I'm up to running one too - though I'll get in line. We ought to get a sticky post with rules and a sign up list

Alright, I've got a setup I like. I'll start a post in the next day or so. I'll be looking for 12 preferably.

That was a filthy, ridiculous game.

17 minutes ago, Ardaedhel said:

That was a filthy, ridiculous game.

what do you mean?

2 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

what do you mean?

I mean that I loved it. Ovi is a devious manipulative bastard, and the sheer luck of offing Biggs in D1 was ridiculous.

Well... My guts were half right, and they were more right when I was more inclined to Ovi, and I was going to say, his flavour text says "things got worse" and "space oddity about to end" which sounded a lot like a metaphor, but Mad, your "don't read much into it" stopped me, damnit, well played Ovi, you had a perfect mask

And for the record black dresses are always better than white

52 minutes ago, Ardaedhel said:

I mean that I loved it. Ovi is a devious manipulative bastard, and the sheer luck of offing Biggs in D1 was ridiculous.

While this is my third mafia game, I played Diplomacy for years. It really helps cause there you are doing the same but everybody knows your actions so building plausible explanations is a must.

However I got lucky:

My role was awesome and the only thing I knew since the beginning was that I must hide it as long as I could. That was another claim to do I'd things turns bad. Point to a ninja and bring everybody to the main line. I would have need to someone else to point that but the option was always there.

CNinja tracking me.

Everybody focused on number of scum-townie rather than which powerful role we had for the 4 role case.

My problems were to hide my role, the background claim, to kill Truthiness who could be lucky and save a night. I was really worried about who CNinja was going to track. All was going so well that I was worried about not looking suspicious enough. Thanks for Visovics for being sooo townie.

Not sure if I am going to play the next one. I suspect that you are going to lynch me at D1 XD

I suggested that Mad include flavour cop so that it would come to light quicker than flavour was not a reliable indicator.

My other advice was that the game was almost balanced but the ninja would walk it. Though it would be fun.

Onid. Start sticking your neck above the parapet. You know what you are doing, so lead, especially when vanilla town.

Visovics, GNips and CNinj. You guys are improving! My advice is to stop worrying about exactly what happened and look at motives. Why did Ovi write a three post explanation that there are three mafia? Truth seemed to notice that one.

JJ, you dont want people asking for your opinion D1. If they are be a bit scummier. CNinj led you to the nightkill by constantly asking for your advice. Scum dont like trusted townies very much.

Truth. You see so much thats going on, which is why your play bothers me so. You seem to make split second decisions without ever stopping to think carefully. Yet you are picking up most of the hints! Also, no need to lead as doc, protect the role.

Norrell. Read your role properly!

Biggs. Never write a list D1. Just never.

Ovi. Similar to Truth here. Try to manipulate rather than lead with essays. No one writes essays with good intentions.

3 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Not sure if I am going to play the next one. I suspect that you are going to lynch me at D1 XD

Nah, I don't hold grudges.

I may be suspicious of your essays though. . .

Ovin,kudos. Masterfully played.

6 hours ago, Visovics said:

Well... My guts were half right, and they were more right when I was more inclined to Ovi, and I was going to say, his flavour text says "things got worse" and "space oddity about to end" which sounded a lot like a metaphor, but Mad, your "don't read much into it" stopped me, damnit, well played Ovi, you had a perfect mask

Yeah but that was specifically regarding the question you asked about yours.

Yay! I won! Go team!

Lists every Day 1. Lists forever!

On 6/14/2017 at 4:11 PM, BiggsIRL said:

Well, I'd feel bad too, except he beat me at a 2016 regional. That kind of vengeance is just the kind of smuggler I am.

He should have known that would one day come back to bite him in the butt. He should have been more vigilant.

Even if he did die the first night.

I am.

Vigilant.

Night.

You guys didn't even give me the chance to use my beautiful fake claim. Jerks.

4 minutes ago, BiggsIRL said:

Yay! I won! Go team!

Lists every Day 1. Lists forever!

I almost used your list at the end to point that Onidsen was at the top and was innocent while CNinja was not so.... But your last list put him with me and visovics I think. However it was not necessary.