I don't think anything is 100%, but I fail to see someone more suspicious, other that perhaps caldias purely off the voting efforts.

After re-reading, I think I'll stick with my vote on Caldias, he is more suspicious to me than Biggs right now

What I see about Biggs is that seems odd he played so good to lynch his mate to now played so bad to lynch Truthiness. The only reason to do that is he had another mate that could finish it if he got lynched.

Caldias is too suspicious but as scum he played so bad. Something that doesn't match with the night actions. If he is so noob to defend his mate and vote wrong every time, he played well enough to "block" the fake cop to keep him alive incriminating him.

If Biggs alive is weird, Visovics alive is even more IMHO. After d1 lynching everyone agreed about both being the most probable townies. But Biggs was pointed as a possible master mind several times (CNinja, Madaghmire and even me). Visovics kept himself far from the main line and Biggs exonerated him completely as he lynching his mate was inconceivable. He was the perfect shot at n1. The doc would save the claimed cop so visovics death was a clear path for scum.

CNinja is suspicious for voting Biggs at d1 but I really think d2 lynching is a better reference. If there is just one scum left he was on that wagon (I THINK). Only in the case of two scum left I would turn over the no voters.

The same works for Broba but he was on the right wagon at day 1 so better for him. I trust those two more than any other.

I cannot say too much about smurf. Not sure if this is good or not. I would like to think is good. It seems he voted Gink by instinct but he is following the others, provably cause he feels himself too noob.

An that is the think. I would follow truthiness wagon: I won't cote myself. My vote came late and was useless (and it is me). Madaghmire is clean and dead. Between the other four, smurf seems the less plausible for me. I have hard times thinking that Madaghmire skip his kill. As a pair, Bigg+Visovics seems odd. Biggs flipping scum could point to Visovics and both are in the same train when Biggs pushed Truthiness hard enough to don't need a mate to lynch him.

I need to think a bit more.

Ok. Conclusion:

I think we have two scum left. But covering the chance of being just one I would choose between Caldias or Visovics. Biggs alone looks as he overplayed on Truthiness lynching what is too bad after the master class he gave us at d1. Caldias plays too bad days a too good nights what is plausible with a scum limited chat and a mate. By his own, the only one able to play good days and nights is Visovics.

So if we look for just the scum left I would lynch Visovics. If we look for a pair of them I would lynch Caldias or Biggs.

My heart says they are two. My mind want to cover te chance of being just one. What we do?

I think Cadilus is the way for me.....sorry fellow newbie

##vote Caldius

Totally understand, and honestly, getting rid of me is probably best, just so my confusion doesn't confound the town's efforts. I am so at a loss as to who could be the other scum player, let alone if there's two. I thought following the lead of a true-blue town player would ensure I couldn't mess anything else up, but hey, mistakes still happen. I still think Biggs is good, and probably just misread Truthiness. I'm also happy to take any pointers from you fine folks on how to play better so no more town folks end up hanging for my screw ups.

BEEP. Boop.

Interpretation:

While I'm a little concerned that we haven't heard from Biggs in 24 hours, I don't think anything has really changed with my list of suspects. I still see the probabilities right now between Caldias and Ovinomanc3r being scum as split. However the voting record leads me to vote Caldias.

##vote Caldias.

Well guys, I just hope town can still somehow pull it off after I'm gone. I wish you all the best in rooting out these scum in our camp.

8 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

BEEP. Boop.

Interpretation:

While I'm a little concerned that we haven't heard from Biggs in 24 hours, I don't think anything has really changed with my list of suspects. I still see the probabilities right now between Caldias and Ovinomanc3r being scum as split. However the voting record leads me to vote Caldias.

##vote Caldias.

Would you like to hear from Biggs but put Caldias at h-1?

Hang in there, guys, and don't weep for me, even as I hang. If we pay attention to the voting, we can still figure out who these scum are! WE CAN STILL WIN THIS!

@Caldias if you have a role with one vote to hammer now would be the time to go ahead and make it known. At this point anything in your defense you have should be public knowledge, otherwise the voting record looks like it's going to be damning.

I suppose that's true. No sense in hiding it now. I am a duelist, and I have tried to use my ability to protect Biggs once he said he was a police officer. I voted for him thinking I could use the protect ability to protect him from being lynched, having no idea that lynching is unprotectable. But then, Biggs wasn't a police officer after all. After that, I was worried Mad might kill Ovinomanc3r, so I protected him last night. I'm so sorry I've been screwing it all up. I suck so much, and have been trying my best but hoo boy was it not very good.

Beep. Whir.

Interpretation:

##Unvote

I have to consider Caldias' claim.

##unvote Calidus

Makes a valid point....I will mull this over in dreamland and make my decision in the morning.

##unvote Caldias

Seems legit, I'll analyze and look deeper in tomorrow

Wow!

Let's say he is lying. Why a claim like that? It really makes my thoughts about Madaghmire being blocked and killed by a strongman impossible. So maybe a move to defect attention. But a really good one. Too goof for someone that was so wrong during the whole game. Or Caldias is awesome pretending to be noob or he was helped but his mate cannot help him now, during the day.

Let's say what he says is true. Then Biggs didn't kill Ghost and I didn't kill Madaghmire. Of course it doesn't mean a scummate couldn't make the kill. But in this case is obvious that to be scum both need a mate so better looking for someone else. And that is the thing, as a scum move is weird the way he is reinforcing two townies instead of his own position.

It needs a careful analysis but I am done for today.

Wait! Caldias couldn't save me from Madaghmire.

Nothing could save from Madaghmire kill unless he was blocked.

So maybe Madaghmire really skip his night action.

Looks more to me that Caldias hadn't fully understood Mad's role and interactions, but seems like he is telling the truth

On 7/10/2017 at 11:46 AM, Onidsen said:

• Ginkapo - Kettch Nelson. Imperial Security Agent
• GhostofNobodyInParticular - Waitso What'midoin. Refugee Healer
• Truthiness - Madaghmire. Refugee Maintenance Technician
• Madaghmire - Long John's Sliver. Refugee Demolitions Expert

Beep. boop. Boop.

Interpretation:

I'm a little lost. I now have a few games under my belt but I have zero understanding of the game balances. If Caldias is telling the truth, we have a lot of power roles. WTF could the scum have that would balance it out?

5 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Beep. boop. Boop.

Interpretation:

I'm a little lost. I now have a few games under my belt but I have zero understanding of the game balances. If Caldias is telling the truth, we have a lot of power roles. WTF could the scum have that would balance it out?

Another duelist and demolisher? would that balance out?

OR!

Caldias is scum duelist, blocked Biggs N1 because of the fake cop

Blocked Ovi N2 because despite not knowing role, he admited to have claimed, so in fear he blocked him

just throwing thoughts out here

Come on guys, less than 6 hours to go

I'll go back to my suspicion

##vote @Caldias

@CaribbeanNinja @BiggsIRL @ovinomanc3r @SmurfWedge @BrobaFett

paging everyone for time awareness