days and leave you even more confused...

@ this point @Bike Stunts im starting to think maybe im the only town here, and you suckered me into this... **** im such a noob =)

Hey, I could be wrong, Pod. I'm happy to hear some rebuttals to these arguments if you have them.

24 minutes ago, Caldias said:

I was also told by some weird comms thing that PodRacer looked suspicious, which I was already suspicious of

what does this mean?

26 minutes ago, Caldias said:

Mad is someone who knows the meta and was puzzled by Ninja's death, so that tells me that perhaps the person who killed Ninja might not be super honed into the meta.

Madaghmire was the first scum i looked into, no result. Scum power role?

but yes your right i have thrown sh1t at most people to see what sticks, and so far we are 2 for 2

45 minutes ago, Caldias said:

He didn't think it was hammertime yet.

i know right ... and @Ginkapo told me off!! But seriously after 2.5 hours of no hammer what was i supposed to think?

29 minutes ago, PodRacer said:

Madaghmire was the first scum i looked into, no result. Scum power role?

Looked into? But didnt you claim watcher?

i meant watched. no visitors. im aware there are ways you can be immune to my spy droids tho

last night tho, caldias and jj visited the deceased, when jj logs in in a bit claiming to be the town doctor.... il be asleep

And if JJ does indeed claim to be a doctor, I'll be pretty suspicious! Right now, I don't see why he'd lead the charge against GNiP if he was scum. Even as some sort of scum gambit it doesn't much sense to me as they were already down one, and that to me seems dubious although possible, I suppose.

57 minutes ago, Caldias said:

Hey, I could be wrong, Pod. I'm happy to hear some rebuttals to these arguments if you have them.

PodRacer isn't making too many convincing arguments, imo. But I also think he's right. He mentioned you going to see the good Captain before you role revealed, and as you said, you were not able to protect him. Unless he has some unholy combination role where he's both a roleblocker and a watcher and also scum, he's probably telling the truth. JJ hasn't really done anything incriminating to this point, in my eyes, but from the evidence presented I don't think it can be anyone but him.

##voteJJs Juggernaut

On 7/21/2017 at 0:44 AM, ForceGhostofNobodyInParticular said:

I think you can drop the 'and'. It would be ridiculously daring of scum without day chat to gang up on themselves.

what about with scumchat?

the seed was planted

And I forgot to say, that if JJ turns out to be innocent, then most likely PodRacer is the scum based on my first night scan. But now I'm kind of having second thoughts, it's very possible that the last scum is someone who can't be detected. I don't want to believe that's how it is, but if it isn't JJ, I fear that that's just as likely as PodRacer being the scum

Interesting. What do @Madaghmire and @Truthiness think?

JJ jumped in somewhat late on GNips. That could be work related, or that could be a scum seeing the writing on the wall and trying to solidify his cover. Pod is acting odd, but he has little reason to fake a claim like this. Like with Imp Cap yesterday, it creates a showdown between two players. That's a terrible scum play. If he's lying, we're killing Pod tomorrow. If not, we win.

I'm gonna go get the suit ready.

##vote JJs Juggernaut

Small correction. YOU win. I'm not above gloating that I already won

I'm willing to roll with that.

##vote JJs Juggernaut

Ahh, the good ole being hammered once again before even being able to have a chance to defend myself...you guys are far too quick to hammer.

@Visovics

Hammer again I believe. @Visovics is probably asleep.

With only one possible combination, all turn towards the one man that could have done it, but he knows they know. He runs to the escape pods in a last attempt to save himself, but as he reaches it, his way in blocked by the men most affected by last night, the man who saw his friend mutilated beyond help, quicker than words came out, the vibro-blade scalpel was already through his throat, the last pirare had fallen

JJsJuggernaut was Ground Troops Commander Roni Space, pirate strongman

Observer's lounge:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qgLd5e2M1RWDo8MvtZqSBI6PI2x_pJ5xyN5Sx7I3tRs

Mafia doc:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fDOKsfMSOdpXD5o_8W-rTUaY-e2EZuJKLuWAtJXuuaE

Setup doc:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1bh9uWt_J8x7iUdSTVcJZdH-9YclaZ1acrWtWWXcu0VQ

That happened.