Good learning experience, definitely.

Yeah Mood should have really gone down day 2. Lesson learned. @Madaghmire played lights out and totally deserves the win. Well done. And seriously, we probably should have conceded when Wig did his wiggle.

@GhostofNobodyInParticular how is the 12 player setup? You got me interested on it since you mentioned

23 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Y'all can kiss my imperial butt

That wasn't the intended connection, but whatever.

Also, @Madaghmire Sir Dre was not in fact named with the Dr. Dre in mind, but with the word Surgery in mind. Sir Dre = Sir Drey = Sirdrey = Surgrey = Surgery.

@Visovics , the following is my 12 players set-up:

12 Players:

1. 3 mafia:
   1. Role-blocker
   2. Bullet-proof Goon
   3. Goon
2. 4 vanilla
3. Tracker
4. PGO
5. Doc
6. Cop
7. 1-shot Day Vigilante

20 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Yeah Mood should have really gone down day 2. Lesson learned. @Madaghmire played lights out and totally deserves the win. Well done. And seriously, we probably should have conceded when Wig did his wiggle.

But I don't deserve the win? Okay, I'll do better next time....

Just now, moodswing5537 said:

But I don't deserve the win? Okay, I'll do better next time....

No, I had you...sucka

Just now, CaribbeanNinja said:

No, I had you...sucka

I will totally agree. I was dead scum walking. I'm surprised gink and Truthi didn't have a bro aneurysm during day 2.....

Total props to @Madaghmire in this win. He kept us going down the right path. Awesome play, partner.

7 minutes ago, moodswing5537 said:

Total props to @Madaghmire in this win. He kept us going down the right path. Awesome play, partner.

You caught the cop claim tho.

On 6/30/2017 at 3:31 PM, CaribbeanNinja said:

Ok, I prefaced this BS line of questioning, because, as many have stated, it'll probably lead Nowhere Special! Wakka wakka Wookiiee

Anyhow, Truth and Mood both have something in their claim that I do not. Now, it could totally be that GNIPs placed different terms in our flavor text. Or the conspiracy theorist in me gives Truth the wherewithal to change something...And it ain't punctuation...and Mood bit into the juicy trap.

I just want to point out to @GhostofNobodyInParticular and @Ginkapo that you could actually catch someone on flavor in this setup. ( MORON. - that one is typed up special just for Gink. )

The Rebels had "terrorist" in their fake flavor, and we had "rebels". I seriously had Mood on this.

What do other games do with the flavors? Do they have any? I'd be more than happy with not having any if it is not supposed to be part of the game.

2 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

I just want to point out to @GhostofNobodyInParticular and @Ginkapo that you could actually catch someone on flavor in this setup. ( MORON. - that one is typed up special just for Gink. )

The Rebels had "terrorist" in their fake flavor, and we had "rebels". I seriously had Mood on this.

What do other games do with the flavors? Do they have any? I'd be more than happy with not having any if it is not supposed to be part of the game.

mine had terrorist,truth was town and also had it

Basically in every game you have played so far, except this one, you could have just mass claimed D1 and caught scum.

As you saw in Truthi's game, we could town confirm at least three of us on the basis of knowing the role pm. Thats crappy mafia.

Knowing the wording of a role pm shouldnt be the basis of this game.

Catch people making odd moves etc. Ask Ovi to explain Mads fatal flaw in this game.

Also going forward mafia should not be allowed to talk to each other during the day phase. And Doc should not be able to self heal.

On the plus side. I am less prone to swearing at all your performances these days. That said, Onid, I dont know where you have played before, but around here you are one of the best readers of the game. For the love of Vader please speak up more!

Ah, must have been an issue cutting and pasting from the setup doc, cause only the rebels (and Ovin) have terrorist in the text there.

Still, how do other games do it?

Just now, CaribbeanNinja said:

Ah, must have been an issue cutting and pasting from the setup doc, cause only the rebels (and Ovin) have terrorist in the text there.

Still, how do other games do it?

Give mafia example town role pm's or sometimes their own fakeclaims. I played a Harry Potter one before where both Ron and Hermione were mafia fakeclaims.

1 minute ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Ah, must have been an issue cutting and pasting from the setup doc, cause only the rebels (and Ovin) have terrorist in the text there.

Still, how do other games do it?

I think they don't have a story, you are just told role and win condition

Also, I know my won't be on for at least a week, but the game I thought of may need A LOT of balancing and advice (I'm pretty sure 90% of it will change from first to final draft) so anyone that knows they won't play the week after, can I have some balancing advice?

I'll be away on holiday the week after and therefor has to work extra hard the week coming up so I'll sit out the next two games. I'd be glad to give a hand with the balance if needed.

1 hour ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

I just want to point out to @GhostofNobodyInParticular and @Ginkapo that you could actually catch someone on flavor in this setup. ( MORON. - that one is typed up special just for Gink. )

The Rebels had "terrorist" in their fake flavor, and we had "rebels". I seriously had Mood on this.

Sigh. Yeah, that was an issue with copy-pasting. I decided to change 'rebels' to 'terrorist' halfway through the writing stage. It wouldn't have been too much of an issue, I guess, had I just copy-pasted all the flavor descriptions, but the cop one was separate from the villager ones and the scum ones were free-handed based on the latest version directly into the PM, from which it was copied into the set up doc (instead of vice versa as was everything else) and which had terrorists instead of rebels. Next time (if there is one) I'll proof-read my proof-reads to ensure that all is perfect before I send out the PMs. Too many issues in this one (WigT's missing win condition being the main one).

Quite confusing game. Well played mafia. Good game after all!

I am still not sure how "I am the ******* cop" could be more clear than what I did but it was fun anyway.

16 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Quite confusing game. Well played mafia. Good game after all!

I am still not sure how "I am the ******* cop" could be more clear than what I did but it was fun anyway.

Yep. Pretty clear. We agree.

Yours I caught. I don't think anyone saw me trying to fake breadcrumb that I was a cop. I dropped "read him his rights " in one post and something else in another. It was weaksauce on my part. Glad it failed now....

1 hour ago, moodswing5537 said:

Yours I caught. I don't think anyone saw me trying to fake breadcrumb that I was a cop. I dropped "read him his rights " in one post and something else in another. It was weaksauce on my part. Glad it failed now....

I saw the "read him his rights" remark. I made an indirect reference to it in one of my early posts about Ovi. I did assign some importance to it, but I didn't follow it up.

You are right, wigs. I remember you talking about it now. I'm glad you dropped it.....lol.

12 minutes ago, moodswing5537 said:

You are right, wigs. I remember you talking about it now. I'm glad you dropped it.....lol.

Guess I'm a rebel at heart.

Signups for the next game are up now! I'll get around to tagging folks after I take care of some stuff around the house.