Is Sabine more manuverable than Poe?

By GlenGarros, in X-Wing Squad Lists

This squad list in 3 fully gooked out ships at 100 points with 3 of the most dodgy ships in the rebel faction. I tried to diagram the manuver possibilities of Sabine's tie with this layout and realized it's better played than shown.

Sabine's tie with Sabine pilot

Push the limit, Sabine's masterpiece, engine upgrade, Kyle katarn, cloaking device

Poe dameron (ps9)

Push the limit, bb-8, seismic torpedo, black-one, pattern analyzer, autothrusters

Jake farrell

Adaptability, chardaan refit, awing test pilot, push the limit, autothrusters.

So the list comes to 100 points as stated before. But while I though Poe would be the powerhouse...which he is in his own right, I thing the edge goes to Sabine if the cloaking device holds out. The reason I say this is that when she decloaks, she gets a 2 speed decloaks move left,right, or straight ahead, then she can do a barrel roll or boost because of her pilot ability followed by the other because of push, then she reveals the dial...and looses the stress, because she revealed a green manuver of course, which procs Kyle and gives her a focus, and then fires into the backside of some unaware ship for 2 to 3 attack dice with a focus to bank on.

So what do you guys think? Anyway to make this better? Does it stand a chance against some tourniment builds? Let me know your thoughts and constructive criticisms.

1 hour ago, GlenGarros said:

So what do you guys think? Anyway to make this better? Does it stand a chance against some tourniment builds? Let me know your thoughts and constructive criticisms.

I think it should be fun.

I recommend dropping Seismic Torpedo to give Jake VI instead of Adaptability. Leave it at 99 for initiative bid.

Your biggest problem is offense. You have no heavy hitters, and not enough defense to win the attrition game. You squad will live and die by you outflying the opponent or not. Some matchups will be more vertical climb than uphill battle.

Probably shouldn't use that word in your opening sentence there OP...