Pretty sure Ard, gink, and myself are imps.

So that leaves 4 suspects. Do we know for sure how many rebels there are?

Dab says no one visited Mad

Gink says Broba visited Mad

Broba says he didnt.

I see only one feasible explanation. But first, does anyone else have any information to share?

Bad news for Broba...

@ovinomanc3r if you talk nicely to Biggs he may let you set up dead chat with Odin, Nobody and Mad

1 minute ago, Ginkapo said:

@ovinomanc3r if you talk nicely to Biggs he may let you set up dead chat with Odin, Nobody and Mad

We have it already. Thanks.

6 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

We have it already. Thanks.

We are talking so much ****.

Apparently I can see force ghosts, because I HEAR DEAD PEOPLE TALKING.

Quiet day today.

Too quiet.

3 hours ago, Tirion said:

Pretty sure Ard, gink, and myself are imps.

So that leaves 4 suspects. Do we know for sure how many rebels there are?

1-2 left. I'm inclined to think 2, but hard to say.

We got some of the pressure off when we got NIP, but not much. Currently we're at 5-2. If we lynch the wrong one today we're still at 3-2 tomorrow; if we don't lynch at all today we're at 4-2 tomorrow, but have to get the right one tomorrow or it's a draw and the Rebels will outlast us.

So that means we have to get 2 of the next three lynchings right, one way or the other.

Right now we're looking at...

Dab claims not to have seen anything at Madaghmire, then

I claim I saw two people there, but don't know who they were, then

Gink claims he saw Brob there, then

Brob claims not to have been there.

----

Brob's claim could be true in conjunction with anybody else's.

Gink's claim could be true in conjunction with mine, but not with mine or Brob's.

My claim could be true in conjunction with with Gink's or Brob's, but not Dab's.

Dab's claim could only be true in conjunction with Brob's.

----

This doesn't even address the possibility that one or more of us were deluded by some kind of Jedi mind tricks.

Hmmmm........

I wasnt there Ard. Affects your logic.

I say the two we should look at are @Ginkapo or @BrobaFett

One of them is lying.

1 hour ago, Ginkapo said:

I wasnt there Ard. Affects your logic.

Whoops, mis-typed.

1 hour ago, Ardaedhel said:

Gink's claim could be true in conjunction with mine, but not with Dab's or Brob's.

Fixed

19 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

I say the two we should look at are @Ginkapo or @BrobaFett

One of them is lying.

Or fooled.

Frankly, though, there's really no way to tell the difference right now as far as I can tell, so I think we kind of have to go with the assumption that untruth is lying, not being mistaken. Unfortunately.

I'm pretty sure there is some kind of... misdirection, or false assumption, or misunderstanding going on somewhere, but I'm not sure we have what we would need in order to draw it out.

1 hour ago, Ardaedhel said:

Or fooled.

Frankly, though, there's really no way to tell the difference right now as far as I can tell, so I think we kind of have to go with the assumption that untruth is lying, not being mistaken. Unfortunately.

I'm pretty sure there is some kind of... misdirection, or false assumption, or misunderstanding going on somewhere, but I'm not sure we have what we would need in order to draw it out.

Completely agree with this assertion. We are kind of damned if we do damned if we don't and that's due to our failure Lynch one. For what it's worth I'm not even half sold on dab being a rebel. And going back to gink's day one blunder I think he is an imp. I'm pretty confident ard you are an imp as well. So as of this moment.

## vote @BrobaFett

3 hours ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

I say the two we should look at are @Ginkapo or @BrobaFett

One of them is lying.

Do we have any way, other than trying to work through Ard's logic tree to identify who is more truthful here? Anything at all? Anything either can say or do (preferably do) to prove something one way or another?

Day 3: 7 living, 4 to lynch - 21 hours remaining

@BrobaFett (1) - Tirion
@Tirion -
@Ardaedhel -
@DabDarklighter (1) - Ardaedhel
@Ginkapo -
@GiledPallaeon (1) - Brobafett
@CaribbeanNinja -

Pretty sure the explanation is that I was redirected...

CNinja. How do you explain Dabs result if Broba is lying?

@DabDarklighter - Says he watched Mads, but didn't see anything...but Mads went boom.

@BrobaFett says he was sleeping, didn't visit anybody, but...

@Ginkapo says Broba visited Madaghmire.

(Can players have two powers?) Because if not, it would take two to pull off "blinding" Dabs and killing Mads.

Gink are you saying you think your vision of Broba was clouded? Because it definitely seems to me like Broba should go.

Roleblock Dab. Redirect Me. Rebel kill.

But that makes Ards results true which just confuses things.

Anyone want to own up to visiting Mad?

Dab has no real reason to lie as far as I can tell. If he is rebel he could just pick someone and say they made the kill. This would be a much odder play.

Broba lying is fair enough. But it doesnt explain Dabs results.

This wasnt a normal kill. Mechanics are odd. I havent figured out whats going on and Ard results are confusing me.

Ard. Should Dab have seen you?

7 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:

Ard. Should Dab have seen you?

I expected to see him, based on what I think his role is.

1 minute ago, DabDarklighter said:

I expected to see him, based on what I think his role is.

but, I'm also questioning a lot after last night...

7 hours ago, Ginkapo said:

Ard. Should Dab have seen you?

7 hours ago, DabDarklighter said:

but, I'm also questioning a lot after last night...

*Sigh*

Yes.

At least according to how I understand his claimed power.

Nothin better

# # vote Broba

Assume just Dab was roleblocked

Just now, Ginkapo said:

Nothin better

# # vote Broba

Assume just Dab was roleblocked

Dab and I would both have to have been roleblocked simultaneously.

My suspicion of @Ginkapo is growing.